Opening the Window of Ultra-Light PBHs by Exorcising the Poltergeist Preprint: MITP-26-023

Yann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister, Pedro Schwaller · 2026

Read Opening the Window of Ultra-Light PBHs by Exorcising the Poltergeist Preprint: MITP-26-023 by Yann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister, Pedro Schwaller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21477.txt.

Introduction

Yann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister, and Pedro Schwaller reopen the window for ultra-light primordial black holes by confronting the Poltergeist signal. The hot Big Bang may have come from evaporation of primordial black holes lighter than a billion grams. Standard single-mass treatments predict near-simultaneous evaporation, abrupt reheating, and a large scalar-induced gravitational wave signal. The authors confront this with the collapse mass tail that general relativity predicts, which smooths reheating, cuts the signal by orders of magnitude, and opens the ultra-light window again.

Catalog record

CREATORYann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister, Pedro Schwaller
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23920
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21477

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Opening the Window of Ultra-Light PBHs by Exorcising the Poltergeist Preprint: MITP-26-023 Yann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister, Pedro Schwaller Abstract The hot Big Bang may have emerged from evaporation of primordial black holes (PBHs) lighter than 10 9 10^{9} g. Standard monochromatic treatments predict nearly simultaneous evaporation, abrupt reheating, and a large Poltergeist scalar-induced gravitational wave signal. We confront this expectation with the irreducible collapse mass tail predicted by general relativity, d ​ f PBH / d ​ ln ⁡ M ∝ M 3.78 df_{\rm PBH}/d\ln M\propto M^{3.78} , which smooths reheating, suppresses the signal by orders of magnitude, and reopens the ultra-light PBH window. Introduction. Primordial black holes provide a direct probe of otherwise inaccessible epochs in the early Universe. Heavy PBHs remain viable dark-matter candidates in parts of parameter space 42 ; 22 ; 58 ; 50 , while PBHs lighter than roughly 10^{9}\,{\rm g} evaporate before Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) 65 ; 18 . If sufficiently abundant, such ultra-light PBHs dominate the energy density before they evaporate and thereby provide a minimal Standard-Model reheating mechanism 21 . They can also produce dark matter through Hawking radiation 44 ; 66 ; 72 ; 43 or participate in mechanisms for baryogenesis 85 ; 86 ; 12 ; 69 ; 27 ; 14 . Such a cosmological history leaves several gravitational-wave (GW) signatures. Direct graviton emission during evaporation and high-frequency GWs from PBH binaries probe frequencies far above the usual interferometer bands 27 ; 7 ; 56 . At lower frequencies, the most promising signals are scalar-induced gravitational waves (SIGWs), generated at second order in cosmological perturbation theory 71 ; 70 ; 6 ; 13 ; 83 ; 39 ; 64 ; 34 . For PBH domination, the best-known source is the Poltergeist mechanism 59 ; 77 ; 28 ; 31 ; 15 ; 52 ; 51 ; 10 ; 30 ; 33 ; 61 ; 76 ; 35 ; 36 : scalar modes freeze during matter domination and begin to oscillate once evaporation restores radiation domination, while efficiently sourcing tensor modes. The predicted amplitude is highly sensitive to the duration of reheating. The studies cited above 59 ; 77 ; 28 ; 31 ; 15 ; 52 ; 51 ; 10 ; 30 ; 33 ; 61 ; 76 ; 35 ; 36 assumed a monochromatic PBH population, for which evaporation is nearly instantaneous and the Poltergeist enhancement is maximized. However, PBHs formed from the collapse of super-horizon overdensities 90 ; 54 ; 19 ; 20 do not have identical masses. Critical collapse implies a universal low-mass tail in the PBH mass function 25 ; 40 ; 73 ; 74 , independent of the detailed shape of the primordial curvature power spectrum. Earlier works already showed that broadening the mass distribution reduces the Poltergeist amplitude 59 . Here we emphasize that a nonzero width is unavoidable and determine the conservative upper envelope of the resulting GW signal. Besides the poltergeist signal generated at reheating, the total SIGW spectrum also receives contributions from PBH formation, from the preceding radiation era, and from the PBH-dominated era itself. These additional channels become important once the poltergeist enhancement is suppressed. The total spectrum then becomes comparable to that of a generic early matter-dominated era, rather than parametrically larger. As a result, both the projected reach of future GW experiments and the BBN bound from the integrated GW energy density are relaxed. In this Letter we keep the discussion at the level of physical ingredients and robust scalings. The detailed derivations of transfer functions, kernels, and numerical fits are presented in a companion paper 48 . Irreducible PBH mass spread. We consider PBHs formed during radiation domination from overdensities that collapse when they re-enter the Hubble horizon (for reviews see Refs. 20 ; 38 ). Close to the threshold, numerical simulations, solely relying on general relativity and spherical symmetry, give the universal critical scaling law 25 ; 40 ; 73 ; 74 \text{Choptuik's law:}\quad M_{\rm PBH}=\kappa M_{H}(\delta_{m}-\delta_{c})^{\gamma_{\rm M}}, (1) where M_{H} is the horizon mass, \delta_{c} is the collapse threshold, \kappa=\mathcal{O}(1) , and \gamma_{\rm M}\simeq 0.36 for radiation domination 25 ; 40 ; 88 ; 57 . Since \delta_{m} is continuous, Eq. ( 1 ) maps even a sharply peaked primordial spectrum into an extended PBH mass function. Press–Schechter and peak-theory computations make this statement explicit 80 ; 11 ; 17 ; 87 ; 88 ; 49 ; 63 . We define the normalized PBH mass function in terms of the energy density fraction at formation \beta_{f} as \psi_{f}(M)\equiv\frac{1}{\beta_{f}}\frac{d\beta_{f}}{d\ln M},\qquad\int d\ln M\,\psi_{f}(M)=1. (2) Critical scaling maps the probability distribution of the linear density contrast at horizon crossing into \psi_{f} . For both Press–Schechter and peak theory this gives \psi_{f}(M)\propto(M/M_{H})^{1+1/\gamma_{\rm M}}P_{H}[\delta_{m}(M)], (3) with \delta_{m}(M) obtained from Eq. ( 1 ). The quantity P_{H} denotes the probability distribution of the smoothed density contrast at horizon crossing. Press–Schechter and peak theory differ only in how this distribution is computed. The prefactor in Eq. ( 3 ) is instead the common Jacobian from \delta_{m} to M and fixes the universal low-mass tail, \psi_{f}(M)\propto M^{1+1/\gamma_{\rm M}}\simeq M^{3.78}. (4) The high-mass tail depends on the statistics, amplitude and shape of the primordial perturbations. For example, it is often parametrized as \psi_{f}\propto M^{1+1/\gamma_{\rm M}}\exp[-c_{1}(M/\langle M\rangle)^{c_{2}}] , with c_{1} and c_{2} model dependent 48 . To remain agnostic, and to obtain the largest possible GW signal, we discard this tail and use the sharpest distribution compatible with Eq. ( 4 ), \psi_{f}^{\rm sharp}(M)=\frac{1+\gamma_{\rm M}}{\gamma_{\rm M}}\left(\frac{M}{M_{\rm cut}}\right)^{1+1/\gamma_{\rm M}}\Theta(M_{\rm cut}-M). (5) The mean mass is then \langle M\rangle=(1+\gamma_{\rm M})M_{\rm cut}/(1+2\gamma_{\rm M}) . Any smoother ultraviolet tail prolongs evaporation and further suppresses the GW signal. The mass function in Eq. ( 5 ) should therefore be understood as a conservative upper limit on the linear SIGW amplitude. PBH reheating. On scales larger than their mean separation, PBHs are described as a pressureless fluid with an additional evaporation term. For a single PBH, M(t)=M_{f}\left(1-\frac{t}{t_{\rm eva}}\right)^{1/3},\qquad t_{\rm eva}=\frac{M_{f}^{3}}{3AM_{\rm pl}^{4}}, (6) where A=(\pi\mathscr{G}/480)g_{H\star} includes greybody factors and the number of emitted degrees of freedom 53 ; 75 ; 56 . If the initial fraction \beta_{f} exceeds a critical value \beta_{c} , PBHs dominate before they evaporate. For an extended mass function, all background quantities are averaged over \psi_{f} , yielding the homogeneous evolution \displaystyle\langle\dot{\rho}_{\rm PBH}\rangle+3H\langle\rho_{\rm PBH}\rangle \displaystyle=-\langle\Gamma\rho_{\rm PBH}\rangle, (7) \displaystyle\langle\dot{\rho}_{\rm r}\rangle+4H\langle\rho_{\rm r}\rangle \displaystyle=\langle\Gamma\rho_{\rm PBH}\rangle. (8) Thus the decay rate is not the rate of a single PBH but the convolution of Eq. ( 6 ) with \psi_{f} . Different masses disappear at different times, smoothening the matter-to-radiation transition. The relevant comoving scales are the evaporation scale k_{\rm eva}=a_{\rm eva}H_{\rm eva} , the equality scale k_{\rm eq}=a_{\rm eq}H_{\rm eq} at the onset of PBH domination, and the discreteness scale k_{\rm PBH} set by the mean inter-PBH separation. These scales determine which modes enter during the first radiation era, during PBH domination, or after evaporation. This smoothing is most transparently seen in the Newtonian potential, sourced by two scalar seeds: the adiabatic mode \Phi inherited from inflation, and the PBH isocurvature seed S\equiv\delta_{\rm PBH}-\frac{3}{4}\,\delta_{\rm rad}, (9) which measures the local imbalance between PBH and radiation densities. Being discrete objects, PBHs carry unavoidable Poisson fluctuations on top of the smooth radiation background.

Read the complete text