The Shape of Testimony: A Scalable Framework for Oral History Archive Comparison
2026
Read The Shape of Testimony: A Scalable Framework for Oral History Archive Comparison (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21623.txt.
Introduction
Itamar Trainin, Renana Keydar, and Amit Pinchevski present a scalable method for oral history archive contrast, examining the shape of accounts. Scholars in Holocaust studies often mark two styles of oral survivor accounts. USC Shoah Archive talks tend to follow a set, host-guided format, whereas Yale Fortunoff Video Archive mostly leans to a free-form, open-ended style. They closely examine that claim via large-scale data study of more than one thousand six hundred accounts from both sets. Shape is measured through topic flow and host-witness shifts.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35097 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21623
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Shape of Testimony: A Scalable Framework for Oral History Archive Comparison Abstract Researchers in Holocaust studies have often distinguished between two styles of oral survivor testimony: the USC Shoah Foundation’s interviews tend to follow a structured, interviewer-guided format, whereas the Yale Fortunoff Video Archive generally favors a more free - form, open - ended style. This distinction has influenced both scholarly research and the development of later archives. In this study, we critically examine that claim by conducting a large-scale computational analysis of more than 1,600 testimonies from both collections. Leveraging discourse segmentation, topic modeling, and large language model (LLM) based analysis, we quantify the “structuredness” level of testimonies through topic coherence, interviewer–survivor dynamics, and the distribution of question types. Our results generally corroborate the structural differences identified in earlier research, while also revealing significant overlaps between the collections, both within individual interviews and across common narrative patterns. This complicates the simple “structured vs. free - form” dichotomy often applied to these oral histories. Beyond revisiting a foundational claim in Holocaust studies, our work provides a scalable, replicable framework for comparative corpus analysis. As a proof of concept, it suggests broader applications for digital oral history, narrative analysis, and the design of citizen - science annotation platforms. Keywords: Holocaust Studies, Oral History Language Resources, Computational Archive Comparison, Large language models (LLMs) The Shape of Testimony: A Scalable Framework for Oral History Archive Comparison Itamar Trainin, Renana Keydar, Amit Pinchevski Hebrew University of Jerusalem {itamar.trainin, renana.keydar, amitpi}@mail.huji.ac.il Abstract content 1. Introduction A common claim in the field of Holocaust Studies suggests that the two main oral history video testimony archives, the Yale Fortunoff Video Archive for Holocaust Testimonies (Henceforth: Yale or Fortunoff) and the USC Shoah Foundation (Henceforth: USC or Shoah Foundation), present two opposite styles of interviews. It is said that the interview practices by Yale tend to be loose and open-ended, whereas USC follows a stricter format. Several studies have ascertained this difference by exploring the institutional agenda and policy as well as through close readings of selected testimonies ( 34 ; 26 ; 21 ) and recently also by a small-scale empirical study ( 22 ) . Yet to empirically evaluate these assumptions, a large-scale comparative analysis is required, which is the purpose of this paper. This analysis calls for advanced computational tools, such as those developed recently in the digital humanities and computational history, for examining large narrative corpora. To date, applying these tools to oral testimonies has been limited due to the interpretive challenge and ethical complexities involved. In what follows, we seek to ascertain the reported difference between the two testimony styles by means of a computational comparison of over 1600 Holocaust survivor testimonies drawn from the USC and Yale archives. Using large language models (LLMs), dialogical segmentation, topic modeling, and question classification, we develop a reproducible pipeline to measure “structuredness” across interviews. We examine topical coherence, interviewer-survivor dynamics, and the evolution of question types along interviews to assess whether and how these archives actually diverge. Our findings confirm that USC testimonies tend to follow a more guided and structured format, especially in the early parts of the interview. Yale testimonies, by contrast, display greater topical fluidity, earlier emergence of core themes, and a higher proportion of open-ended questions. However, our analysis also uncovers significant convergences across both collections in later stages of the interviews, as well as similar narrative arcs, which seem to follow the chronology of Holocaust experience. This article thus makes a dual contribution: (1) it offers a data-driven reassessment of a central historiographical claim within Holocaust testimony scholarship; (2) it introduces a scalable framework for computational comparison of large oral history corpora. By demonstrating how complex, ethically sensitive narratives can be analyzed computationally without compromising their integrity and interpretive richness, we open a pathway for further digital humanities work in trauma studies, oral history, and memory research. 2. Oral history archives of the Holocaust Figure 1: (a) Number of interviews conducted (individually or jointly) by each interviewer in each archive. (b) Annual distribution of testimonies recorded across both archives, computed over the subset of testimonies available for this study. The Yale Fortunoff Video Archive for Holocaust Testimonies and the USC Shoah Foundation Visual History Archive are the two main and largest collections of video testimonies of Holocaust survivors. The Fortunoff Archive began in 1979 as a local initiative in New Haven, Connecticut, later relocating to Yale University ( 10 ) . Holding more than 4,400 testimonies collected in the US, Europe, and Israel, its mission is to collect, preserve, and share the stories of those who were there. Being the first of its kind, the archive set the standard for projects to come ( 7 ; 11 ) . The USC archive was founded in 1994 by Steven Spielberg with the goal of recording 50,000 testimonies, for which hundreds of interviewers were trained in multiple countries ( 29 ) . It has since surpassed that goal, and in addition to Holocaust testimonies, has expanded to record victim narratives of other genocides (including Armenian, Rwandan, Cambodian) ( 1 ; 29 ) . Both archives were initially based on videotape technology and, over time, came to embrace digital technology, while incorporating and developing new methods to access and engage with testimonies ( 1 ; 25 ) . At its core, an oral history interview is a process in which an interviewer and an interviewee spend extended time together engaged in storytelling and attentive listening. It is a collaborative act of constructing a narrative. Unlike other forms of qualitative interviewing (such as in-depth interviews), oral history interviews tend to be less narrowly focused in their topical organization ( 12 ) . As with other oral history initiatives, each of the Holocaust archives has developed its own interview methodology. From the outset, interviews recorded at Yale followed a clear code of conduct: putting the witnesses at the center and allowing them to relate their story freely with minimal guidance from interviewers. The interviewers’ main role was to provide survivors with a supportive listening companion during the interviews, all of which took place on the Yale campus ( 7 ) . Conversely, USC interviews take place at the witness’s home and are typically preceded by a preparation meeting. USC employs a large number of interviewers in many countries, who all go through formal training and follow a set of elaborate and formulated guidelines ( 31 ) ( 28 ) ). The Yale archive has relied on a relatively small group of interviewers, mostly academics, some with psychological training. As will be shown below, despite these disparities, interviews recorded by both archives tend to unfold chronologically, beginning with life before the war, through early signs of change, antisemitism and persecution, experiences during the war (ghetto, captivity, forced labor, extermination), end of war, and finally life after the war. All interviews examined here were transcribed manually by their respective archive, together with speaker identification and speaker-side segmentation. It is hard to imagine contemporary Holocaust history and memory without the prevalence of survivors’ testimonies. The two archives have contributed significantly to the legitimacy of personal narratives as a source for the study of recent history, particularly of traumatic