Conditional Enhancement of Radical Pair Dynamics via Chiral State Preparation

Tristen Gwynn, Betony Adams, Francesco Petruccione · 2026

Read Conditional Enhancement of Radical Pair Dynamics via Chiral State Preparation by Tristen Gwynn, Betony Adams, Francesco Petruccione (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22130.txt.

Introduction

Gwynn and co-authors test whether chiral-induced spin selectivity can enhance radical pair dynamics across a broad parameter space. The effect lifts magnetic sensitivity in radical pair models under specific Hamiltonian conditions, but wider persistence was untested. They model the effect as a spin-dependent starting state and recombination operator for a model radical pair. Gains in the single-nucleus model are largely suppressed by a second nucleus, except where tensor misalignment drives a robust antisymmetric response. Sustaining it thus needs highly ordered, rigid molecular geometries.

Catalog record

CREATORTristen Gwynn, Betony Adams, Francesco Petruccione
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56776
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22130

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Conditional Enhancement of Radical Pair Dynamics via Chiral State Preparation Tristen Gwynn, Betony Adams, Francesco Petruccione Abstract Chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) has been shown to enhance magnetic sensitivity in radical pair mechanism (RPM) models under specific Hamiltonian conditions, yet whether these enhancements persist across a broader parameter space remains untested. We incorporate the CISS effect as a spin-dependent initial state and recombination operator and systematically evaluate the spin dynamics of a model radical pair across a comprehensive parameter sweep of the RPM Hamiltonian. We characterise the orientational response through symmetric and antisymmetric decomposition of the yield distribution under field reversal, providing a direct quantitative signature of CISS-induced symmetry breaking. Our analysis demonstrates that CISS does not function as a generic amplifier of magnetic sensitivity. Claimed enhancements are conditional on the relative alignment of the internal hyperfine and dipolar interaction axes, arising specifically under conditions of non-collinear internal interactions. Extension to a two-nucleus model confirms that these enhancements are sensitive to nuclear spin. CISS-induced effects observed in the single-nucleus model are substantially suppressed when a second collinear nucleus is introduced, with the exception of the hyperfine axis rotation sweep where non-collinear tensor misalignment drives a robust antisymmetric response. These findings indicate that the conditions for CISS-enhanced magnetoreception are more stringent than previously demonstrated, requiring highly ordered and rigid molecular geometries to sustain the effect. I Introduction The interaction between photo-excited electron radical pairs and environmental magnetic fields is widely proposed as the light-dependent mechanism underlying magnetoreception in avian photo-sensitive proteins 27 ; 17 . Within this framework, Zeeman coupling with the Earth’s magnetic field, together with exchange, dipolar, and hyperfine couplings, governs the spin dynamics that determine spin-selective reaction pathways, forming the basis of the radical pair mechanism (RPM) 21 . Theoretical studies on the orientational properties of the RPM have demonstrated strong magnetic dependencies and ‘quantum needle’ precision, consistent with experimental observations 3 ; 16 ; 26 . Since these reactions occur within chiral protein environments, an additional spin selectivity may arise from molecular chirality 23 ; 4 . The chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect describes the preferential transmission of electron spins through chiral structures 2 ; 25 , with spin selectivity intrinsically linked to spatial handedness rather than chemical composition 24 ; 9 . While theoretical descriptions commonly invoke spin–orbit coupling in chiral potentials, the microscopic origin of CISS remains an open question 4 ; 7 ; 9 ; 11 ; 33 . The introduction of a spin-selective process into the spin-sensitive RPM has motivated considerable interest 22 ; 31 . Incorporating CISS into RPM models has been shown to enhance quantum coherence and magnetic sensitivity under certain conditions 10 ; 31 ; 32 , a finding further supported by recent direct spectroscopic evidence of CISS in radical-pair systems 20 . However, these enhancements are typically demonstrated for specific, isolated Hamiltonian parameter choices. Given that the magnetic response is highly sensitive to the interplay of internal interactions, it remains unclear whether CISS constitutes a robust, universal amplifier of magnetic sensitivity or whether its efficacy is bounded by strict structural constraints. In this work, we address this question by systematically exploring the RPM Hamiltonian across physically relevant parameter ranges to characterise the conditions under which CISS-induced enhancement arises. To isolate the impact of spin selectivity without committing to a specific microscopic origin, we adopt the kinetic model of Luo and Hore 22 , treating CISS as a kinetic filter on the initial spin composition rather than a modification of the Hamiltonian dynamics. Section II details the radical pair model, the Lindblad master equation framework, and the shelving state approach used to extract asymptotic reaction yields. Section III presents a systematic evaluation of each internal interaction across the relevant parameter space, characterising how each modulates the orientational anisotropy and spatial symmetry of the reaction yields under chiral and non-chiral initial conditions. Section IV contextualises these findings within the broader framework of biological magnetoreception and examines the structural and dynamical conditions under which CISS may play a functional role. II Model and Methods In the absence of CISS, radical pairs are typically formed in the singlet state due to spin conservation and Pauli exclusion 17 , \ket{\psi_S}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{\alpha_D \beta_A}-\ket{\beta_D \alpha_A}), (1) where \alpha and \beta denote spin-up and spin-down states, and D and A label the donor and acceptor sites. Within the Luo–Hore framework, CISS is incorporated as a spin-selective constraint on the electron transfer process, such that forward transfer and recombination favour opposite spin orientations 22 . This modifies the initially prepared spin state to, \ket{\psi_I}=\cos{(\chi/2)}\ket{\psi_S}+\sin{(\chi/2)}\ket{\psi_{T_0}}, (2) where the mixing angle \chi\in[0,\pi/2] parametrises the strength of spin selectivity, and the triplet component \ket{\psi_{T_0}} is defined as, \ket{\psi_{T_0}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{\alpha_D \beta_A}+\ket{\beta_D \alpha_A}). (3) The corresponding chiral recombination state is, \ket{\psi_R}=\cos{(\chi/2)}\ket{\psi_S}-\sin{(\chi/2)}\ket{\psi_{T_0}}, (4) ensuring the same parameter \chi governs both state preparation and recombination. In this study, we contrast the limits of zero chirality ( \chi=0 ) and maximal CISS-induced triplet mixing ( \chi=\pi/2 ). These two-electron states of D and A form the basis of the radical pair. However, in order to consider the spin evolution of the system we need to include the spin states of the nuclei. The initial density matrix is then constructed by averaging over all nuclear spin configurations, \rho_{0}=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i}\ket{\psi_{I,i}}\bra{\psi_{I,i}}, (5) where N is the nuclear multiplicity corresponding to a thermal initial state. The initial density matrix evolves under the total Hamiltonian 8 , \hat{H}_{\text{Tot}}=\hat{H}_{\text{Z}}+\hat{H}_{\text{hf}}+\hat{H}_{\text{dip}}+\hat{H}_{\text{ex}}, (6) where the Zeeman Hamiltonian is given by, \hat{H}_{\text{Z}}=-\gamma_{e}\mathbf{B}\cdot(\hat{\mathbf{S}}_{D}+\hat{\mathbf{S}}_{A}), (7) where \gamma_{e} is the gyromagnetic ratio of the electron, \hat{\mathbf{S}}_{i} are the spin operators of the donor and acceptor electrons and the external magnetic field \mathbf{B} can be expanded as, \mathbf{B}(B_{0},\theta_{\text{Z}},\phi_{\text{Z}})=B_{0}(\sin\theta_{\text{Z}}\cos\phi_{\text{Z}},\sin\theta_{\text{Z}}\sin\phi_{\text{Z}},\cos\theta_{\text{Z}}), (8) where B_{0} is the field strength and \theta_{\text{Z}} and \phi_{\text{Z}} are the spherical coordinates of the magnetic field direction, illustrated by Fig. 1 . The hyperfine Hamiltonian is expressed as, \hat{H}_{\text{hf}}=\sum_{i\in D,A}\sum_{k}\hat{\mathbf{S}}_{i}\cdot\mathbf{A}_{ik}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{I}}_{ik}, (9) where \hat{\mathbf{I}}_{ik} denotes the k -th nuclear spin operator associated with radical i . The hyperfine interaction tensor \mathbf{A}_{ik} is decomposed as \mathbf{A}=a_{0}\mathbbm{1}+\mathbf{T}, (10) where the isotropic Fermi contact term a_{0} is given by 21 , a_{0}=\frac{2\mu_{0}\gamma_{e}\gamma_{\text{N}}}{3}|{\psi(0)}|^{2}, (11) where \mu_{0} is the permeability of free space, \gamma_{e,N} are the the electron and nuclear gyromagnetic ratios and |{\psi(0)}|^{2} denotes the non-zero spin density at the nucleus. The anisotropic tensor \mathbf{T} represents the electron-nuclear dipolar interaction expressed by, T_{kj}(\mathbf{r_{i}})=\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}\frac{\gamma_{e}\gamma_{\text{N}}}{r_{i}^{3}}(\delta_{kj}-3n_{k}n_{j}), (12) where r_{i} represents the distance between the nucleus and the centre of the electron spin density, and n_{k},n_{j} are the components of the unit vector \mathbf{n} directed along r_{i} 5 . The principal axis of the hyperfine tensor \mathbf{A} is oriented at polar angle \theta_{\text{hf}} and azimuthal angle \phi_{\text{hf}} relative to the reference molecular z -axis, which coincides with both the dipolar principal axis and the CISS polarisation direction. In this study, \phi_{\text{hf}}=0 is fixed, confining the hyperfine rotation to the xz -plane, and \theta_{\text{hf}} is swept to evaluate the dependence of CISS-induced enhancement on axial alignment. The electron–electron dipolar interaction Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{\text{dip}} is described by, \hat{H}_{\text{dip}}=\hat{\mathbf{S}}_{D}\cdot\mathbf{D}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{S}}_{A}, (13) with the tensor \mathbf{D} receiving the same treatment as the anisotropic hyperfine tensor, D_{kj}(r_{DA})=\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}\frac{\gamma_{e}^{2}}{r_{DA}^{3}}(\delta_{kj}-3n_{k}n_{j}), (14) where r_{DA} represents the distance between the radicals. The axial dipolar parameter D_{0} is defined as 8 ; 21 , D_{0}=-\frac{3}{2}\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}\frac{\gamma_{e}^{2}}{r_{DA}^{3}}. (15) Aligning the inter-radical vector with the z -axis of

Read the complete text