Defect Kinematics in 2D Nematics: Contributions from Surface Topology, Intrinsic and Extrinsic Geometry, Solitons, Defect Orientations, and Elastic Anisotropy
Joseph Pollard, Richard G. Morris · 2026
Read Defect Kinematics in 2D Nematics: Contributions from Surface Topology, Intrinsic and Extrinsic Geometry, Solitons, Defect Orientations, and Elastic Anisotropy by Joseph Pollard, Richard G. Morris (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21855.txt.
Introduction
Joseph Pollard and Richard Morris study the particlelike kinematics of charge-carrying topological defects in nematic media through a field theory. Unlike electromagnetism, it lacks gauge invariance, so its free-energy rules face constraints a gauge-invariant theory would ignore. Hodge theory captures these as harmonic excitations, joining defect orientations and topological solitons. Energy shifts that add non-linear terms to the Euler-Lagrange equations produce defect effects beyond pairs despite abelian U-one symmetry, seen in non-zero extrinsic curvature and elastic anisotropy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph Pollard, Richard G. Morris |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 111077 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21855
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Defect Kinematics in 2D Nematics: Contributions from Surface Topology, Intrinsic and Extrinsic Geometry, Solitons, Defect Orientations, and Elastic Anisotropy Joseph Pollard, Richard G. Morris Abstract We characterise the particlelike kinematics of charge-carrying topological defects in nematic media via a geometric field theory. This differs from the theory of electromagnetism, with which it is often compared, due to the absence of gauge-invariance. In both approaches, basic defect interactions are governed by a propagator, which depends upon the global topology and/or intrinsic geometry of the surface. For nematic materials, however, the minimisation of the free energy is sensitive to constraints that a gauge invariant theory would otherwise be indifferent to. Hodge theory is used to capture these as ‘harmonic’ excitations, unifying two factors known to additionally affect the kinematics of defects in nematics: relative defect orientations and topological solitons. Perturbations to the form of the energy are also permitted in nematic materials due to gauge non invariance. Those that introduce non-linearities in the corresponding Euler–Lagrange equations are shown to result in defect interactions that go beyond pairwise despite the otherwise abelian nature of the underlying U ( 1 ) U(1) symmetry. We show how this type of induced many-body effect manifests in the cases of non-zero extrinsic curvature and/or elastic anisotropy. I Introduction The close analogy between nematic materials and electromagnetism is exemplified by the fact that topological defects in two-dimensional nematics interact logarithmically via a pairwise, Coulomb force. This correspondence motivates ‘particlelike’ descriptions of nematic media that centre on the kinematics of charge-carrying topological defects—so-called Coulomb gases Bowick et al. 2022 . Such an approach has been applied in the context of both active and passive liquid crystals deGennes and Prost 2013 ; Vromans and Giomi 2016 ; Tang and Selinger 2017 ; Angheluta et al. 2021 ; Schimming 2025 ; Romano et al. 2023 ; Romano et al. 2024 and the XY-model Kosterlitz and Thouless 1973 ; Vitelli and Turner 2004 ; Vitelli and Nelson 2004 ; Turner et al. 2010 , as well as in related models more broadly Mermin 1979 . Despite this apparent duality, however, nematic materials are not equivalent to electromagnetism in 2D. The difference relates to how the otherwise shared U(1) symmetry manifests in each case. In electromagnetism, such a symmetry underpins a (Yang-Mills) gauge field theory, where the energy is invariant under generic gauge transformations valued in the group U(1) . In nematic materials, however, the Frank free energy is manifestly not invariant under such a transformation, resulting in a so-called geometric field theory where quantities that would be irrelevant in electromagnetism play an important role. Here, we construct a geometric field theory for nematic media in two-dimensions using the modern language of differential forms and exterior calculus. As part of this, we highlight the topological nature of the decomposition of the nematic field that comes from the Hodge theorem Hodge 1989 . Broadly, this says that a nematic field extremising the energy is generated by three contributions: topologically-nontrivial fields that encode defect winding; a different kind of topologically-nontrivial field that encodes solitons, and; topologically-trivial fields that encode transient geometric features, such as defect orientation, which are not conserved by the dynamics but still play a role in the defect-defect interaction. The possibility of including the latter two parts is where the physics of nematic materials deviate strongly from electromagentism: in a gauge invariant theory, these contributions can be removed by gauge transformations and thus are non-physical, and do not manifest in the energy. Via explicit calculations, our approach leads to two broad contributions. First, the geometry-centric framework provides a clarifying perspective on many of the effects that have been reported in the literature so far Vitelli and Turner 2004 ; Vitelli and Nelson 2004 ; Turner et al. 2010 ; Vromans and Giomi 2016 ; Tang and Selinger 2017 ; Čopar and Kos 2024 ; Schimming 2025 . Capturing the pairwise interactions between defects via a propagator, or Green’s function, we describe how such interactions are modified by surface topology due to the existence of non-trivial cycles, as well as intrinsic geometry, due to altered geodesic distances Vitelli and Turner 2004 ; Vitelli and Nelson 2004 ; Turner et al. 2010 . This corresponds to the first type of field described above, and is therefore analogous to the theory of electromagnetism. There is also an additional affect due to intrinsic geometry—not strictly related to the aforementioned decomposition—with defects experiencing an effective potential whose leading-order contribution is proportional to Gaussian curvature Vitelli and Turner 2004 ; Vitelli and Nelson 2004 ; Turner et al. 2010 . The other two types of ‘extra’ field in the Hodge decomposition do not play a role in gauge-invariant theories such as electromagnetism. They exert forces on defects without modifying the propagator. Topological solitons Schimming 2025 are shown to give rise to such a field, which does not impact defect interactions but can lead to defect nucleation. Further contributions are shown to result from the relative orientations between defects Vromans and Giomi 2016 ; Tang and Selinger 2017 ; Pearce et al. 2021 ; Čopar and Kos 2024 ; we clarify how such orientational effects manifest on a curved surface, in contrast to previous work that has focussed on flat surfaces. Second, the approach also makes transparent a further consequence of geometric field theory: because the energy functional is not required to be gauge invariant, various types of perturbation are allowed that would otherwise be forbidden. Of particular interest are those that render the corresponding Euler–Lagrange equations nonlinear. These perturbations, we show, generically result in many-body interactions, going beyond the purely pairwise interactions that occur in the linear systems. This subverts expectations based on naive analogy with electromagentism, since linearity would otherwise be demanded by gauge-invariance under an abelian Lie algebra, such as that trivially generated by U(1) . Extrinsic curvature and elastic anisotropy are both shown to be examples of this effect. The paper is organised as follows. We begin in Section II with the broad concepts. This includes a brief introduction to the ideas of abelian geometric field theory and how this relates to other approaches to defect dynamics, such as that attributed to Halperin and Mazenko Liu and Mazenko 1992 ; Mazenko and Wickham 1998 ; Mazenko 1999 ; Angheluta et al. 2021 ; Schimming and Viñals 2022 ; Schimming and Viñals 2023 ; Schimming 2025 . We also explain, at a high level, the Hodge decomposition Hodge 1989 , and describe how it implies three classes of fields, as described above, as well as how it endows the energy with a topological structure. We go on to give a generic summary of perturbations to the energy that give rise to nonlinearities in the Euler–Lagrange equations. In the remainder of the paper we focus in detail on the four classes of effects shown in Fig. 1 . In Section III , we calculate how certain features lead to modifications to the first of the Hodge fields, and hence the propagator. These are the global topology of the surface and its intrinsic curvature. The geometric potential arising from intrinsic curvature is then discussed in Section IV . We go on to describe, in Section V ,