Lower Bounds for Advection-Diffusion Equations: An Exploration with AI-Generated Proofs
Chenyang An, Xiaoqian Xu · 2026
Read Lower Bounds for Advection-Diffusion Equations: An Exploration with AI-Generated Proofs by Chenyang An, Xiaoqian Xu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20623.txt.
Introduction
Chenyang An and Xiaoqian Xu prove explicit lower bounds for advection-diffusion equations in three settings. They give a polynomial bound for inviscid shears, a uniform positive bound on mixing size for diffusive shears, and an exponential limit for rapidly oscillating time-regular flows. All constants are clear in the data. Strikingly, the proofs were generated entirely by QED, a multi-agent maths proving system, with no expert human intervention, as a test of AI rigour.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chenyang An, Xiaoqian Xu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 113918 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20623
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lower Bounds for Advection-Diffusion Equations: An Exploration with AI-Generated Proofs Chenyang An, Xiaoqian Xu Abstract . We establish explicit lower bounds for advection-diffusion equations in three settings: a polynomial H ˙ − 1 \dot{H}^{-1} bound for inviscid shears with u ∈ L t ∞ W y 1 , 1 u\in L^{\infty}_{t}W^{1,1}_{y} , a uniform positive lower bound on the mixing scale for diffusive shears, and an exponential L 2 L^{2} bound for rapidly oscillating time-periodic flows. All constants are explicit in the data. The proofs were generated entirely by a multi-agent math proving system, QED [ 1 ] , without expert human intervention, serving as a test of AI’s capability to produce rigorous mathematics. 1. Introduction The advection–diffusion equation \partial_{t}\rho+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\rho=\mu\Delta\rho (1.1) on the torus \mathbb{T}^{d} provides a fundamental setting in which to study the competition between transport and dissipation. When \mathbf{u} is divergence-free, the dynamics are driven by two opposing effects: advection stretches and folds the scalar field, creating ever finer scales, while diffusion smooths the field and damps gradients. Understanding the long-time balance between these mechanisms is at the heart of the mathematical theory of mixing, with connections to turbulence theory [ 7 ] , chemical reactor design [ 14 ] , and atmospheric science [ 24 ] . For a mean-zero solution the L^{2} norm satisfies \frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\|\rho(t)\|_{L^{2}}^{2}=-2\mu\|\nabla\rho(t)\|_{L^{2}}^{2}, so the norm is non-increasing. In the absence of advection the decay is exponential, governed by the Poincaré inequality. The presence of a velocity field can accelerate this dissipation, a phenomenon termed enhanced dissipation, which has been the subject of extensive research [ 12 , 8 , 30 , 29 , 20 , 16 , 31 , 28 ] . The question of optimal decay rates for the L^{2} norm has attracted considerable attention. A fundamental lower bound was proved in [ 25 , 15 , 23 ] , that is for any bounded velocity field, \|\rho(t)\|_{L^{2}}\geq C\exp(-Ce^{Ct}), so the norm cannot drop faster than a double exponential. Rowan [ 26 ] subsequently proved that this bound is sharp by constructing bounded flows that indeed achieve double-exponential decay. Thus, without additional structure, the L^{2} norm may decay doubly-exponentially, but not faster. A natural question is what structural conditions restore the more familiar exponential lower bound. For shear flows, Huang and Xu [ 19 ] recently proved that an exponential L^{2} lower bound is possible, confirming that diffusion can fundamentally suppress mixing. Their analysis, however, is non-constructive, leaving open the explicit dependence of the decay exponent on the data. In this paper we develop several new directions related to these lower bounds, with a unified focus on explicit, constructive estimates. We treat three increasingly general settings, each exposing a different aspect of the interplay between advection, diffusion, and temporal oscillation. In this paper, first, we study the purely advective limit of a shear flow, where the absence of diffusion leads to a polynomial lower bound on the \dot{H}^{-1} norm. Second, we add a small diffusivity and consider a bounded shear; here we obtain an explicit exponential L^{2} lower bound and a uniform positive lower bound on the mixing scale \|\rho\|_{\dot{H}^{-1}}/\|\rho\|_{L^{2}} , which is shown to be sharp in the \nu -scaling. This gives a rigorous foundation for the arrested cascade observed numerically in [ 23 ] and connects to the broader theory of mixing scales [ 21 , 28 ] . Finally, we consider general divergence-free velocity fields with fast time-periodic oscillations, proving that for sufficiently large frequencies an exponential L^{2} lower bound is restored, with explicit constants. As a by-product, this also provides an exponential bound for time-independent flows. Inviscid shear mixing. Consider the transport equation \partial_{t}\theta+u(y,t)\,\partial_{x}\theta=0,\qquad\theta(0)=\theta_{0}\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{T}^{2}),\ \int\theta_{0}=0, where the shear satisfies u\in L^{\infty}_{t}W^{1,1}_{y}(\mathbb{T}) . Lower bounds on negative Sobolev norms for inviscid shears have been studied under several different regularity assumptions. For C^{\alpha} shear flows, Colombo, Coti Zelati, and Widmayer [ 11 ] proved that the L^{2}_{x}H^{-1}_{y} norm satisfies a uniform upper bound of order t^{-1} for all times, together with a matching lower bound along a sequence of times t^{\prime}_{m}\to\infty : \|\theta_{\star}(t^{\prime}_{m})\|_{L^{2}_{x}H^{-1}_{y}}\geq C(t^{\prime}_{m})^{-1}\|\theta^{\mathrm{in}}_{\star}\|_{L^{2}_{x}H^{1}_{y}}. Galeati and Gubinelli [ 17 ] considered generically rough shears in the Besov scale B^{\alpha}_{1,\infty} and established sharp mixing rates in the H^{1/2} norm, uniform for all times; along certain diverging sequences \tilde{t}_{n} , they also proved a lower bound for the stronger H^{-1} norm: \|e^{-\tilde{t}_{n}u\partial_{x}}f_{0}\|_{H^{-1}}\gtrsim\tilde{t}_{n}^{-1}\|f_{0}\|_{H^{1}}. For cellular flows with a palenstrophy constraint u\in L^{\infty}_{t}\dot{W}^{s,p} ( s>1 ), Crippa and Schulze [ 13 ] obtained a polynomial lower bound on the \dot{H}^{-1} norm along a discrete sequence of times: \|\theta(T_{n})\|_{\dot{H}^{-1}}\geq CT_{n}^{-2/(s-1)}. Our contribution is to extend this line of inquiry to the still weaker W^{1,1} regularity class, and to obtain a bound that holds for all times rather than along a subsequence. Theorem 1.1 (Polynomial \dot{H}^{-1} lower bound for inviscid shears) . Let \theta be the unique solution of the above transport problem with \theta_{0}\not\equiv 0 . Then there exists a constant c_{*}>0 , depending only on \theta_{0} and u , such that \|\theta(t)\|_{\dot{H}^{-1}}\geq\frac{c_{*}}{1+t^{2}}\qquad\text{for all }t\geq 0. The proof uses the exact phase evolution of x -Fourier modes: a nonzero x -mode e^{ikx} evolves by multiplication with e^{ik\Phi(y,t)} , conserving its L^{2}_{y} mass, while the W^{1,1}_{y} norm of \Phi grows at most linearly. This forces a fixed fraction of the mode’s energy to remain in low y -frequencies, yielding the O(t^{-2}) lower bound. Mixing scale for diffusive shears. We next turn to the advection-diffusion equation with a bounded shear, \partial_{t}\rho+U(t,y)\,\partial_{x}\rho=\nu\Delta\rho,\qquad\rho(0)=\rho_{0}\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{T}^{2}),\ \int\rho_{0}=0, (1.2) where \nu>0 and U\in L^{\infty}_{t,y}(\mathbb{T}) . A physically important quantity in this setting is the mixing scale \|\rho\|_{\dot{H}^{-1}}/\|\rho\|_{L^{2}} , which measures the characteristic filamentation length. Miles and Doering [ 23 ] observed numerically that this scale seems to encounter a limiting Batchelor scale, beyond which diffusion prevents further refinement. The double-exponential decay constructed by Rowan [ 26 ] corresponds to the absence of such a limiting scale. For a bounded shear we prove that the mixing scale is uniformly bounded away from zero, providing a rigorous justification for the arrested cascade. By a completely constructive Fourier method we first obtain an explicit exponential L^{2} lower bound. Theorem 1.2 (Explicit L^{2} lower bound and mixing scale) . For the solution \rho of ( 1.2 ) with \rho_{0}\not\equiv 0 , there exists an explicit constant c_{2}>0 , computable from \rho_{0} , U , and \nu , such that \|\rho(t)\|_{L^{2}}\geq\|\rho_{0}\|_{L^{2}}\,e^{-c_{2}t}\qquad(t\geq 0). Moreover, the mixing scale satisfies a uniform lower bound: one can determine a constant c_{*}>0 , again explicit in the data, for which \frac{\|\rho(t)\|_{\dot{H}^{-1}}}{\|\rho(t)\|_{L^{2}}}\geq c_{*}\qquad\text{for all }t\geq 0, in the small diffusivity regime 0<\nu\ll 1 . The proof proceeds mode-by-mode in the conserved x -Fourier variable. For each nonzero x -mode, a high-low frequency decomposition in y shows that the low block eventually retains at least half of the mode’s energy, provided the block size is chosen large enough relative to |k|\,\|U\|_{\infty}/\nu . Once this is established, the H^{-1} norm is controlled by the low modes, giving the uniform bound. Fast time-periodic oscillations. Finally, we consider general divergence-free velocity fields that are time-periodic with frequency A : \partial_{t}\rho+u(At,x,y)\cdot\nabla\rho=\nu\Delta\rho,\qquad u(t+L,\cdot)=u(t,\cdot), (1.3) with u\in L^{\infty}_{t}W^{1,\infty}_{x,y} . For large A , the fast oscillation temporally averages the advection, and we prove that the exponential lower bound