MAcNLOPS for Z ​ Z ZZ Pair Production at the LHC

Yuxiao Che, Rikkert Frederix · 2026

Read MAcNLOPS for Z ​ Z ZZ Pair Production at the LHC by Yuxiao Che, Rikkert Frederix (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22108.txt.

Introduction

Yuxiao Che and Rikkert Frederix present MAcNLOPS matching for ZZ pair production at the Large Hadron Collider, in a MadGraph5_aMC@NLO plus Pythia8 setup. From a standard MC@NLO event sample, negative H events are removed and compensated by a veto on the first shower emission of S events. Validation against MC@NLO for radiation-sensitive and diboson observables shows agreement except for a small power-suppressed part at very low transverse momentum. The method removes all negative H weights at negligible extra cost, leaving negative S weights unchanged.

Catalog record

CREATORYuxiao Che, Rikkert Frederix
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27008
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22108

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

MAcNLOPS for Z ​ Z ZZ Pair Production at the LHC Yuxiao Che, Rikkert Frederix Abstract We present an implementation of the MAcNLOPS matching prescription for p ​ p → Z ​ Z pp\rightarrow ZZ production in a MadGraph5_aMC@NLO + Pythia8 setup. Starting from a standard MC@NLO event sample, negative ℍ \mathbb{H} events are removed and compensated by a veto applied to the first shower emission of the 𝕊 \mathbb{S} events. The implementation is validated against MC@NLO for radiation-sensitive and inclusive diboson observables. Agreement is found up to a rather small power-suppressed contribution affecting the very low- p T p_{T} region. The method removes all negative ℍ \mathbb{H} weights with negligible additional computational cost, while negative 𝕊 \mathbb{S} weights are left unchanged, showing that MAcNLOPS is a promising alternative to MC@NLO with a reduced fraction of negative weights. 1 Introduction Precision predictions for LHC observables are based on event generators that combine fixed-order perturbative accuracy with fully exclusive final states. In this context, NLO+PS matching is a baseline requirement for phenomenological studies and experimental analyses. The matching procedure must preserve the NLO accuracy of inclusive observables, describe the first hard QCD emission reliably, and at the same time remain compatible with the logarithmic structure, recoil prescription and event structure of the parton shower. These requirements are not independent, and different matching schemes realise the compromise between fixed-order accuracy, shower control and event-generation efficiency in different ways. A canonical formulation of this problem is provided by the MC@NLO method [ 1 ] . Its central idea is to subtract from the real-emission matrix element the approximation already generated by the shower, and to add the corresponding integrated contribution to the Born-like event sample. This gives NLO-accurate predictions while leaving the subsequent shower evolution to the parton-shower program. The price paid for this generality is the appearance of events with negative weights. Negative weights do not invalidate the calculation: they are a consequence of the local cancellation structure of the matched cross section. They are, however, undesirable in practice. They reduce the statistical power of event samples, increase the number of generated events needed for a given precision, and complicate the use of simulated samples in experimental analyses. Several approaches have been proposed to address this problem. In the POWHEG method [ 2 , 3 ] , the hardest emission is generated with a positive Sudakov formulation based on the real matrix element. This largely avoids the negative-weight problem and has been highly successful phenomenologically, but it also changes the division of labour between the NLO calculation and the parton shower: the first emission is generated by the matching framework rather than by the shower itself. This distinction can be relevant when one wants to preserve, as much as possible, the logarithmic structure and recoil strategy of a given shower. Other methods, such as KrkNLO [ 4 ] , also aim at positive-weight event samples, but are less straightforward to apply as fully general matching prescriptions. Within the MC@NLO framework itself, a detailed analysis of the origin of negative weights led to the MC@NLO- \Delta prescription [ 5 ] . This method modifies the MC@NLO matching formula by introducing a Sudakov-like factor \Delta in the \mathbb{H} contribution, together with a compensating term in the \mathbb{S} contribution. The factor is constructed from shower no-emission probabilities and suppresses \mathbb{H} events in regions where the parton shower gives an efficient description of the radiation. This reduces the negative \mathbb{H} -event component while preserving the NLO expansion and the hard-emission behaviour of the matched result. Consequently, MC@NLO- \Delta can significantly improve the event-generation efficiency, but it does not remove the negative-weight problem altogether. The MAcNLOPS method [ 6 ] provides a different route. It can be viewed as a minimal modification of the MC@NLO construction in which the regions where the shower approximation exceeds the real matrix element are treated multiplicatively, while the remaining regions retain an additive structure. In this way, the negative \mathbb{H} -event contribution of MC@NLO is removed and compensated by a veto procedure applied after the first shower emission. The method therefore keeps a key practical advantage of MC@NLO, namely that the first emission is still generated by the shower, while addressing one of its main efficiency limitations. In the implementation studied here, the focus is on this minimal MAcNLOPS mechanism and, in particular, on the removal of negative \mathbb{H} weights. Possible negative \mathbb{S} weights are a separate issue and are not eliminated by the procedure considered in this work. More recently, the ESME framework, “Exponentiated Subtraction for Matching Events”, was introduced [ 7 ] . Like MAcNLOPS, it aims at positive-weight NLO+PS matching while retaining a close connection to the parton shower, but it addresses the problem more broadly by exponentiating the subtraction contribution associated with the NLO normalisation and treating it through an event-by-event accept–reject procedure. In this sense, ESME is conceptually more comprehensive than the minimal MAcNLOPS construction studied here. The aim of this paper is to present a first implementation of this MAcNLOPS prescription for pp\rightarrow ZZ production, using MadGraph5_aMC@NLO ( MG5_aMC ) [ 8 ] interfaced to Pythia8 [ 9 ] , and to validate it against standard MC@NLO. The pp\rightarrow ZZ process is a useful first application. Its Born-level final state is colour singlet, which avoids the additional complications associated with final-state QCD radiation from coloured particles, while being less trivial than a 2\to 1 colour-singlet process. It therefore offers a controlled but meaningful environment in which to study the practical behaviour of MAcNLOPS. We compare the two approaches for radiation-sensitive and inclusive observables, both after the first shower emission and after the subsequent shower evolution. Particular attention is paid to the low-emission region, where the compensation of removed negative \mathbb{H} events is most delicate. This paper is organised as follows. In Sects. 2 and 3 , we review the formulation of MAcNLOPS and describe the implementation strategy used in this work. We present numerical results and compare them to standard MC@NLO in Sect. 4 and conclude in Sect. 5 . 2 MAcNLOPS We first review the form of the MAcNLOPS matching formula and then describe how it is implemented in the present calculation. Throughout this section, the formulae are written for a single real-emission sector. Sums over flavours, FKS sectors and parton luminosities are suppressed in the notation, but are included in the implementation. We assume a factorisation of the real-emission phase space, d\Phi=d\Phi_{B}\,d\Phi_{R}, (1) where \Phi_{B} denotes the underlying Born phase space and \Phi_{R} the radiation variables. In MC@NLO matching [ 1 ] , the hard-event generation can be written in terms of two event classes. The \mathbb{S} events have Born kinematics, while the \mathbb{H} events have real-emission kinematics, schematically, \displaystyle\mathcal{F}^{(\mathbb{S})}(\Phi_{B}) \displaystyle=\mathcal{B}(\Phi_{B})+\mathcal{V}(\Phi_{B})+\int\mathcal{K}(\Phi_{B},\Phi_{R})\,d\Phi_{R}\equiv\widetilde{\mathcal{B}}(\Phi_{B}), (2) \displaystyle\mathcal{F}^{(\mathbb{H})}(\Phi) \displaystyle=\mathcal{R}(\Phi)-\mathcal{K}(\Phi). (3) Here \mathcal{B} , \mathcal{V} and \mathcal{R} denote the Born, virtual and real-emission contributions, respectively. The quantity \mathcal{K} is the Monte Carlo counterterm, i.e., the shower approximation to the real-emission matrix element in the corresponding singular region. It removes the part of the real-emission contribution that would otherwise be generated again by the parton shower. The origin of negative \mathbb{H} weights is apparent from Eq. ( 3 ). Whenever the shower approximation locally exceeds the real matrix element, \mathcal{K}(\Phi)>\mathcal{R}(\Phi)

Read the complete text