Profiling User Vulnerability to Phishing Through Psychological and Behavioral Factors
Valeria Formisano, Danilo Gentile, Gennaro Esposito Mocerino, Michela Ponticorvo, Luigi Gallo, Alessio Botta, Davide Marocco · 2026
Read Profiling User Vulnerability to Phishing Through Psychological and Behavioral Factors by Valeria Formisano, Danilo Gentile, Gennaro Esposito Mocerino, Michela Ponticorvo, Luigi Gallo, Alessio Botta, Davide Marocco (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-21246.txt.
Introduction
Valeria Formisano and colleagues ask who is most at risk from phishing. They test one thousand eighty-six people with a lifelike phishing task from the Spamley set. Five traits emerge from factor analysis: seniority, expertise, creativity, stability, and risk. People who decide fast are more at risk, and fast choices match self-reported impulsivity. Sorting by seniority and creativity yields two groups: aware users and high-risk users.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valeria Formisano, Danilo Gentile, Gennaro Esposito Mocerino, Michela Ponticorvo, Luigi Gallo, Alessio Botta, Davide Marocco |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34048 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21246
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Profiling User Vulnerability to Phishing Through Psychological and Behavioral Factors Valeria Formisano, Danilo Gentile, Gennaro Esposito Mocerino, Michela Ponticorvo, Luigi Gallo, Alessio Botta, Davide Marocco Abstract Phishing remains one of the most pervasive cybersecurity threats, shifting the focus from technological vulnerabilities to human cognitive and psychological factors. In coherence with the trend of studies on phishing to increasingly focus on human aspects and vulnerable users profiling, this study investigates the multidimensional nature of user susceptibility by analyzing data from the Spamley dataset, involving 1,086 participants evaluated through a realistic phishing detection task. Using Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA), five latent constructs were identified, named: Seniority, Expertise, Creativity, Stability, and Vulnerability. Behavioral findings, validating self-reported impulsivity through its negative correlation with response times, demonstrate that faster decision-making significantly distinguishes vulnerable users from resilient ones. A K-Means clustering procedure, driven by the dimensions of Seniority (F1) and Creativity (F3), revealed two distinct user profiles: the Aware User and the High-Risk User. The results demonstrate that technical knowledge alone is insufficient to guarantee resilience; rather, the interaction between operational maturity, decision-making speed, and cognitive approach determines effectiveness. The findings suggest that the majority of users fall into the High-Risk category, characterized by hasty evaluation processes and lower critical analysis. These results underline the urgent need to move beyond "one-size-fits-all" training toward personalized, adaptive cybersecurity programs that actively address cognitive biases and behavioral tendencies. 1 Introduction and Motivation With the continuous expansion of digital services and communication networks, sharing personal and financial information online has become an everyday practice, exposing users to increasingly sophisticated threats. In this digital landscape, phishing stands out as one of the most widespread and effective forms of cyber crime, as it allows attackers to bypass purely technological defenses by targeting the end point of every technological system directly: the user [ 3 ] . Traditional cybersecurity measures, however advanced, are often insufficient unless integrated with a deep understanding of human behavior, which constitutes the true target of these threats [ 19 ] . The success of phishing attacks, understood as complex social engineering tactics, fundamentally depends on the interaction of two distinct dimensions: on the one hand, the characteristics of the message, and on the other, the characteristics of the person receiving it. With respect to the first aspect, the effectiveness of the attack is determined by a set of structural and psychological elements carefully designed to deceive the victim. At the structural level, the characteristics of the email play a crucial role in the perception of authenticity: cybercriminals use spoofing techniques to forge the sender’s address, faithfully replicate the aesthetics, logos, and formatting of legitimate organizations (such as banks or government agencies), and disguise malicious URLs or infected attachments by presenting them as routine documents, such as invoices or receipts [ 4 , 1 ] . Psychologically, these communications are structured around specific principles of persuasion developed in social psychology by Robert Cialdini [ 5 ] , used to circumvent the user’s critical thinking. For example, attackers frequently exploit authority, impersonating corporate executives, IT administrators, or law enforcement to intimidate the victim and coerce immediate compliance. Similarly, they use the principle of reciprocity by offering fake rewards or unexpected refunds, or they leverage consistency, first requesting small, seemingly harmless actions and then pushing the user to hand over sensitive credentials [ 23 ] . It is worth noting that many phishing attacks make use of urgency (such as the threat of imminent account suspension within 24 hours) to induce tension and force hasty decisions, yet quantitative studies show that the use of levers such as authority and consistency [ 23 ] or appreciation (also known as liking) [ 16 ] are actually the strongest predictors of compromising the user’s defenses. However, vulnerability to such attacks is not limited to the effectiveness of the deceptive strategies employed in the message, but also on the characteristics of the human that reads the email. This study therefore decided to focus its initial analysis on this still largely unexplored phenomenon: the human psychological factor. Specifically, our initial goal was to identify, within a publicly available dataset on phishing susceptibility, the profiles of users who are potentially most vulnerable to phishing attacks. To this end, we analyze data from the Spamley dataset [ 22 ] , a publicly available dataset on users’ ability to recognize phishing emails. Susceptibility to fraud stems from a complex interaction between the external attack and the individual’s intrinsic decision-making, cognitive, and physiological processes. Understanding the human being behind the screen is essential for developing effective defense models. 1.1 The State of the Art An analysis of the existing literature reveals that research has progressively explored the human factor by cataloging a wide range of predictive variables [ 25 , 14 ] . A first fundamental line of research has focused on cognitive and decision-making processes. It has been widely demonstrated that information processing modes play a key role. In fact, the likelihood of falling victim to fraud increases significantly when users rely on heuristic processing referred to as “System 1” [ 13 ] and described as intuitive, emotional, and fast, rather than on a systematic and rational analysis of the message (“System 2”) [ 29 , 6 ] . Added to these dynamics is the pervasive effect of habit: the automatic and routine use of email can inhibit the activation of suspicion, lowering the cognitive barriers necessary to detect anomalies and deception [ 26 ] . Conversely, expertise in the subject allows for the development of effective defensive heuristics, such as the ability to interpret linguistic anomalies or instinctively recognize unrealistic offers in everyday life [ 2 ] . A second crucial strand concerns psychological and personality traits. Much research draws on the Big Five psychometric model, confirming that fundamental personality traits directly influence how messages are processed. For example, high levels of extroversion, openness, or neuroticism tend to correlate with greater susceptibility to certain phishing scenarios, such as those promising rewards or inducing emotional stress [ 9 , 17 , 11 , 6 ] . Furthermore, intrinsic signal detection abilities and the level of suspicion (understood both as a dispositional traits inherent in the individual, and as a transient psychological state induced by the context) profoundly alter judgments of truthfulness and accuracy in detecting deception [ 24 ] . While some approaches make use of unsupervised learning models to uncover vulnerable users profiles [ 27 ] , others focus on user behavior while performing specific tasks related to phishing content analysis [ 21 , 18 ] . Finally, the literature has explored the impact of demographic, physiological, and contextual variables. Vulnerability trajectories change drastically with age. Aging, especially when associated with a decline in executive functions or specific genetic profiles, tends to severely exacerbate susceptibility to phishing [ 20 ] . However, compensatory factors have also been identified: high interoceptive accuracy (the ability to perceive one’s body’s internal signals, such as heart rate) can improve deception detection skills in older adults [ 12 ] . At the opposite end of the age spectrum, the psychological impact also hits young adults hard, among whom direct experience with cyber attacks generates anxieties and concerns that have proven to be cross-cultural