Strategic Inertia and Institutional Change: A Behavioral Model of Price Reforms versus Action Deletion
Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Mohammadali Berahman, Hasti Eshaghi · 2026
Read Strategic Inertia and Institutional Change: A Behavioral Model of Price Reforms versus Action Deletion by Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Mohammadali Berahman, Hasti Eshaghi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21647.txt.
Introduction
Madjid Eshaghi Gordji and co-authors model why weak practices, technologies, or institutions linger even when superior options are known. They introduce a quantal response equilibrium with status-quo bias, where each player pays a fixed switching cost for leaving the default action. In a binary coordination game they compare two reforms: a tax on the default action versus deleting the default action entirely. A threshold tax exists: below it the status quo persists, above it transition occurs, independent of bounded rationality, while deletion always forces the superior outcome.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Mohammadali Berahman, Hasti Eshaghi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26422 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21647
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Strategic Inertia and Institutional Change: A Behavioral Model of Price Reforms versus Action Deletion Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Mohammadali Berahman, Hasti Eshaghi Abstract Why do inefficient practices, technologies, or institutions persist even when superior alternatives are available? This paper introduces a quantal response equilibrium with status-quo bias (QRE-SB) in which each player incurs a fixed switching cost when deviating from an inherited default action. In a binary coordination game, we compare two policy interventions: a tax on the default action (price-only reform) versus deleting the default action entirely (ban). We prove that there exists a threshold tax below which the status quo persists and above which a transition occurs; notably, this threshold does not depend on the degree of bounded rationality. Deleting the default action always forces play to the superior equilibrium, irrespective of switching costs or rationality. Moreover, when the superior equilibrium is Pareto-dominant, deletion yields strictly higher expected welfare than any finite tax that leaves the old action feasible. Numerical simulations illustrate the theoretical predictions. The framework provides a formal foundation for the policy principle that sometimes you must ban, not just tax, with direct applications to climate policy, social media regulation, and international sanctions. 1 Faculty of Mathematics, Statistics and Computer Science, Semnan University, Semnan, Iran [email protected] [email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran [email protected] Keywords: Bounded rationality, quantal response, switching costs, status quo bias, institutional change, action deletion. AMS Classification: 91A26, 91A40, 91B06, 91B18. 1 Introduction Why do inefficient practices, technologies, or institutions persist even when superior alternatives are available? Economists have long recognized that coordination failures and path dependence can lock in suboptimal outcomes [ 7 , 3 , 16 ] . More recently, behavioral economists have documented that individuals exhibit a systematic status quo bias: they disproportionately stick with inherited choices, even when switching would improve their welfare [ 18 , 12 ] . Meanwhile, the literature on bounded rationality [ 20 , 19 ] emphasizes that real decision makers do not fully optimize; instead, they respond noisily to incentives, a property captured elegantly by the quantal response equilibrium (QRE) of 14 . Despite these advances, a unified framework that combines (i) noisy, boundedly rational play, (ii) a microfounded status-quo bias, and (iii) the possibility of changing not only payoffs but also the set of feasible actions has been lacking. This paper fills that gap by introducing a quantal response equilibrium with status-quo bias (QRE-SB) in which each player incurs a fixed switching cost whenever they deviate from an inherited default action. We then ask: can a policymaker dislodge an inefficient status quo by imposing a tax on the default action (a price-only reform), or must they resort to deleting the default action altogether (a ban)? This paper develops a behavioral framework for comparing two classes of institutional interventions: • price-based reforms, which modify incentives while preserving the action space; • action-deletion interventions, which remove inefficient or undesirable strategic options. Our analysis shows that structural interventions can fundamentally alter the equilibrium landscape in ways that purely monetary incentives cannot. Our analysis focuses on a simple but economically important class of binary coordination games [ 6 , 23 ] . Such games capture situations ranging from technology adoption [ 13 ] to climate cooperation [ 15 ] and social norms [ 4 ] . Within this class, we derive three main results. First, for any positive switching cost and any level of rationality (logit precision), there exists a threshold tax below which the status quo persists with high probability and above which a transition to the superior equilibrium occurs. Notably, this threshold does not depend on the degree of rationality when defined as the point where the two actions are equally likely. Second, deleting the default action always forces play to the only remaining feasible equilibrium, irrespective of switching costs or rationality. Third, when the superior equilibrium is Pareto-dominant, deletion yields strictly higher expected welfare than any price-only reform that keeps the old action feasible. Our contribution builds on several strands of literature. The QRE framework has been applied to many settings [ 10 ] , but only rarely augmented with state-dependent costs. Exceptions include work on switching costs in discrete choice [ 8 ] and on inertia in repeated games [ 9 ] . However, the specific comparison between taxes and bans in a coordination environment with endogenously evolving beliefs has not been formalized. The insight that changing the choice set may be more effective than changing incentives is not new in policy debates [ 22 , 21 ] , but our model provides a rigorous game-theoretic foundation for that intuition. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the baseline model of QRE-SB in a symmetric 2×2 coordination game. Section 3 introduces the two policy interventions – a tax on the default action and a deletion of that action – and analyzes their effects. Section 4 states and proves the main results, including the tax threshold, the effect of deletion, and the welfare comparison. Section 5 presents numerical simulations to illustrate the theoretical predictions. Section 6 discusses applications to climate policy, social media regulation, and international sanctions, and connects the model to the broader literature on bounded rationality and institutional change. Section 7 concludes and suggests directions for future research. The key mechanism is that taxes shift payoff differences smoothly, whereas deletion introduces a discrete change in the feasible set, eliminating inertia entirely. 2 Baseline Model: Quantal Response with Status-Quo Bias We consider a symmetric two-player normal-form game. The set of players is N=\{1,2\} . Each player has two pure actions: A_{i}=\{X,Y\} . The payoff matrix is given by \begin{array}[]{c|cc}&X&Y\\ \hline\cr X&a,\;a&c,\;d\\ Y&d,\;c&b,\;b\end{array} with the following standard assumptions: a>c and b>d (each action is a best response to itself), and b>a so that the (Y,Y) equilibrium is Pareto-superior. The game exhibits strategic complementarities, a property that holds automatically in the 2\times 2 case. The status quo is the inherited action profile. We assume that initially both players have played X and continue to regard X as the default. This default matters because we introduce a switching cost: each player incurs a fixed penalty \kappa\geq 0 whenever they choose an action different from the default X . This cost captures cognitive dissonance, transaction costs, psychological attachment, or institutional friction [ 18 , 12 ] . Throughout, p denotes the probability of playing the status quo action X ; thus lower values of p correspond to greater adoption of the alternative Y . Following 14 , players do not necessarily best respond perfectly; instead, they choose actions according to a logit rule. Let \sigma_{i} denote the mixed strategy of player i , with \sigma_{i}(X)=p_{i} and \sigma_{i}(Y)=1-p_{i} . Given a belief about the opponent’s strategy, the expected payoff of playing a pure action is linear. For a symmetric equilibrium we look for p_{1}=p_{2}=p . The expected payoff of action X when the opponent plays Y with probability 1-p is U(X,p)=pa+(1-p)c, while the expected payoff of action Y is U(Y,p)=pd+(1-p)b. The switching cost \kappa reduces the effective payoff of Y because choosing Y means deviating from the default X . Hence \tilde{U}(Y,p)=U(Y,p)-\kappa,\qquad\tilde{U}(X,p)=U(X,p). The logit response function (with precision parameter \beta\geq 0