Position: The Pre/Post-Training Boundary Should Govern IP in Industry–Academia ML Collaborations

Dirk Bergemann, Soheil Ghili, Nitzan Mekel-Bobrov · 2026

Read Position: The Pre/Post-Training Boundary Should Govern IP in Industry–Academia ML Collaborations by Dirk Bergemann, Soheil Ghili, Nitzan Mekel-Bobrov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22632.txt.

Introduction

Bergemann and team argue firm ties fail to launch, not for science reasons. Scholars must publish while companies must protect private models, and no standard contract fixes this tension. Because legal teams alone write contracts, many legal fights are motive problems only scientists can spot. The team offers PBOS, a contract form with a single line: pretraining work is open science; posttraining work (weights trained on private data) is business IP. This line is sound, legally clean, and open to checks. The field should adopt PBOS.

Catalog record

CREATORDirk Bergemann, Soheil Ghili, Nitzan Mekel-Bobrov
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23729
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22632

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Position: The Pre/Post-Training Boundary Should Govern IP in Industry–Academia ML Collaborations Dirk Bergemann, Soheil Ghili, Nitzan Mekel-Bobrov Abstract Industry–academia ML collaborations routinely fail to launch—not for scientific reasons, but because academics must publish while companies must protect models trained on proprietary data, and no standard contract framework resolves this tension. Because contracts are negotiated by legal departments alone, many apparent legal disputes are incentive misalignment problems that only scientists at the table can correctly diagnose. We propose PBOS (Protect-the-Business / Open-Source-the-Science), a community-adoptable contract template anchored to a single technically-grounded boundary: pre-training artifacts (architectures, training code, benchmarks, untrained weights) are open science; post-training artifacts (weights trained on proprietary data) are business IP. This boundary is technically meaningful, legally clean, and auditable—and could not have been drawn correctly without scientists at the negotiating table. We argue the ML community should adopt PBOS as its default contract for such collaborations. 1 Introduction The complementarity between industry and academia in machine learning is obvious. Companies accumulate proprietary datasets—transaction logs, user behavior, negotiation transcripts—at a scale and richness that no university lab can replicate. Universities produce the algorithmic ideas, the graduate talent, and the publication record that companies depend on to attract that talent and advance the science. On paper, the incentives to collaborate are overwhelming. In practice, they are not enough. In the spring of 2024, a university research team set out to build an AI negotiator that could learn to bargain on a major peer-to-peer marketplace. The company had millions of real negotiation transcripts; the researchers had the methods and the people to study them. Together, they could advance both the science of strategic AI and the company’s product. Yet before the research could begin, the collaboration was delayed for months in contract negotiations. Lawyers exchanged successive document drafts across dozens of versions. The central question was not about money, access, or scientific scope—it was about where to draw the line between what could be published and what had to stay proprietary. That question had no standard answer, because the ML community has never agreed on one. This is not an isolated case. The friction between academic publication norms and corporate IP protection is a structural feature of the landscape, not a series of unlucky negotiations. Academics must publish to advance their careers; companies must protect the models trained on their data to preserve their competitive advantage. Neither side is acting irrationally. What is missing is a shared contract framework that tells both sides where the line is before the lawyers start drafting. The absence of such a framework has a second, less obvious consequence: because contracts are negotiated solely between legal departments, the technical structure of the collaboration is invisible to the people writing the terms. Many apparent legal disputes in this setting are not really legal problems--- they are incentive misalignment problems in disguise. Correctly diagnosing them requires knowing what the scientists are building: which artifacts reveal proprietary information and which do not, which outputs the company legitimately needs to control and which the academic legitimately needs to release. Lawyers alone cannot answer these questions. Scientists must be at the table. 1 1 1 The collaboration described above produced the contract framework studied in this paper precisely because researchers participated directly in contract negotiation, proposing specific language around what constitutes “The Science” (Section 3 ). We propose PBOS (Protect-the-Business / Open-Source-the-Science) as a community-standard contract template for ML collaborations involving proprietary data, anchored to a single technically-grounded boundary: pre-training artifacts---architectures, training code, benchmarks, and untrained weights---are open science and must be releasable; post-training artifacts---weights trained on proprietary data---are business IP and remain under exclusive commercial control, with academics retaining only a narrow research license to use them for evaluation and publication. 2 2 2 The PBOS contract template, clause pack, and implementation guidance are available at https://github.com/soheil23/pbos-contract . This paper is available at https://sites.google.com/view/soheil-ghili/pbos . The pre/post-training boundary is technically meaningful (trained weights encode proprietary data; untrained artifacts do not), legally clean (ownership of each artifact class is unambiguous), and practically auditable (transfer logs and repository records make it straightforward to verify what left corporate infrastructure). Crucially, it is a boundary that could not have been drawn correctly without ML researchers at the negotiating table—it is a technical claim, not a legal one. We further argue that the process of cross-disciplinary contract negotiation, historically rare because scientists lacked fluency in legal language, is now becoming scalable. AI tools allow researchers to engage with contract language substantively without becoming lawyers. Scientific proposals need not be legally perfect to be influential: even partial engagement shifts negotiations toward incentive alignment and away from protracted contract revision cycles. The rest of the paper is structured as follows. Section 2 characterizes the structural incentive misalignment underlying collaboration failure. Section 3 presents the PBOS framework in detail. Section 4 discusses why PBOS aligns incentives, its community precedents, the boundary questions the framework must handle, and why researcher participation in contract negotiation is a technical necessity. Section 5 concludes with a call to action. 2 The Problem: Structural Incentive Misalignment Industry–academia ML collaborations fail not because the parties disagree about science, but because their institutional incentives are misaligned in a predictable way. Each side has requirements that the other’s institutional constraints make difficult to accommodate. 2.1 The Nature of the Incentive Mis-alignment Academic researchers require the ability to publish: to describe their methodology, report their results, and release artifacts sufficient for replication. Publication determines career advancement, grant eligibility, and scientific reputation. A collaboration that ends without a publishable paper, or that produces one only after stripping out the empirical contributions, fails on the academic’s core requirement. Companies that provide proprietary data for model training require control over the resulting artifacts. A model trained on proprietary data encodes patterns derived from that data; if the trained weights leave corporate infrastructure, or if a publication reveals sufficient detail to permit reconstruction, the company’s competitive position is weakened. Companies therefore require exclusive control over any artifact that has absorbed their data. These two requirements are not inherently incompatible, but they conflict in the absence of a shared framework for distinguishing which artifacts belong to science and which belong to the business. Without such a framework, each collaboration must resolve this question independently, incurring the associated transaction costs each time. 2.2 The Consequences of the Mis-Alignment The consequences of the coordination failure are not confined to the transaction costs of individual negotiations. When a class of problems is systematically inaccessible to academic researchers, the corresponding research literatures do not form. Problems that require proprietary behavioral data at scale—learning from real-world negotiations, modeling large-scale user dynamics, training agents on production logs—remain outside the academic research frontier, regardless of their scientific importance. As industry develops products and methods in these domains, the divergence between the applied frontier and the academic research frontier widens over time. The cost to companies is the foregone contribution of external research capacity. Academic collaborators identify failure modes, propose architectural improvements, and produce peer-reviewed results that internal teams cannot generate independently. When collaboration fails to form, companies bear this cost in addition to the direct costs of extended contract negotiations. The aggregate effect is a market failure in scientific

Read the complete text