Negative neutrino mass or negative dark energy?
Cihad Kıbrıs, Willem Elbers, Özgür Akarsu, Eleonora Di Valentino · 2026
Read Negative neutrino mass or negative dark energy? by Cihad Kıbrıs, Willem Elbers, Özgür Akarsu, Eleonora Di Valentino (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21456.txt.
Introduction
Cihad Kıbrıs and co-authors ask whether negative neutrino mass or negative dark energy explains a cosmological tension. DESI and CMB analyses show tension between the inferred sum of neutrino masses and the minimum allowed by oscillation tests. This assumes standard Lambda-CDM cosmology. They explore alternative dark energy models, including negative-density models reproducing effects of negative effective neutrino masses. Such models can ease tension by changing expansion over a redshift range relevant for CMB lensing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cihad Kıbrıs, Willem Elbers, Özgür Akarsu, Eleonora Di Valentino |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 119480 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21456
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Negative neutrino mass or negative dark energy? Cihad Kıbrıs, Willem Elbers, Özgür Akarsu, Eleonora Di Valentino Abstract Recent cosmological analyses based on DESI and CMB data have revealed a tension between the inferred sum of neutrino masses and the minimum value allowed by neutrino oscillation experiments, when assuming an underlying Λ \Lambda CDM model of cosmology. In this work, we perform a systematic exploration of alternative dark energy models, including models that can supply a negative dark energy density capable of reproducing the cosmological effects of negative effective neutrino masses. We argue that dark energy models can alleviate the tension by modifying the cosmic expansion rate over a specific redshift range relevant for CMB lensing, while matching BAO distance measurements from DESI at lower redshifts. Among the models considered, we find that a sign-switching cosmological constant model, Λ s \Lambda_{\mathrm{s}} CDM, is uniquely capable of recovering positive neutrino masses by modifying the expansion history in this way. For the combination of DESI DR2 BAO, CMB, and DES-Dovekie supernova data, the constraint on the effective neutrino mass shifts from ∑ m ν , eff = − 0.075 − 0.053 + 0.039 eV \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}=-0.075^{+0.039}_{-0.053}\,\mathrm{eV} (68%) for Λ \Lambda CDM to ∑ m ν , eff = 0.055 ± 0.050 eV \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}=0.055\pm 0.050\,\mathrm{eV} (68%) for Λ s \Lambda_{\mathrm{s}} CDM, with a 95% lower bound on the dark energy transition redshift, z † > 2.4 z_{\dagger}>2.4 . Although Λ s \Lambda_{\rm s} CDM does not have the strongest overall statistical support among the models considered, when the ∑ m ν , eff \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}} parameter is allowed to vary, our findings point toward a specific sign- and redshift-structured contribution to the late-time expansion history as a viable way to alleviate the neutrino mass tension. I Introduction The existence of massive neutrinos provides concrete evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model. Over the past two decades, a sustained experimental effort has led to percent-level determinations of the mixing angles and mass splittings that characterize the standard three-neutrino framework 41 ; 40 ; 57 ; 86 ; 42 ; 75 ; 43 . Yet, while oscillation experiments impose a robust lower limit on the sum of the three known neutrino masses, \sum m_{\nu}\geq$0.059\text{\,}\mathrm{eV}$ 75 , their ordering and absolute mass scale remain uncertain. Massive neutrinos play a nontrivial role in cosmology, affecting both the expansion history of the Universe and the growth of cosmic structure. These effects provide powerful and complementary means of probing neutrino masses independently of terrestrial experiments (see 105 ; 167 ; 1 ; 102 ; 59 for reviews). In practice, the strongest constraints typically derive from measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), combined with probes of the large-scale structure and late-time expansion history, particularly through baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO). The latest cosmological observations have now reached a level of precision at which the inferred bounds on the sum of neutrino masses approach, and in some cases even surpass, the lower limits implied by oscillation experiments. In particular, BAO measurements from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) 3 ; 4 , when combined with the latest CMB data 9 ; 117 ; 39 ; 139 , provide the tightest constraints to date on \sum m_{\nu} . Conventional analyses of these data, adopting the standard \Lambda CDM model of cosmology, have produced 95% upper limits in the range of \sum m_{\nu}<0.04-$0.06\text{\,}\mathrm{eV}$ 69 ; 39 ; 97 , falling below the oscillation lower limit \sum m_{\nu}\geq$0.059\text{\,}\mathrm{eV}$ . This discrepancy, which we call the cosmological neutrino mass tension , points to a failure of the underlying assumptions. If the tension is not a statistical fluctuation or a result of unidentified systematic errors, then it may signal new physics in the neutrino sector or a departure from the assumed \Lambda CDM cosmology. The problem becomes more evident once the physical prior \sum m_{\nu}\geq 0 is relaxed and an effective neutrino-mass parameter is allowed to explore negative values. In this case, the likelihood distribution peaks in the unphysical region \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 54 ; 88 ; 70 ; 69 ; 87 ; 137 ; 169 ; 119 , and the significance of the tension reaches the 3\sigma level. Intriguingly, a full-shape analysis of DESI galaxy clustering with limited prior information from the CMB also peaks in the range \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 , albeit with increased uncertainty, and the same holds for analyses of CMB and CMB-lensing data alone 69 . These findings suggest that the preferred cosmological solution may lie beyond the physical boundary imposed by the prior on the neutrino masses. However, the extension to \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 should only be considered as a diagnostic parameter, rather than as a proposal for negative neutrino rest masses. The question we address is whether this diagnostic is pointing to a breakdown of the assumed cosmological model. Within \Lambda CDM, the sum of neutrino masses acts as a compensating parameter that can partially absorb mismatches among different cosmological observables, including BAO distance measurements and the growth and lensing information encoded in the CMB. Allowing this parameter to become negative effectively supplies a negative contribution to the effective cosmic energy budget governing the late-time Friedmann equation, thereby modifying both the expansion history and the growth of structure. From this perspective, the preference for \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 may indicate that the standard \Lambda CDM+ \sum m_{\nu} framework lacks relevant late-time degrees of freedom. Recent analyses suggest a specific picture. The standard \Lambda CDM model struggles to simultaneously accommodate the shorter low-redshift BAO distance scales measured by DESI and the CMB lensing amplitude preferred by current data, while maintaining the precise geometric constraint from the angular acoustic scale in the CMB. At fixed CMB geometry, the shorter BAO distances pull the fit toward lower values of the fractional matter density, \Omega_{\rm m} , than those inferred from the CMB alone, but this in turn reduces the predicted CMB lensing amplitude. Adopting \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 can absorb this mismatch by reversing the usual cosmological effects of massive neutrinos: it lowers the effective late-time matter budget while enhancing the lensing signal. To replace \sum m_{\nu,\mathrm{eff}}<0 with a more compelling physical resolution, a model should either boost gravitational lensing directly or modify the expansion history 87 . In this study, we focus on models that modify the expansion history. We argue that these models should suppress H(z) over the intermediate-redshift range most relevant for CMB lensing, while restoring a larger expansion rate at lower redshift so as to remain compatible with DESI BAO distances and CMB geometry. Modifications in the dark energy (DE) sector, for example through dynamical dark energy (DDE) models, provide one possible source of such behavior. In low-dimensional equation-of-state (EoS)-based dynamical dark energy parametrizations, such as the Chevallier–Polarski–Linder (CPL) model 51 ; 113 , the neutrino-mass posterior can be broadened or shifted by altering the late-time expansion history 70 ; 69 ; 169 . This is achieved by suppressing H(z) during a high-redshift period with a phantom-like equation of state, w_{\mathrm{DE}}(z)<-1 , before crossing the phantom-divide line (PDL) to a non-phantom period, w_{\mathrm{DE}}(z)>-1 , at z\lesssim 0.5 . However, recovering a large positive value of \sum m_{\nu} implies that w_{\mathrm{DE}}(z) should evolve rather quickly, as illustrated, for example, in Fig. 3 of Ref.