The Cognitive Kardashev Scale: Quantifying the Material Envelope of Civilisational Computation

Sachin Sharma · 2026

Read The Cognitive Kardashev Scale: Quantifying the Material Envelope of Civilisational Computation by Sachin Sharma (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22840.txt.

Introduction

Sharma borrows the Kardashev ladder, which ranks civilizations by energy commanded. He asks how much machine cognition every rung could support. Only a share of total power goes to computing. Each joule buys computation at the hardware efficiency of the day. Their product caps machine thought, measured here in rough units of human brain processing rate. Set against modern supercomputers, the ceiling sits far above present use. So capacity, not energy, is the looser bound.

Catalog record

CREATORSachin Sharma
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47323
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22840

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Cognitive Kardashev Scale: Quantifying the Material Envelope of Civilisational Computation Sachin Sharma Abstract How much thinking can a civilisation do? 9 ’s typology ranks civilisations by total power: planetary (Type I, ∼ 10 16 \sim 10^{16} W), stellar (Type II, ∼ 10 26 \sim 10^{26} W), galactic (Type III). This paper builds an analogous Cognitive Kardashev Scale : how much sustained AI-grade computation each tier could support. Four ingredients enter the calculation: total power P P (watts), the share f f of it devoted to cognition, the efficiency η \eta at which energy becomes compute (operations per joule), and the brain’s own processing rate C brain C_{\text{brain}} as a reference unit. Anchoring on 2024–2026 hardware (El Capitan, NVIDIA Blackwell, Vera Rubin) gives η 2026 = 10 12 \eta_{2026}=10^{12} FLOP/J. Contemporary humanity sits at K ≈ 0.73 K\approx 0.73 , three-quarters of the way to Type I. At Type I and f = 1 % f=1\% , available compute is, within an order of magnitude, one personal AI’s worth of cognition per human inhabitant; at Type II it is essentially incomprehensible. Three trajectories for frontier compute through 2035 are reported as conditional projections, not predictions. Whether the long-run binding constraint is energy or efficiency depends on engineering choices not yet made; the political economy of who has access may matter more than either. 1 Introduction Humanity already lives inside an extended cognitive system whose energy footprint rivals that of medium-sized countries. Global data centres consumed \sim 415 TWh of electricity in 2024 and are projected to roughly double by 2030 ( 7 ) . A single frontier AI training run now draws power on the order of a small city for weeks at a time. The hardware racks executing the dominant share of this compute—NVIDIA’s Vera Rubin platform, entering volume production in 2026 at \sim 50 PFLOP/s sparse FP4 per accelerator—are being deployed inside vertically integrated, hundred-billion-dollar consortia whose announced infrastructure commitments (Stargate, Terafab) exceed those of any previous industrial buildout in human history ( 16 ; 2 ) . The question this paper asks is not whether such investments will happen—they are happening—but what cognitive capacity they could in principle support, and how that capacity scales as energy budgets grow. 9 proposed that civilisations be classified by total power consumption: Type I commands the energy striking a planet from its parent star ( \sim 10^{16} W); Type II commands the full luminosity of its star ( \sim 10^{26} W); Type III commands a galaxy ( \sim 10^{37} W). The original typology was framed as a typology for SETI, oriented toward whether a civilisation’s energy output would be detectable across interstellar distances. Carl Sagan later refined the scale to a continuous logarithmic index K=(\log_{10}P-6)/10 , which places contemporary humanity, with primary energy consumption \sim 2\times 10^{13} W in 2024 ( 6 ) , at K\approx 0.73 . By Sagan’s measure, humanity has travelled roughly three-quarters of the way from a pre-industrial baseline ( K=0 ) to commanding the full energy budget of a planet ( K=1 ). The original Kardashev scale remains an energy and detectability typology, and this paper does not modify it. I instead construct an analogous framework—which I call the Cognitive Kardashev Scale —that runs in parallel with Kardashev’s original tiers but is calibrated in computational units rather than purely energetic ones. The contribution is calibration, not a new theoretical construct: the paper reports what total sustained machine-learning-grade compute, in floating-point operations per second, each Kardashev tier could support given a defensible 2024–2026 efficiency anchor. The arithmetic is straightforward. Take the total power P a civilisation has available (measured in watts—i.e. joules per second). A civilisation does not allocate all of that to thinking; it has to grow food, run factories, move people, heat buildings. Let f be the fraction set aside for cognition. Computation costs energy, but with steadily improving efficiency: let \eta be the rate at which a system converts joules of energy into operations of compute (operations per joule). Then the available cognitive throughput is C_{\text{cog}}\;=\;f\,P\,\eta\quad\text{(operations per second)}. (1) This is the primary quantity reported throughout the paper. To make the result intuitive rather than just a large number, I also express C_{\text{cog}} in human-brain-equivalent units, dividing by C_{\text{brain}} (the brain’s own processing rate, in operations per second). The secondary quantity, N=C_{\text{cog}}/C_{\text{brain}} , is reported with explicit uncertainty: the literature on C_{\text{brain}} spans 10^{15} – 10^{17} FLOP/s depending on which neural events are counted as “operations,” so brain-equivalent counts carry at minimum \pm 1 order of magnitude of irreducible uncertainty. I use them as an interpretable comparator—a yardstick—not as a literal claim that so many FLOP/s of silicon reproduces a human mind. The cognitive-Kardashev framework and the original Kardashev scale are therefore complementary: the former indexes how much sustained ML-grade compute a given Kardashev-tier energy budget can in principle support, holding the latter’s energetic typology fixed. The paper is organised as follows. Section 2 anchors the efficiency parameter \eta in 2024–2026 hardware data, comparing six classes of workload from sustained scientific FP64 supercomputing to the Landauer thermodynamic limit. Section 3 adopts a central biological-baseline estimate. Section 4 establishes the Earth 2024–25 baseline. Section 5 computes the Type I, II, and III cognitive envelopes and presents the scale. Section 6 reports per-capita capacity under realistic fractional allocation. Section 7 presents three forward scenarios for frontier training compute and connects them to current infrastructure commitments. Section 8 discusses parameter sensitivity. Section 9 discusses what the Scale does and does not show about the political economy of cognitive compute, and Section 10 concludes. 2 Compute Efficiency in 2026 The relevant efficiencies, expressed as floating-point operations per joule of electrical input, span roughly twelve orders of magnitude from sustained scientific computing through near-term ML accelerators to the Landauer thermodynamic limit (Table 1 ; Figure 1 ). Table 1: Compute efficiency \eta in 2026, by class of workload. “Sustained” denotes top-of-list HPL benchmarks; “peak ML” denotes vendor-reported sparse Tensor Core throughput at design power. Workload class Representative system \eta (operations / J) Sustained scientific (FP64) El Capitan, LLNL (2024) 5.9\times 10^{10} Peak ML training (FP16) NVIDIA B200 sparse (2024) \sim 4\times 10^{12} Peak ML inference (FP8) NVIDIA B200 sparse (2024) \sim 2\times 10^{13} Peak ML inference (FP4) NVIDIA B200 sparse (2024) \sim 4\times 10^{13} Peak ML inference (FP4) NVIDIA R200 sparse (2026) \sim 2.5\times 10^{13} Peak ML training (NVFP4) NVIDIA R200 sparse (2026) \sim 1.8\times 10^{13} Biological brain Human cortex ( \sim 20 W) 5\times 10^{13} – 5\times 10^{15} Landauer limit (300 K) Irreversible bit-op bound \sim 3.5\times 10^{20} Figure 1: Compute efficiency \eta across workload classes, 2024–2026. Bars on a logarithmic horizontal axis. The roughly two- to three-order-of-magnitude gap between sustained scientific (FP64) and peak ML inference (FP4) reflects the move to lower-precision arithmetic; the further gap of up to two orders of magnitude between peak ML inference and the upper end of biological-brain efficiency bounds the energetic advantage that biology retains over silicon at the single-system level; and the approximately six-order-of-magnitude gap between the brain and the Landauer limit at 300 K records the headroom available to thermodynamically optimal computation. None of the values in Tables 2 – 3 approach that bound. The Landauer entry is in

Read the complete text