Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping 2026 Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping – References
Chul Chung, Junhyuk Son, Seunghyun Park, Suk-Jin Yoon, Hyejeon Cho, Dongwook Lim, Young-Wook Lee · 2026
Read Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping 2026 Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping – References by Chul Chung, Junhyuk Son, Seunghyun Park, Suk-Jin Yoon, Hyejeon Cho, Dongwook Lim, Young-Wook Lee (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21586.txt.
Introduction
Chul Chung and co-authors re-examine age-bias correction in supernova cosmology. They re-examine Wiseman et al. (2026), who claim progenitor-age bias has negligible impact on Type Ia supernova inferences. They show Wiseman's inferred host-age-Hubble residual slope is severely underestimated. Their sample spans a wide redshift range, zero point zero four to zero point four two, over which mean host age evolves by about three gigayears. Supernovae spanning large host-age differences are thus assigned similar residual values before regression, flattening the relation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chul Chung, Junhyuk Son, Seunghyun Park, Suk-Jin Yoon, Hyejeon Cho, Dongwook Lim, Young-Wook Lee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21372 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping 2026 Still non-accelerating: age-bias correction in supernova cosmology is robust to host-progenitor age mapping – References Chul Chung, Junhyuk Son, Seunghyun Park, Suk-Jin Yoon, Hyejeon Cho, Dongwook Lim, Young-Wook Lee Abstract We re-examine the claim by 25 that progenitor-age bias has a negligible impact on cosmological inferences from Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). We show that their inferred host-age–Hubble residual (HR) slope is severely underestimated because their combined SN Ia sample spans an unusually wide redshift range ( 0.04 < z < 0.42 0.04<z<0.42 ), over which the mean host age evolves by ∼ \sim 3 Gyr. As a result, SNe Ia spanning substantial host-age differences are effectively assigned similar HR values prior to regression, artificially flattening the inferred age–HR relation. In addition, their application of the Pantheon+ host-mass correction further suppresses the slope, but the underlying dust model is highly incompatible with the measured dust attenuation curves of galaxies. We also demonstrate that our age bias correction is robust to uncertainties in host–progenitor age mapping arising from different choices of the SN Ia delay-time distribution. The reduced progenitor-age evolution argued by 25 must, by the same logic, be accompanied by a steeper inferred progenitor-age–HR slope. When these two effects are consistently combined in computing the redshift-dependent magnitude correction, the final correction, and hence the resulting cosmological impact, remain largely unchanged from 22 . 1 Introduction Supernova cosmology relies on the key assumption that “the calibrating relationships between Type Ia supernova (SN Ia) luminosity and light curve shape must be invariant with progenitor age” ( 9 ) . Therefore, if this assumption is valid, no correlation should be observed between SN Ia magnitude and progenitor age after luminosity calibration. Direct tests of this assumption have become possible only relatively recently, as reliable measurements of the mean age of the stellar populations in SN Ia host galaxies (host age), which is the observable quantity most closely linked to progenitor age, have become available. Based on very high quality (signal to noise ratio \sim 175 ) spectra for nearby early-type host galaxies, 10 first reported a hint of a \sim 3\sigma correlation between host age and Hubble residual (HR), which is used as a measure of relative SN luminosity after standardization. Then, using the 20 sample and their photometric age measurements, 13 found a 4.3\sigma correlation for host galaxies spanning all morphological types. This result has since been independently confirmed by two third-party studies at the \sim 5\sigma level ( 26 ; 23 ) . More recently, 7 remeasured ages for a larger sample of host galaxies over a broader redshift range, including the 20 sample at low redshift ( z<0.2 ) and the 8 sample at relatively high redshift ( z<0.42 ), and confirmed the ubiquitous nature of the age bias at 5.5\sigma for the 20 sample and 4.8\sigma even for the higher-redshift 8 sample (see Park et al. 2026). The origin of this strong correlation was clarified by 12 and Park et al. (2026). They showed that, contrary to the key assumption of SN cosmology, the light-curve width-luminosity relation (Phillips relation) and the color-luminosity relation, which are the two correction terms in the SN Ia luminosity calibration process, exhibit significant luminosity offsets depending on host age. This is reminiscent of 2 ’s discovery of two Cepheid period-luminosity relations that depend on population age, which ultimately led to the realization that the Hubble constant originally derived by Hubble had been seriously overestimated. The discovery of an analogous effect in the SN Ia luminosity standardization process suggests that the apparent dimming of high-redshift SNe Ia, on which the discovery of cosmic acceleration and the cosmological constant was based, may in fact have been significantly affected by the evolution of progenitor age with redshift and the resulting systematic bias. Figure 1: Correlation between host age and HR. As in 25 , HRs for the combined 20 + 8 sample are calculated using the Pantheon+ ( 3 ) parameters and methodologies with (upper-left panel) and without (upper-right panel) the host-mass correction. The lower-left panel is obtained when the intrinsic scatter is additionally removed, and the lower-right panel shows the corresponding subsample in the narrow redshift interval 0.06\leq z\leq 0.20 , which yields the slope closest to the true value (see text). Based on these results, 22 showed that, after correcting for the age bias as a function of redshift, the SN dataset becomes more consistent with the w_{0}w_{a} CDM model recently suggested by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) project ( 1 ) from a combined analysis using only BAO and the cosmic microwave background (CMB) data. When the three cosmological probes (SNe, BAO, and CMB) are combined, they found a significantly stronger ( >9\sigma ) tension with the \Lambda CDM model, suggesting a time-varying dark energy equation of state in a currently non-accelerating universe. In their rebuttal, however, 25 argued that the key ingredients underlying this conclusion – the host-age dependence of standardized SN magnitude, the redshift-dependent progenitor-age difference, and their combined impact – are either negligible or already corrected for in the Pantheon+ ( 3 ) SN dataset. In this paper, which serves as a counter-rebuttal to 25 , we show that the main arguments advanced by 25 are either based on serious methodological flaws or are internally inconsistent by their own logic. 2 The origin of the shallower slope of the host-age–HR relation in W26 25 claimed that the slope of the host-age–HR correlation in the combined 20 + 8 sample is substantially weaker, and of low statistical significance, compared to the slopes derived in 7 and 22 when the 20 and 8 samples are analyzed separately. However, their inferred slope is severely underestimated for two reasons. First, the redshift range of their combined sample ( 0.06<z<0.42 ) is too wide for HR to be interpreted simply as a measure of relative luminosity. HR can be used as a proxy for relative luminosity only when the SNe Ia being compared lie at essentially the same redshift. In practice, a narrow redshift bin ( \sim 0.1 ) is usually adopted as a compromise to secure a sufficient sample size while still allowing HR to serve this role. If the redshift range becomes substantially wider, however, HR is no longer a pure measure of relative luminosity, because its value depends on the baseline cosmological model used in its definition, while the mean age of the host stellar population also evolves with redshift. Unlike the 20 sample, which is confined to a relatively narrow redshift range ( 0.06\leq z\leq 0.20 ), the combined 20 + 8 sample used by 25 spans a much broader interval ( 0.06\leq z\leq 0.42 ), over which HR acquires a redshift-dependent contribution from the assumed baseline cosmological model. Over this same range, the mean host age evolves by \sim 3 Gyr (see Figure 2 of 22 ). Because a \Lambda CDM model was adopted as the baseline when computing HRs, SNe Ia spanning host-age differences of up to \sim 3 Gyr, corresponding to \sim 40\% of the full age span, were effectively assigned similar HR values even before the host-age-HR regression was