Knowledge Graph Re-engineering Along the Ontological Continuum (Extended version)
Enrico Daga, Valentina Tamma, Terry R. Payne · 2026
Read Knowledge Graph Re-engineering Along the Ontological Continuum (Extended version) by Enrico Daga, Valentina Tamma, Terry R. Payne (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-22093.txt.
Introduction
Enrico Daga, Valentina Tamma, and Terry Payne reshape knowledge graphs along the ontological continuum. Knowledge graphs drive data integration and AI, but varied modeling styles, from lightweight vocabularies to rich ontologies, make merging and reuse expensive and brittle. That challenge is acute for neuro-symbolic AI, where bridging neural and symbolic parts depends on reshaping graphs to fit new requirements. The authors ground their vision in a provenance case study, showing one concern manifesting differently across the continuum, and they articulate five open challenges as a shared agenda.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Enrico Daga, Valentina Tamma, Terry R. Payne |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51774 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.22093
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Knowledge Graph Re-engineering Along the Ontological Continuum (Extended version) Enrico Daga, Valentina Tamma, Terry R. Payne Abstract Knowledge graphs have become the primary vehicle for data integration and are critical to the success of modern AI — but the diversity of KG modelling practices, from lightweight vocabularies to richly axiomatised ontologies, makes integration and reuse expensive and brittle. This challenge is particularly acute in neuro-symbolic AI, where bridging neural and symbolic components depends on the ability to re-engineer KGs to fit new requirements; GenAI now offers unprecedented automation capability, but without a principled understanding of the KG engineering space, such automation remains conceptually ungrounded. We introduce the ontological continuum as that missing conceptualisation, a theoretical construct whose characterisation framework is defined by two orthogonal distinctions: semantics ↔ \leftrightarrow pragmatics, and properties ↔ \leftrightarrow affordances, allowing to describe, compare, navigate, and potentially transform KGs across the full range of modelling practices. The methodological stance is empirical: rather than prescribing how KGs should be designed and built, the continuum aims to define a theory of the existent, derived from observation of real-world KG engineering practices and whose structure can be made formally explicit, for example, through Formal Concept Analysis (FCA). We ground the vision through a case study on provenance knowledge, showing how a single concern manifests differently across the continuum. We articulate five open research challenges and invite the community to develop the ontological continuum as a shared research agenda. 1 Introduction Knowledge graphs have become critical for data integration across scientific, governmental, and commercial domains. The diversity of KG modelling practices, ranging from lightweight vocabularies (e.g. Schema.org, Dublin Core) to richly axiomatised ontologies (e.g. Gene Ontology, SNOMED CT), reflects the breadth of problems and communities they serve. This diversity is an asset rather than a weakness: different communities 1 1 1 A community is a group of agents (human actors or organisations) with shared practices, expertise, and tasks: who uses the knowledge and how. and tasks genuinely require different representational choices, thus creating a rich and varied KG ecosystem. The cost of this diversity, however, is restricted reuse. Adapting KG content across communities and tasks, e.g. repurposing a provenance model built for scientific workflows in an open data portal, integrating a statistical dataset with a CIDOC-CRM-based knowledge base, reusing ontological fragments defined under one foundational ontology in a setting grounded in a different one, remains expensive, brittle, and poorly understood. On the one hand, neuro-symbolic methods bring novel tasks, which require the adaptation of existing KGs. On the other hand, large language models offer the unprecedented capability to automate KG engineering at scale [ 16 ] . However, without a principled map of the space they are navigating, such automation remains conceptually ungrounded. Emerging work on autonomous knowledge engineering agents [ 16 ] (systems that decompose, plan, and execute re-engineering decisions with minimal human intervention) makes this gap particularly acute: an agent navigating the KG ecosystem without a principled framework is forced to treat it as a black box, with no basis for choosing transformations, estimating their cost, or explaining its choices. The dominant response to KG diversity has been structural harmonisation: thirty years of ontology mapping, aligning, and merging [ 35 ] , with evaluation cultures that consistently reward full coverage over task-relevant partial alignment [ 35 , 25 ] . Yet cross-KG reuse remains expensive and brittle in practice, and the premise deserves scrutiny. We pose that the right question is not “how similar is KG 1 to KG 2 ?” but rather: “does KG 1 afford what community C needs for task T ? And if not, what would it take, and at what cost, to get there?” These are questions that structural harmonisation cannot answer and that current quality metrics do not even pose. We reframe reuse as a transformation problem : given a source KG and a community with a task, what sequence of principled steps leads to a target that affords what is needed? Answering this question requires not a mapping technique but a map of the problem space itself. What is missing is a principled account of how diverse KG modelling practices interplay, to integrate both the semantic side , i.e. the domain meanings a KG encodes, and the pragmatic side , i.e. what a KG affords for which task. We propose the ontological continuum as that missing conceptualisation. The contribution of this paper is conceptual and terminological . We define the ontological continuum : a characterisation framework, organised around two orthogonal distinctions, semantics versus pragmatics , and properties versus affordances , that provides a vocabulary for describing, comparing, navigating, and potentially transforming KGs across the full range of modelling practices. We ground the vision through a case study on provenance knowledge, showing how a single concern manifests differently across the continuum and how the structure of those positions can be made explicit and formally ordered through Formal Concept Analysis (FCA) [ 15 , 34 ] . We articulate five open research challenges and discuss their implications. The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 surveys related work. Section 3 introduces the ontological continuum: first as a theoretical construct (Section 3.1), then as a characterisation framework (Section 3.2), and finally as an empirically-derived discrete projection (Section 3.3). Section 4 presents the provenance case study. Section 5 discusses implications. Section 6 articulates open research challenges. Section 7 concludes. Details on the case studies, including tables and diagrams of the FCA, are provided in the appendices. 2 Background and Related Work The KG ecosystem spans from lightweight vocabularies (e.g. Dublin Core [ 11 ] , Schema.org [ 20 ] ) to richly axiomatised ontologies (e.g. Gene Ontology [ 8 ] , SNOMED CT [ 7 ] ) and this diversity is both healthy and necessary: different communities have developed different formalisms, governance practices, and modelling methodologies, each fit for its own purpose. Yet diversity comes at a cost, and this is often not fully acknowledged. Knowledge and ontology engineering methodologies such as NeOn [ 41 ] , LOT [ 36 ] , and MOMO [ 40 ] provide principled guidance for ontology construction, but assume a one-size-fits-all approach; reuse practices remain poorly understood and underspecified. This diversity runs deeper than formalisms: foundational ontology choices, BFO [ 32 ] , DOLCE [ 3 ] , UFO [ 21 ] , create incompatibilities at the level of the conceptual model with real downstream consequences. Antipatterns defined within a UFO-based validation framework cannot be straightforwardly applied in a DOLCE-based setting; bridging them requires explicit mappings, operationalised as SPARQL and SHACL, a form of ad hoc pragmatic adaptation for which currently there is no principled support [ 38 , 30 ] . The standard response to heterogeneity has been harmonisation: mapping languages (R2RML [ 10 ] ), ontology alignment systems (LogMap [ 37 ] , AML [ 13 ] ), and modularisation techniques [ 27 ] operationalise integration but fall short of addressing diversity in a unified methodology. Ontology alignment systems take full ontologies as input and are evaluated against complete reference alignments [ 35 ] , and evaluation metrics reward full coverage even if fit-for-purpose reuse requires only the task-relevant fragment. Pay-as-you-go engineering approaches [ 39 ] and