X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet spectra from collisions of Ar 18+ and O 8+ ions with neutrals

Stepan Dobrodey, Chintan Shah, Sonja Bernitt, Ming Feng Gu, Liyi Gu, Thomas Pfeifer, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia · 2026

Read X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet spectra from collisions of Ar 18+ and O 8+ ions with neutrals by Stepan Dobrodey, Chintan Shah, Sonja Bernitt, Ming Feng Gu, Liyi Gu, Thomas Pfeifer, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22689.txt.

Introduction

Dobrodey and others measure K shell X ray emission from charge exchange between fully ionized argon and neutral gas targets at low collision energies within an electron beam ion trap. The same trap resolves the capture quantum number in extreme ultraviolet spectra from bare and hydrogen like oxygen ions. Comparing these and earlier measurements with multichannel Landau Zener models exposes discrepancies the paper analyzes in detail. The work thus tests charge exchange theory against precision trap spectra for two highly charged ion systems.

Catalog record

CREATORStepan Dobrodey, Chintan Shah, Sonja Bernitt, Ming Feng Gu, Liyi Gu, Thomas Pfeifer, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56955
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22689

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet spectra from collisions of Ar 18+ and O 8+ ions with neutrals Stepan Dobrodey, Chintan Shah, Sonja Bernitt, Ming Feng Gu, Liyi Gu, Thomas Pfeifer, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia Abstract We present measurements of K-shell x-ray emission following charge exchange of fully ionized argon with various neutral gaseous targets at small collision energies inside an electron beam ion trap. We also resolve the principal quantum number of electron capture in extreme-ultraviolet spectra from initially bare and hydrogen-like oxygen ions held in the same trap. We analyze discrepancies between these as well as previous measurements with theoretical models based on the multichannel Landau-Zener approach. keywords atomic processes — line: formation — methods: laboratory: atomic 1 Introduction Charge exchange (CX) is a semi-resonant atomic process in which one, or several, bound electrons of a donor atom or molecule are captured by an ion during a collision. For highly charged ions (HCI), the cross sections for this process far surpass those of radiative capture of free plasma electrons. CX collisions tend to populate highly excited states having binding energies close to the one of the donor species. Those excited states subsequently decay, either by autoionizing Auger processes, by emission of one or several photons, or combinations of these pathways. In many cases, the dominant channel is single-electron capture, and quite often a single X-ray photon is observed. However, radiative cascades to the ground state are also common. Photon emission following CX is of diagnostic interest for the astrophysical community; well-known examples are the X-rays from interactions of solar-wind ions with neutrals species in the solar system, in particular around comets ( 51 ; 57 ; 50 ; 45 ) , planetary exospheres ( 43 ; 23 ; 16 ; 69 ) , and the Moon ( 71 ) . Furthermore, CX is also important in MK-hot astrophysical environments, particularly in galactic winds ( 52 ; 26 ) , and galaxy clusters ( 31 ; 33 ; 34 ; 60 ) . X-rays emitted due to CX can also provide insight into the shock physics of supernovae remnants and the element-abundance problem ( 39 ; 40 ; 20 ; 68 ) . This process also drew strong attention due to the hypothesized presence of an unidentified weak spectral feature at 3.55\,\mathrm{keV} energy in the stacked X-ray spectra from various galaxies and galaxy clusters ( 17 ; 15 ) . A small excess at that energy was attributed to the decay of a sterile neutrino ( 1 ) , a hypothetical dark matter particle, since it could not initially be assigned to any tabulated atomic lines. Soon after, 31 explained it based on expected CX processes in hot intracluster media inducing a transitions at that energy. Subsequently, a dedicated experiment by 60 showed how the predicted cluster of CX-excited transitions of hydrogen-like sulfur at 3.47(6)\,\mathrm{keV} could match the claimed X-ray excess. It is important to note that the modeling of the Ly-series transitions np\rightarrow 1s for n\leq 4 in S 15+ in the works of 17 ; 15 can shift the centroid of the excess feature enough to explain the small remaining discrepancy. Similarly, it was suggested ( 58 ) that an excess at 8.7 keV in the spectrum of the Galactic center observed by Suzaku could be caused by the decay of a 17.4-keV mass sterile neutrino. Again, this could also reasonably follow from CX by Fe 25+ ions exciting the \mathrm{Ly}\gamma line ( 70 ) . These two examples show how understanding CX in thermal plasmas is a prerequisite for reliable interpretation of weak signatures in astrophysical X-ray spectra ( 28 ) . Unfortunately, CX theory remains challenging, and several approximations are needed for modeling it. Including multi-electron capture (MEC) is particularly difficult ( 49 ) . Moreover, the scarcity of experimental data, and in particular, of state-selective observation makes benchmarking existing models difficult. Although various experiments using electron beam ion traps (EBITs) showed good agreement with predicted cross-sections for electron capture into specific principal quantum number states n , cross-section calculations for angular momentum states \ell for a given n are inconclusive ( 9 ; 70 ) . Spectra of K and L shell transitions obtained with a high-resolution X-ray microcalorimeter showed even more striking inconsistencies with the theory ( 47 ; 48 ; 11 ) , as well as with widely used astrophysical models such as SPEX-CX ( 32 ) and ACX ( 62 ) . These discrepancies could be caused by inaccurate transition energies, uncertainties in scaling equations used for estimating the n\ell -state in which the electron is captured, or inappropriate utilization of configuration mixing in the models, as explained in Refs. ( 11 ; 21 ) . It is important to note that CX also generates observable lines in the ultraviolet and optical range, as the CX-populated Rydberg levels stepwise decay through radiative cascades to the ground state. High-resolution spectroscopy at tokamaks showed the presence of strong extreme-ultraviolet (EUV) CX emission lines that are otherwise only weakly excited by direct electron impact 10 ; 46 . Thus, an investigation of EUV photons emitted through radiative cascades starting from excited states after CX could help understanding how the n\ell -states are populated. In the present work, we simultaneously measured in the X-ray and EUV wavelength ranges line emissions following CX between fully ionized Ar and O ions and various neutral targets using an electron beam ion trap. We note some striking discrepancies to previous CX measurements, as well as departures from CX models based on the multichannel Landau-Zener (MCLZ) approach, such as Kronos ( 53 ) , FAC ( 29 ) , and from X-ray spectral codes such as SPEX-CX ( 32 ) , and ACX ( 62 ) . 2 Theory A straightforward description of CX is the classical over-the-barrier (COB) method ( 59 ; 54 ) , where the combined electrostatic potential barrier of the highly charged projectile and the neutral target decreases during the mutual approach, leading to charge transfer at a certain internuclear separation. With this and other numerical methods like the classical trajectory Monte Carlo (CTMC) method ( 2 ; 56 ) , total and n -resolved cross-sections can be predicted. More complete approaches like the multichannel Landau-Zener (MCLZ) approximation ( 36 ) , atomic-orbital close-coupling (AOCC), and quantum mechanical molecular orbital close coupling (QMMOCC) ( 25 ; 61 ) also yield the fractional populations of nlS states for the captured electron. The MCLZ approach is widely used due to its comparatively low computational complexity and qualitative agreement with many experiments. Multi-electron capture, which becomes noticeable at lower collision energies typically prevalent in electron beam ion traps, is not included in most of the models. Here, we evaluate MCLZ predictions of n\ell S -resolved cross-sections for single-electron capture. The method calculates the transition probabilities between initial and final states in the collision. Already during the approach of the projectile with charge q_{1} , the neutral becomes polarized causing an attractive potential V_{i} dependent on the internuclear distance R between both partners given by V_{i}=A\exp{(-BR)}-\frac{\alpha q_{1}^{2}}{2R^{4}}, (1) where A and B are coefficients estimated in 18 and the polarization is represented by the second term with the dipole polarizability \alpha of the

Read the complete text