Towards precision cosmology with Void × \times CMB correlations (II)
Mar Pérez Sar, Carlos Hernández Monteagudo, András Kovács, Alice Pisani, Yun Wang · 2026
Read Towards precision cosmology with Void × \times CMB correlations (II) by Mar Pérez Sar, Carlos Hernández Monteagudo, András Kovács, Alice Pisani, Yun Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22630.txt.
Introduction
Pérez Sar and others test how void crossed with cosmic microwave background lensing signals respond to method choices, using Roman mock catalogues. They find the signal less sensitive to mock construction than galaxy or void statistics, so future tensions are unlikely to stem from mock errors alone. The best signal to noise comes from two dimensional voids with rescaled profiles. Forecasts reach about 13 sigma for two dimensional and 8 sigma for three dimensional voids with Planck, rising to about 31 sigma and 18 sigma with a CMB-S4 like survey.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mar Pérez Sar, Carlos Hernández Monteagudo, András Kovács, Alice Pisani, Yun Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81879 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22630
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards precision cosmology with Void × \times CMB correlations (II) Mar Pérez Sar, Carlos Hernández Monteagudo, András Kovács, Alice Pisani, Yun Wang Abstract Gravitational lensing by large-scale structure imprints secondary anisotropies on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) that can be exploited to probe cosmology. In particular, cosmic voids produce a characteristic lensing signature detectable through Void × \times CMB cross-correlations. This signal has been robustly measured in the past but its cosmological constraining power remains limited by the incomplete knowledge of how methodological choices affect its measurement and by its uncertain dependence on cosmological parameters. Using a set of validated Roman mock catalogs, we first quantify how mock construction impacts the measured signal and then forecast the capabilities of Roman , in combination with current and upcoming CMB surveys such as Planck , SO and CMB-S4-like experiments. We analyze the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) for different void definitions (2D and 3D), stacking approaches (rescaled versus non-rescaled profiles), CMB map filtering schemes and noise levels. In contrast to galaxy and void statistics, we find that the Void × \times CMB lensing signal is less sensitive to the choice of mock catalog, indicating that future tensions with data are unlikely to stem from mock inaccuracies alone. The highest S/N is achieved for 2D voids with rescaled profiles. We forecast S/N ≈ \approx 13 σ \sigma (8 σ \sigma ) for 2D (3D) Roman voids combined with Planck , increasing to 22 σ \sigma (13 σ \sigma ) for SO and 31 σ \sigma (18 σ \sigma ) for CMB-S4-like surveys. For comparison, current Planck -based measurements reach S/N ≈ \approx 17 σ \sigma for 3D DESI Legacy Survey LRG voids and 5.9 σ \sigma for 2D DES Year 3 voids, both covering substantially larger areas than Roman ( ∼ \sim 2000 deg 2 ). While the cosmological dependence of this observable remains to be quantified, Roman together with next-generation of LSS and CMB surveys opens a path toward the first direct cosmological constraints from Void × \times CMB lensing. Impact of mock catalogs on the Void \times CMB lensing signal. 1 Introduction Figure 1 : Review of prior work on Void \times CMB lensing cross-correlations. The figure presents the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) achieved and the value of the parameter \rm A_{\kappa} which quantifies the agreement between the observed signal and cosmological simulations. Unfilled circles denote results from 2D voids and filled circles from 3D voids. A ‘T’ symbol inside a point indicates a tension with theoretical expectations for some configuration. In 1978, the same year the Nobel Committee for Physics recognized the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) as the first compelling evidence for the Big Bang model ( 53 ; 54 ; 8 ; 9 ; 103 ) , two independent studies ( 77 ; 59 ) reported the first observational hints of cosmic voids, starting to uncover the ”cellular pattern” now identified as the cosmic web within the large-scale structure (LSS). Nearly fifty years later, the CMB and LSS have become the two foundational pillars of modern cosmology and constitute unique probes to test the dynamics and contents of our Universe through its cosmic history ( 42 ; 102 ) . The cosmological information within the CMB is primarily encoded in its angular anisotropies—tiny fluctuations at the level of \sim 10^{-5}\penalty\ \mathrm{K} superimposed on the uniform background of the most perfect blackbody ever measured ( T_{\mathrm{CMB}}=2.72548\pm 0.00057\penalty\ \mathrm{K} , 122 ; 17 ). The anisotropies represent the seeds that would later grow into the cosmic web and are classified into two types: primary and secondary anisotropies. Primary anisotropies originate at the surface of last scattering ( z\sim 1100 ) and reflect the physical processes at play in the early Universe, mainly the oscillation of the photon–baryon plasma in the evolving dark matter potential wells and the Thomson scattering keeping both components bound until recombination. Secondary anisotropies arise from interactions of the resultant CMB photons with the intervening large-scale structures through gravitational and scattering processes. Gravitational effects includes lensing, i.e, the deflection of CMB photons due to spatially varying gravitational potentials ( 89 ) and the Integrated Sachs–Wolfe (ISW) effect, i.e, the change of CMB photon energies due to time-varying gravitational potentials ( 116 ) . Scattering effects originate from interactions of the CMB photons with the baryonic matter of the LSS, including the kinetic and thermal Sunyaev–Zel’dovich effects (kSZ and tSZ, respectively) ( 127 ; 128 ) , Rayleigh scattering by neutral hydrogen ( 14 ; 90 ) , and fine-structure transitions in metals and ions ( 14 ; 71 ; 69 ) . Precision mapping of these anisotropies by COBE ( 122 ) , WMAP ( 18 ; 124 ) , and Planck ( 106 ; 107 ; 108 ) has enabled constraints at percent level on key cosmological parameters—including the baryonic and dark matter physical densities, and the amplitude and slope of the primordial power spectrum. Ground-based telescopes like the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT, 37 ; 120 ) and the South Pole Telescope (SPT, 126 ; 138 ) have refined these measurements and upcoming ones such as the Simons Observatory (SO, 5 ) promise even higher accuracy. At late times, the three-dimensional distribution of galaxies also carries cosmological information about the initial conditions of the Universe and its later evolution. Through the galaxy–halo connection, galaxies trace the underlying matter field with a certain bias, outlining the filamentary structure of the cosmic web. In this context, the study of cosmic voids has evolved significantly since their initial discovery. Thanks to their underdense nature, voids are less affected by the complex, non-linear processes that dominate overdense regions, making them particularly clean environments for probing cosmic expansion and dark energy ( 21 ; 22 ; 105 ; 109 ) , the properties of dark matter ( 113 ; 12 ; 10 ) , modified theories of gravity ( 25 ; 13 ; 29 ) and the presence of massive neutrinos ( 92 ; 86 ; 15 ) . Their quiet interiors also shelter some of the most isolated galaxies, making them powerful laboratories for studying how environment shapes galaxy formation and evolution ( 19 ; 85 ; 61 ) . The primary void observables are the void size function ( 121 ; 52 ; 76 ; 105 ; 115 ; 34 ; 33 ; 132 ; 131 ; 130 ; 49 ) and the void-galaxy cross-correlation function (with its distortions in redshift space) ( 79 ; 7 ; 88 ; 64 ; 93 ; 11 ; 35 ; 63 ; 110 ; 39 ) , which currently provide the tightest and most mature constraints from underdense regions. Historically, cosmic voids have been treated as a byproduct of galaxy surveys and investigated mainly in wide-area datasets such as SDSS ( 139 ; 1 ) , VIPERS ( 60 ) , Pan-STARRS ( 78 ) , BOSS ( 38 ) , and DES ( 50 ; 36 ; 3 ) . Because of the multiscale nature of voids, which span tens to hundreds of megaparsecs, the ideal void survey would benefit from the combination of: large contiguous sky coverage to capture the rare, cosmologically sensitive large voids; dense galaxy sampling to resolve small-scale structures within voids;