Causal Discovery in Structural VAR Models Under Equal Noise Variance

SeyedSina Seyedi HasanAbadi, Fahimeh Arab, Erfan Nozari, AmirEmad Ghassami · 2026

Read Causal Discovery in Structural VAR Models Under Equal Noise Variance by SeyedSina Seyedi HasanAbadi, Fahimeh Arab, Erfan Nozari, AmirEmad Ghassami (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21846.txt.

Introduction

SeyedSina Seyedi HasanAbadi and coauthors study causal discovery in linear Gaussian structural VAR models under equal noise variance. Causal effects may span time and intervals, a point for neuroscience, where sampling is coarse. Unlike the DAG equal-variance case, time-series data do not find a unique causal graph, since several parameterizations can give the same law. The authors define observational equivalence and describe its class by orthogonal transformations plus a global positive scale. They propose ENVAR, a sparsity-based search of that class for a sparse representative.

Catalog record

CREATORSeyedSina Seyedi HasanAbadi, Fahimeh Arab, Erfan Nozari, AmirEmad Ghassami
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76713
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21846

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Causal Discovery in Structural VAR Models Under Equal Noise Variance SeyedSina Seyedi HasanAbadi, Fahimeh Arab, Erfan Nozari, AmirEmad Ghassami Abstract Causal discovery from multivariate time series is challenging when causal effects may occur both across time and within the same sampling interval. This issue is especially important in applications such as neuroscience, where the sampling rate may be coarse relative to the underlying dynamics and contemporaneous effects need not form an acyclic graph. We study causal discovery in linear Gaussian structural VAR models under an equal noise variance assumption, meaning that the structural noise terms have a common variance. Unlike the DAG-based cross-sectional equal noise variance setting, the time-series setting considered here does not generally yield point identification of a unique causal graph. Instead, multiple structural VAR parameterizations can induce the same stationary observed process law. We introduce a notion of observational equivalence tailored to this setting and show that the corresponding equivalence class is characterized by orthogonal transformations of the structural equations together with a global positive scale. This characterization leads to an equivalence-aware model discrepancy, the observational alignment discrepancy, which compares structural models modulo transformations that preserve the observed law. Building on this theory, we propose ENVAR , a sparsity-based procedure that searches over the induced observational equivalence class for a sparse normalized structural representative. We evaluate the proposed methodology on synthetic structural VAR data and on an fMRI dataset. Keywords: Causal Discovery; Structural VAR Model; Contemporaneous Effects; Equal Noise Variance 1 Introduction Causal discovery from multivariate time series is central in applications in which interventions are expensive, slow, or ethically constrained. In functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), for example, one often observes simultaneous activity traces from many brain regions or sensors and wishes to infer which regions influence which other regions. Linear vector autoregressive (VAR) models and their structural variants are particularly powerful for answering such questions ( 15 ) , and Granger-causal methods remain widely used in neuroscience and neuroimaging ( 8 ; 7 ; 23 ) . At the same time, fMRI data create a particular difficulty: the sampling interval is often too coarse relative to the timescale of latent neural dynamics ( \sim 1s vs. \sim 10ms) ( 9 ) , and a purely lagged model can therefore misattribute within-bin interactions to lagged predictive effects. This motivates structural time-series models with both lagged and contemporaneous effects. We study causal discovery in structural VAR models under an equal noise variance assumption, meaning that the structural noise vector is centered and has covariance equal to a common scalar multiple of the identity matrix. The equal noise variance assumption was introduced as an identifying restriction for cross-sectional linear Gaussian structural equation models by 17 and was further studied by 4 . It is especially natural when all observed variables are measured in the same physical domain and on a comparable scale. In neuroimaging, this situation arises, for example, for region-level fMRI time series, especially after standard preprocessing and normalization steps. Given the same, effective-connectivity models are routinely formulated in the fMRI literature as dynamical systems driven by homogeneous stochastic fluctuations ( 5 ; 25 ; 19 ) . The setting considered here differs substantially from the cross-sectional structural equation model under equal noise variance of 17 . In their setting, the graph is a directed acyclic graph (DAG), acyclicity provides a causal ordering, and the equal noise variance assumption yields point identification of the causal DAG from the observational Gaussian distribution. In the context of algorithm design for fMRI, however, the assumption of acyclicity is in great contrast with the highly cyclic nature of brain networks. Furthermore, in time-series data with contemporaneous effects, this point identification generally fails: multiple different graph structures can perfectly produce the exact same observed data distribution. Because point identification is generally unavailable, the correct target is not a single structural graph, but an observational equivalence class. Therefore, we need a careful notion of equivalence that captures exactly the information available from the observational time series. Hence, any method that distinguishes between two observationally equivalent structures must be using assumptions beyond the observed distribution. In this paper, we characterize the resulting observational equivalence class for structural VAR models under equal noise variance. We show that observationally equivalent models are related by an orthogonal transformation of the structural equations together with a global positive scale. This characterization also motivates an equivalence-aware model discrepancy, which we call the observational alignment discrepancy . Unlike raw Frobenius error between structural matrices, the observational alignment discrepancy assigns zero error to different representatives of the same observational law. Thus it is the appropriate notion of model-level error for both theory and simulations in this setting. Our main contributions are as follows. • We formulate causal discovery in structural VAR(1) models under an equal noise variance assumption, allowing both lagged effects and contemporaneous effects that are not assumed to form a DAG. • We introduce the relevant notion of observational equivalence for this setting and prove an exact characterization of the corresponding equivalence class. • We introduce the observational alignment discrepancy as an equivalence-aware error measure for comparing structural VAR models under equal noise variance. • We propose a sparsity-based estimator that searches over the observational equivalence class for a sparse normalized representative. We refer to the resulting procedure as ENVAR , short for Equal-Noise VAR causal discovery. Related work. Several lines of work address causal discovery from time series. Granger causality and reduced-form VAR methods orient effects by temporal precedence but do not, by themselves, identify contemporaneous structure ( 8 ; 11 ; 23 ) . Structural VAR methods in econometrics recover instantaneous effects only after adding identifying restrictions such as recursive orderings, sign restrictions, heteroskedasticity, or non-Gaussianity ( 24 ; 13 ; 10 ) . TiMINo and related functional-model approaches use restrictions such as additive noise or independent residual processes to obtain identifiability in nonlinear time-series models ( 18 ) . Constraint-based methods such as PCMCI and PCMCI+ learn lagged and, in later variants, contemporaneous relations under conditional-independence assumptions ( 20 ; 21 ; 1 ) ; SVAR-FCI handles latent confounding in time series but returns partial graphical information rather than a fully parameterized structural VAR ( 12 ) . Score-based dynamic Bayesian-network methods such as DYNOTEARS estimate contemporaneous and lagged edges but impose an acyclicity constraint on the contemporaneous layer ( 16 ) . A broader survey of causal discovery methods for time series is given by 2 . 2 Model Description 2.1 Structural VAR Model Under Equal Noise Variance Let X_{t}=(X_{1t},\ldots,X_{pt})^{\top}\in\mathbb{R}^{p} denote the vector of observed variables at time t . We consider the linear Gaussian structural VAR(1) model X_{t}=A_{0}X_{t}+A_{1}X_{t-1}+e_{t},\qquad e_{t}\overset{\mathrm{i.i.d.}}{\sim}\mathcal{N}(0,\sigma^{2}I_{p}),\qquad\sigma>0. (1) Here A_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{p\times p} is the contemporaneous effect matrix and A_{1}\in\mathbb{R}^{p\times p} is the lag-one effect matrix. The assumption \operatorname{Cov}(e_{t})=\sigma^{2}I_{p} is the equal noise variance assumption. It means that the structural noise terms are mutually independent and have a common variance. This assumption concerns the structural noise vector e_{t} , not the marginal variances of the observed variables X_{t} and not the covariance matrix of the reduced-form residuals. We are specifically interested in models that satisfy the normalization requirement \operatorname{diag}(A_{0})=0 . Equivalently, if B=I-A_{0} , then \operatorname{diag}(B)=\mathbf{1} . This convention rules out instantaneous self effects

Read the complete text