No Blue without Red: Evolutionary Properties of Super-Early Galaxies

A. Ferrara, G. Rodighiero, S. Carniani, Z. Zhang, M. Kohandel, B. Das · 2026

Read No Blue without Red: Evolutionary Properties of Super-Early Galaxies by A. Ferrara, G. Rodighiero, S. Carniani, Z. Zhang, M. Kohandel, B. Das (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22914.txt.

Introduction

Ferrara and five coauthors explain the color diversity of super-early galaxies seen by JWST beyond redshift ten. In their Attenuation-Free Model, radiation-driven outflows push dust to large radii, cutting how much light it blocks. Applied to 32 confirmed galaxies, the model places them in massive halos with modest star formation rates. It proposes an evolution from a dust-hidden red phase to a UV-bright blue phase as outflows clear galactic centers.

Catalog record

CREATORA. Ferrara, G. Rodighiero, S. Carniani, Z. Zhang, M. Kohandel, B. Das
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63135
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22914

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

No Blue without Red: Evolutionary Properties of Super-Early Galaxies A. Ferrara, G. Rodighiero, S. Carniani, Z. Zhang, M. Kohandel, B. Das Abstract The discovery of numerous luminous, super-early galaxies at z > 10 z>10 by JWST has revealed a striking diversity in their ultraviolet (UV) properties, ranging from extremely blue, dust-poor systems to a smaller population of significantly reddened sources. We investigate the physical origin of this diversity within the framework of the Attenuation-Free Model (AFM), in which radiation-driven outflows redistribute dust to large galactic radii, reducing the effective attenuation. Applying the model to a sample of 32 spectroscopically confirmed super-early galaxies, we derive their key physical properties, including halo mass, star formation efficiency, metallicity, and outflow extent. We find that these systems reside in massive halos ( log ⁡ M / M ⊙ ∼ 10.7 \log M/M_{\odot}\sim 10.7 ) and exhibit moderate ( 0.01 ≲ ϵ ∗ ≲ 0.05 0.01\lesssim\epsilon_{*}\lesssim 0.05 ) star formation efficiencies, while frequently reaching super-Eddington conditions that trigger powerful outflows. Within this framework, we propose an evolutionary sequence in which galaxies transition from a dust-obscured “Red Monster” phase to a UV-bright “Blue Monster” phase as outflows clear their central regions. The recently confirmed red galaxy EGS-z11-R0 at z = 11.45 z=11.45 is naturally interpreted as a system observed during this obscured phase. Compact ( r e ≲ 150 r_{e}\lesssim 150 pc) sources are instead difficult to reconcile within AFM; we speculate that their emission is dominated by an AGN. Our results provide a unified interpretation of super-early galaxy properties and highlight the key role of radiation-driven outflows in shaping galaxy evolution at cosmic dawn. Future observations with JWST and ALMA will be essential to test these predictions and further constrain the nature of the earliest galaxies. I Introduction The first few hundred million years after the Big Bang represent a critical phase in galaxy formation, when the earliest stellar systems assembled, enriched their interstellar media with heavy elements, and contributed to cosmic reionization (for reviews see 81 ; 23 ). Since its commissioning, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has revolutionized our view of this epoch, revealing a surprisingly abundant population of luminous galaxies at z>10 , corresponding to cosmic ages \lesssim 500 Myr (e.g., 65 ; 41 ; 15 ; 10 ; 36 ; 21 ; 11 ; 64 ). A defining characteristic of the majority of these systems is their extremely blue rest-frame ultraviolet (UV) continuum slopes, often reaching \beta_{\mathrm{UV}}\lesssim-2.5 ( 62 ; 20 ; 77 ; 7 ; 27 ) . Such steep slopes are typically interpreted as evidence for young, metal-poor stellar populations with minimal dust attenuation, earning them the nickname “Blue Monsters” ( 35 ; 93 ) . The properties of Blue Monsters – including their bright UV luminosities ( M_{\mathrm{UV}}\lesssim-20 ), compact sizes ( r_{e}\approx 200 pc), and large stellar masses ( M_{\star}\approx 10^{9}\,M_{\odot} ) – have posed significant challenges to theoretical models based on pre-JWST expectations. In response, the so-called “attenuation-free model” (AFM) has been proposed ( 35 ; 93 ; 38 ; 32 ; 33 ) . According to AFM, the extreme UV brightness and blue colors of these galaxies result from extremely low dust attenuation conditions, rather than from an intrinsic lack of dust. In this scenario, dust is produced by stars in standard net amounts but is subsequently pushed to kiloparsec scales by radiation-driven outflows, dramatically reducing the UV attenuation for a fixed dust mass (since A_{V}\propto r^{-2} ). The AFM has successfully explained the shape of the UV luminosity functions at z>10 , the evolution of the cosmic star-formation rate density, and the star-formation histories of individual galaxies ( 32 ; 33 ; 29 ) . A key prediction of the AFM is that the dust-to-stellar mass ratio \xi_{d} in Blue Monsters should be comparable to that measured in somewhat lower-redshift ( z\sim 7 ) galaxies, i.e., \log\xi_{d}\sim-2 ( 31 ; 22 ; 83 ) . However, direct observational constraints from JWST/NIRSpec spectra of 15 spectroscopically confirmed z>10 galaxies instead indicate \log\xi_{d}\lesssim-4 ( 30 ) . This striking discrepancy suggests that standard dust production and destruction physics cannot reproduce the observed UV transparency of Blue Monsters. Within the AFM framework, this tension is resolved if dust is efficiently displaced from the central regions by radiation-driven outflows: while the total dust mass remains high, its redistribution to large radii significantly reduces the effective attenuation along the line of sight, yielding the observed UV transparency. While super-early galaxy simulations show the presence of strong outflows (see e.g. 46 ; 66 ), direct observational evidence for such outflows in z>10 galaxies has recently begun to emerge. Notably, deep JWST/NIRSpec observations of GS-z14-0 at z=14.18 , have revealed spatially offset CIII] \lambda\lambda 1907,1909 emission extending up to \sim 400 pc from the stellar continuum, with a luminosity three times brighter than that measured in the nuclear spectrum ( 12 ) . The lack of a corresponding feature in ultra-deep NIRCam medium-band imaging implies that the emitting gas is diffuse rather than point-like, consistent with a scenario in which carbon-enriched gas has been expelled from the galaxy by ongoing or past outflows. From the CIII] luminosity, the authors derive a mass outflow rate of \dot{M}_{\mathrm{out}}\approx 55M_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} , corresponding to a mass-loading factor of \eta=\dot{M}_{\mathrm{out}}/\mathrm{SFR}\approx 1-5.5 . This suggests that outflows are highly efficient at early times, expelling gas at rates comparable to or exceeding then SFR. Further support to the outflows scenario is provided by 87 who presented a spatially resolved stacked analysis of 287 LAEs at z>4 observed with JWST/NIRSpec prism spectroscopy. Similarly, 54 in a study dedicate to GN-z11 ( z=10.6 ) find a deep, blue-shifted CIV \lambda 1549 absorption trough, tracing an outflow with a velocity of \sim 800\ {\rm km\,s}^{-1}\, . The outflow is likely driven by radiation pressure from the combined stellar + AGN luminosity. Further indirect evidence comes from the galaxy UNCOVER-37126 at z\approx 10.25 . 55 find that this galaxy is undergoing an “ISM-naked” starburst phase, in which a strong outflow has cleared the remaining gas from its stellar core, allowing most LyC photons to escape. Together, these observations provide support for the AFM framework, demonstrating that radiatively driven outflows are already operating at the earliest cosmic epochs, efficiently clearing dust and gas from the central regions of galaxies and thereby enabling the emergence of the bright, blue systems that JWST has revealed. While the AFM provides a compelling framework for the dominant population of blue, dust-poor galaxies at z>10 , recent studies have uncovered a small but intriguing population of candidate ( 74 ; 60 ; 86 ) or spectroscopically confirmed ( 47 ; 68 ; 26 ; 75 ) high-redshift galaxies exhibiting significantly redder UV continua, i.e., \beta_{\mathrm{UV}}>-1.5 . These objects deviate markedly from the canonical M_{\mathrm{UV}} – \beta_{\mathrm{UV}} relation established at z\sim 6 – 9 and extended to z\sim 10 – 12 with JWST. Their red slopes are difficult to reconcile with simple models of chemically primitive galaxies given the short age of the Universe at these epochs ( \lesssim 400 Myr). Instead, significant dust attenuation ( A_{V}\sim 0.5 – 1 mag, 46 ) or extreme nebular continuum emission from dense, highly ionized gas have been proposed as possible

Read the complete text