From Summer to Spring: A Shift in US Housing Market Seasonality

Yihan Hu, Cemil Selcuk · 2026

Read From Summer to Spring: A Shift in US Housing Market Seasonality by Yihan Hu, Cemil Selcuk (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21358.txt.

Introduction

Yihan Hu and Cemil Selcuk track a shift in US housing market seasonality from summer to spring. Prices and sales once rose through spring, peaked in summer, and fell through autumn and winter. Since 2021, the pattern has moved earlier, with spring strengthening at the expense of the summer peak. Viewed through the search-and-matching model of Ngai and Tenreyro, which links cycles to household mobility through thick markets, the shift raises whether move timing changed. Using SIPP data, they find residential mobility did shift earlier after 2021.

Catalog record

CREATORYihan Hu, Cemil Selcuk
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68922
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21358

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From Summer to Spring: A Shift in US Housing Market Seasonality Thanks: Hu: [email protected] , Selcuk: [email protected] Yihan Hu, Cemil Selcuk Abstract The US housing market exhibits pronounced seasonal cycles: prices and sales rise through spring, peak in summer, and decline through autumn and winter. Since 2021, this pattern has shifted earlier in the calendar year, with spring strengthening at the expense of the traditional summer peak. A leading explanation for housing market seasonality is the search-and-matching model of Ngai and Tenreyro (2014), which links these cycles to household mobility through a thick-market mechanism. In this framework, periods with higher mobility generate thicker markets and higher prices and transaction volumes. Viewed through this lens, a shift in the seasonal cycle of prices and sales raises the question of whether the timing of household moves has changed. Did residential mobility shift earlier in the calendar year after 2021? We find that it did. Using SIPP data, and corroborating evidence from Google Trends indicators, we document a post-2021 shift in mobility toward spring. We extend the model to a monthly frequency, prove the existence and uniqueness of the equilibrium, and calibrate it to the observed mobility patterns. The calibrated model reproduces the spring shift in both prices and transaction volumes, consistent with the view that a change in the timing of household mobility alone can account for the recent shift in housing market seasonality. Keywords: Housing market, Seasonality, Mobility, Search and matching JEL codes: D4, J6, R2 1 Introduction The US housing market exhibits highly regular seasonal cycles. Prices and transaction volumes rise through spring, peak in summer, and fall through autumn and winter. This pattern has been documented repeatedly over several decades and across a wide range of markets ( 2 ; 5 ) . The regularity of this cycle has made it one of the most robust stylised facts in housing economics. Summer is the “hot” season, winter the “cold” one, and the amplitudes of the swings are economically meaningful in both prices and volumes. There are signs, however, that this regularity may have changed. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, seasonal peaks appear to arrive earlier in the calendar year, with spring months strengthening at the expense of the traditional summer surge, and the amplitude of the cycle itself may have changed ( 13 ; 7 ) . These changes represent a break in one of the most stable empirical patterns in housing economics. As a first step, we verify these shifts: using transaction data from Zillow, one of the largest real estate platforms in the United States, we establish that the seasonal cycle has indeed shifted, in both prices and sales. In the post-2021 period, the spring months pick up earlier and more strongly than they did before, while the summer term softens. The seasonal cycle has not disappeared; it has moved forward in the calendar year. The spring quarter gains roughly 2 percentage points in seasonal price intensity and 6 percentage points in sales, with similar and statistically significant contractions in summer, confirming the earlier findings. To understand what might be driving this shift, we turn to theory. In 18 , arguably the leading theoretical account of housing market seasonality, the seasonal cycle in housing markets is driven by seasonal variation in household mobility. More households tend to move in summer than in winter. When many households move at the same time, more buyers and sellers enter the housing market simultaneously, making the market thicker. In a thick market, buyers are more likely to find a house that matches their preferences, which raises the probability of a transaction. Because matches are better on average, the surplus from trade is larger, and prices are higher as well. In winter, when fewer households move, the market becomes thin: matches are harder to find, transactions are less frequent, and prices are lower. In this way, the seasonal patterns of prices and sales are pinned down directly by the seasonal pattern of household mobility. This mechanism has a sharp implication. The pattern of prices and transactions is inherited from the pattern of household mobility. If prices and sales have shifted earlier in the calendar year, then, all else equal, the model predicts that households themselves must be moving earlier as well. Did the timing of household moves shift earlier after 2021? We find that it did. Our primary evidence comes from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP), a nationally representative longitudinal survey conducted by the US Census Bureau. SIPP follows households over time and records detailed information on employment, income, and residential mobility. Crucially for our purposes, respondents report the calendar month in which they moved residence, allowing the timing of household moves to be measured directly. The data reveal a clear shift. June, historically the busiest moving month, loses 3.0 percentage points of annual moves post-2021, and July drops a further 1.9 percent. On the other side, March gains 1.8 percent and April gains 1.4 percent. In aggregate, the spring quarter absorbs 4.0 additional percentage points of annual moves post-2021, while the summer quarter contracts by 4.8 percent. All changes are statistically significant. We corroborate this finding with Google Trends search indices for eight keywords that capture different aspects of a household move: rental trucks ( moving truck , uhaul ), professional movers ( atlas van lines , mayflower moving ), packing ( moving supplies ), moving assistance ( moving help ), and administrative tasks ( address forwarding , thumbtack ). All eight show a statistically significant shift of seasonal search activity from summer toward spring. Finally, a recent report by MoveHQ, a leading logistics company that handles household relocations across the US, documents the same pattern in its own operational records covering over one million moves. Three independent sources of evidence, each measuring different populations using different methods, point to the same pattern: American households are moving earlier in the year. To link mobility patterns to prices and sales, we extend the setup in NT from two seasons to twelve calendar months. The monthly frequency is essential because the monthly shifts we document cannot be captured in a model that operates at a semi-annual frequency. We prove the existence and uniqueness of the housing market equilibrium and propose an algorithm based on contraction mapping to numerically solve it. We then feed the pre- and post-2021 hazard rates obtained from the SIPP mobility profiles into the model calibration. Three features of the results are worth highlighting. First, the hump-shaped seasonal pattern of mobility translates into a hump-shaped profile of prices and transaction volumes, matching the qualitative pattern observed in the data. Market activity and prices are highest in summer, lowest in winter, and intermediate in spring and autumn. Second, and more importantly, the observed shift in seasonal mobility produces a corresponding shift in the trajectory of prices and sales. As households begin to move earlier in the year, the housing market thickens earlier, raising matching rates and prices in spring at the expense of summer. In other words, the observed spring shift in both prices and transaction volumes is quantitatively consistent with a change in the timing of household mobility alone, requiring no change in preferences, technology, or market structure.

Read the complete text