Causal UV completions of relativistic hydrodynamics
Robbe Brants · 2026
Read Causal UV completions of relativistic hydrodynamics by Robbe Brants (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21377.txt.
Introduction
Robbe Brants proves that any stand-alone relativistic hydrodynamic effective field theory is inherently acausal. Such theories describe the low-energy regime of many out-of-equilibrium systems, yet they require transient UV modes to restore causality. Exponential decay of dissipative hydrodynamics across most of the lightcone allows a causal description that still reduces to hydrodynamics at late times. He investigates the emergence and restrictions of non-hydrodynamic modes in these causal UV completions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Robbe Brants |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41105 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21377
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Causal UV completions of relativistic hydrodynamics Robbe Brants Abstract Relativistic hydrodynamics successfully provides an effective field theory description for the low energy regime of many out-of-equilibrium systems. On the other hand, in this paper we proof that any stand-alone hydrodynamic EFT is inherently acausal and therefore requires the addition of transient UV modes in order to restore causality. This is made possible by the exponential decay of dissipative hydrodynamics in a majority of the lightcone, allowing the possibility of a causal description that still reduces to the hydrodynamic one at late timescales. We then investigate the emergence and possible restrictions of the non-hydrodynamic modes in these causal UV completions. I Introduction Relativistic hydrodynamics plays a crucial role in the phenomenological description of various out-of-equilibrium systems 11 ; 2 ; 18 . Its success is regarded as a result of the separation of scales between the modes governing the dynamics of the system. A hydrodynamic mode corresponds to a conserved quantity in the system, and as a result its dispersion relation \omega(k) in complex frequency space vanishes in the limit of infinite wavelength k\to 0 . In contrast, the remaining degrees of freedom correspond to transient or non-hydrodynamic modes, which decay exponentially in time at all wavelengths. Relativistic hydrodynamics can therefore be seen as an EFT description, applicable in the IR limit corresponding to large wavelengths and late times, when the system is close to equilibrium. On the other hand, this success may still come as a surprise, since this EFT description is expected to be acausal without corrections in the form of non-hydrodynamic modes, a clear flaw when describing a relativistic fluid 22 ; 23 ; 14 . This statement will be made explicit in the paper, but already a straightforward example is Fick’s diffusion equation, with hydrodynamic mode \omega(k)=-iDk^{2} . After perturbing the system at a single point in space, the retarded correlation function governed by this mode spreads out instantaneously throughout the entirety of real space for all t>0 : G(t,x)=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int e^{ikx-i\omega(k)t}dk=\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi Dt}}\exp\left(-\dfrac{x^{2}}{4Dt}\right)\,. (1) A possible solution to this problem is moving away from the IR limit, and reintroducing the UV modes that were integrated out. An example is given by the Telegrapher’s equation, where a transient mode with relaxation time \tau_{\pi} is added. This type of causal completion is used in many hydrodynamic descriptions such as MIS theory 29 ; 26 ; 25 and the BDNK framework 5 ; 28 ; 4 . However, this approach also modifies the dispersion relation of the hydrodynamic mode in the IR regime, in the form of higher gradient corrections. We instead want to focus on causal UV completions , which are causal correlation functions containing additional transient UV modes, that have any particular hydrodynamic dispersion relation as an exact mode below some energy cutoff, where it furthermore remains the slowest decaying mode. This approach can be seen as a bootstrap method for constructing the UV completion of an EFT. Here, the IR description is fixed by the hydrodynamic dispersion relation, while we remain fully agnostic about the microscopics of the system. We then use causality as an overarching principle to put restrictions on the regime of applicability of hydrodynamics, together with the compatible UV completions. This goal is achieved by proving three mathematical theorems, together with a proper study of causal mode structures. First, we investigate the requirements for correlation functions and their modes to be causal, and proof stand-alone dissipative hydrodynamic theories are guaranteed to violate causality, justifying the need for a causal completion. We then proceed to look at the effects of dissipative hydrodynamics on real-space evolution, where we find a decay rate depending on the radial direction (velocity) within the lightcone. This is used to guarantee the existence of causal UV completions for hydrodynamic theories. Finally, we look at the emergence of non-hydrodynamic modes in these UV completions, in particular for the example of pure diffusion. In the paper, correlation functions and Fourier transforms will be considered as if one-dimensional. Generalizing to higher dimensions is reasonably straightforward, as it adds polynomial factors while we will focus entirely on exponential decay rates. II Causal correlation functions The main object of interest in this paper will be the retarded correlation function G(t,x) , which describes the reaction of a fluid to an initial perturbation at x=0 , together with its singularities in complex frequency space, known as the modes of the system. If G(t,x) is a causal correlation function, it must vanish outside of the forward light cone, i.e. when |x|>t . In QFT, G(t,x) is generally assumed to be a tempered distribution. In simple terms, this means its growth is bounded by some polynomial at large x and t , and so this condition translates to stability of the theory. It furthermore guarantees the existence of a Fourier transform G(\omega,k)=\int G(t,x)e^{i\omega t-ikx}dtdx\,, (2) and because of the causality condition, we find that the integrand is exponentially suppressed when \imaginary\omega>|\imaginary k| . As a result, the integral and all its derivatives will converge absolutely in this region of Fourier space. This leads to the well studied causality condition that all singularities of the retarded correlation function must obey 20 ; 13 ; 21 ; 12 ; 24 : \imaginary\omega(k)\leq|\imaginary k|\,. (3) This condition is sufficient to bring us to the first important point of this paper, which is that dissipative hydrodynamics as a stand-alone EFT can not be causal, meaning that if only the hydrodynamic mode contributes to the correlation function, it will have support outside of the lightcone. In this statement, a dissipative hydrodynamic dispersion relation corresponds to a function \omega(k):\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{C} , for which \omega(0)=0 and \imaginary\omega(k)<0 for all k\in\mathbb{R}\backslash\{0\} . Explicitly, we find the following result: Theorem 1 (Acausality of hydrodynamics) . Let \omega(k) be a dissipative hydrodynamic dispersion relation. Then, the correlation function G(t,x)=\frac{1}{2\pi}\theta(t)\int e^{ikx-i\omega(k)t}dk (4) has support outside of the lightcone |x|\leq t . Proof. We first observe that, since \imaginary\omega(k)\leq 0 for all k\in\mathbb{R} , \theta(t)e^{-i\omega(k)t} is bounded for all t . It is therefore a tempered distribution, and so is the correlation function G(t,x) at a fixed t . For any Schwartz function \varphi\in\mathcal{S}(\mathbb{R}^{2}) , we can make use of the boundedness of the integrand to find \langle G,\varphi\rangle=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\overline{\hat{\varphi}(t,k)}e^{-i\omega(k)t}dtdk\,, (5) and therefore |\langle G,\varphi\rangle|\leq\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}|\hat{\varphi}(t,k)|dtdk<\infty\,, (6) meaning G(t,x) is also tempered in \mathbb{R}^{2} . We can thus directly calculate its Fourier transform G(\omega,k)=\frac{i}{\omega-\omega(k)}\,. (7) We will now assume the correlation function to vanish outside of the lightcone, and look separately at the cases where \omega(k) is either entire, or when it contains singularities. If \omega(k) is an entire function, we can use Theorem 1 from 20 which states that, in order to satisfy the causality condition ( 3 ), \omega(k) must be a polynomial of at most degree one. Since \omega(k) is dissipative, this is not a possibility. The dispersion relation can therefore not be analytic in the entire complex k -space. We invert the relation \omega(k)=\omega-\frac{i}{G(\omega,k)}\quad\forall(\omega,k)\in\mathbb{C}^{2}\,, (8) and see that \omega(k) will be non-analytic at k=k_{*} if either G(\omega,k) is also non-analytic at k_{*} , or G(\omega,k_{*})=0 . In the second case, \omega(k) has a pole, which is ruled out from Theorem 2 in 20 under the causality condition. In the first case,