Lost in the Prefix: Revisiting IP Geolocation Accuracy Across Networks and Geographies
Syed Tauhidun Nabi, Jocelyn Bliton, Tijay Chung, Shaddi Hasan · 2026
Read Lost in the Prefix: Revisiting IP Geolocation Accuracy Across Networks and Geographies by Syed Tauhidun Nabi, Jocelyn Bliton, Tijay Chung, Shaddi Hasan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21937.txt.
Introduction
Syed Tauhidun Nabi and co-authors evaluate four major IP geolocation providers against reference data from RIPE Atlas and UNICEF Giga across 175 countries. Mobile networks show median errors more than 10 times higher than fixed networks, and Global South geographies fare far worse than Europe. Both gaps trace to prefix granularity. Provider prefixes in mobile networks and the Global South are more likely coarser than BGP announcements, and about 70 percent of mobile prefixes span over 100 km. Coarser prefixes consistently yield the highest errors, for any provider, network type, or region.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Syed Tauhidun Nabi, Jocelyn Bliton, Tijay Chung, Shaddi Hasan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34595 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21937
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lost in the Prefix: Revisiting IP Geolocation Accuracy Across Networks and Geographies Syed Tauhidun Nabi, Jocelyn Bliton, Tijay Chung, Shaddi Hasan Abstract IP geolocation databases are widely used in research, policy, and industry, yet their accuracy across network types and geographies remains poorly characterized. We present a large scale evaluation of four major providers (MaxMind GeoLite2, IPinfo, IP2Location, and DB-IP) using ground truth from RIPE Atlas and UNICEF Giga across 175 countries. We find that mobile networks exhibit median errors more than 10 times higher than fixed networks across all providers (179–207 km vs. 3–16 km), and that Global South regions show significantly higher failure rates than Global North: Asia exceeds 53–61% and Africa 66–72%, compared to 9–20% in Europe. We trace both gaps to a shared structural source: provider prefixes in mobile networks and Global South geographies are more likely to be coarser than BGP announcements, and approximately 70% of mobile prefixes span more than 100 km geographically. Our findings point to prefix granularity as a common explanatory factor: coarser prefixes consistently produce the highest errors regardless of provider, network type, or geography. 1 Introduction IP geolocation databases map IP addresses to physical locations and are widely used across research, industry, and policy. Measurement platforms, researchers, and policy makers use them to associate performance data with geographic communities and identify underserved populations [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 23 ] . Content delivery networks use them for traffic steering and latency optimization [ 20 ] , and advertising platforms use them for geographic targeting [ 3 ] . Despite this pervasive use, the accuracy of these databases outside the conditions under which they have historically been evaluated remains poorly understood. Prior evaluations [ 20 , 23 , 5 ] have documented meaningful errors in IP geolocation, but their ground truth is drawn predominantly from fixed broadband networks in North America and Europe. This leaves two significant blind spots. First, mobile networks, where subscribers’ IP addresses are assigned by carrier-grade NAT infrastructure [ 21 ] that may aggregate traffic across large geographic regions, have received little systematic attention. Second, the Global South, where mobile connectivity is often the primary access medium and where IP address allocation practices may differ substantially from wealthier regions, is nearly absent from existing benchmarks. Whether current databases are accurate enough to support the research, policy, and operational decisions that depend on them in these contexts is an open question. We address this gap with a large scale measurement study of four major IP geolocation providers: MaxMind GeoLite2 [ 15 ] , IPinfo [ 9 ] , IP2Location [ 8 ] , and DB-IP [ 4 ] . We evaluate accuracy against ground truth drawn from two complementary sources. RIPE Atlas [ 22 ] provides our primary instrument, offering stable, well-characterized vantage points that are dense in North America and Europe but span multiple continents, predominantly on fixed networks. UNICEF Giga school connectivity measurements [ 25 , 26 ] augment our dataset with coverage of the Global South and mobile networks that RIPE Atlas alone cannot provide at scale; to our knowledge, this is the first use of the Giga dataset as a ground truth instrument for IP geolocation evaluation, introducing it as a new resource for the network measurement community. Together, our ground truth comprises 37,302 observations spanning 175 countries collected over a one-month window, with explicit coverage of mobile, fixed, and satellite access network types. We address two research questions: • RQ1: How does IP geolocation accuracy vary across access network types? • RQ2: How does IP geolocation accuracy vary across geographies at global scale? Our analysis reveals consistent and large accuracy gaps along both dimensions. Mobile networks exhibit median errors an order of magnitude higher than fixed networks, with all four providers failing at similar rates on mobile, pointing to a common rather than provider-specific cause. Global South regions show significantly higher failure rates than Global North across all providers and all continents. We trace both gaps to a shared structural source: provider prefixes in mobile networks and Global South geographies are substantially coarser than BGP announcements, and approximately 70% of mobile prefixes span more than 100 km geographically. This paper makes the following contributions. First, we present the first large scale evaluation of IP geolocation accuracy across both fixed and mobile networks and Global South geographies, using 37,302 georeferenced observations spanning 175 countries. Second, we introduce the UNICEF Giga [ 25 ] school connectivity measurements as a new ground truth resource for evaluating geolocation accuracy, providing coverage of mobile networks and the Global South absent from prior benchmarks. Finally, we show that BGP prefix granularity is a consistent explanatory factor for the Global South accuracy gap, and a contributing factor for the mobile accuracy gap, supported by within-prefix geographic spread analysis and BGP prefix size comparisons across all geolocation providers. 2 Datasets and Methodology 2.1 Ground Truth Dataset We construct ground truth from two complementary sources. RIPE Atlas [ 22 ] provides our primary instrument, comprising 10,294 IPv4 and 5,716 IPv6 probe records collected on March 23, 2026, filtered to probes with operator-reported coordinates, stable IP addresses over the preceding 30 days, and excluding IPs appearing at multiple probes to remove potential NAT or VPN addresses (323 rows removed, 16,010 retained across 10,561 unique probes). RIPE Atlas probes are dense in North America and Europe, and only approximately 1% carry a mobile network tag, limiting mobile network coverage in our ground truth. We note that a small fraction (1.5%) of RIPE Atlas probes misreport their geolocation, with violations disproportionately concentrated in low-coverage regions such as southern Africa [ 11 ] ; we treat probe-reported coordinates as ground truth with this caveat. UNICEF Giga school connectivity measurements augment our dataset with Global South and mobile network coverage that RIPE Atlas cannot provide at scale [ 25 , 26 ] . Giga runs NDT7 speed tests [ 16 ] from GPS-reported school locations across 33 countries. We apply four sequential filters: (1) a one-month measurement window (February 15 to March 15, 2026); (2) removal of measurements where school GPS coordinates are missing; (3) deduplication to unique (IP, school) pairs, and (4) exclusion of IPs appearing at more than one school within the one-month measurement window, a conservative heuristic to identify NAT/CGNAT addresses where the same IP serves multiple geographic locations. The filtered Giga dataset comprises 21,292 unique (IP, school) pairs across 4,872 schools in 27 countries. Combined with RIPE Atlas, our ground truth totals 37,302 observations spanning 175 countries, of which 74.7% are IPv4 and 25.3% are IPv6. IP Reuse and Unit of Analysis. We treat individual observations as our unit of analysis, where each observation is defined as a unique (IP address, vantage point) pair. For RIPE Atlas, each observation corresponds to a single connected probe with a stable IPv4 or IPv6 address and operator-reported coordinates. For Giga, each observation corresponds to one unique (IP, school) pair within the measurement window. IP reuse in Giga takes two forms: a single school observed with multiple IPs over time, consistent with DHCP reassignment at a fixed location; and a single IP observed at multiple schools, consistent with NAT, CGNAT, or VPN infrastructure aggregating traffic