Beyond minimal coupling for charged scalars? Modified electrodynamics and London-penetration tests
F. Minotti, G. Modanese · 2026
Read Beyond minimal coupling for charged scalars? Modified electrodynamics and London-penetration tests by F. Minotti, G. Modanese (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20499.txt.
Introduction
Minotti and Modanese link optical condensate weight to static magnetic screening in charged bosonic condensates. From a Ginzburg-Landau functional they derive the London equation and low-frequency transverse conductivity. With an added diamagnetic coupling, the modified theory doubles both the optical weight and the inverse-square magnetic screening value at fixed condensate settings. Published data for Nb, Pb, YBCO, MgB2 and Ba(Fe,Co)2As2 test consistency but cannot tell the couplings apart, so the pair call for an absolute-response experiment.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | F. Minotti, G. Modanese |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33234 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20499
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond minimal coupling for charged scalars? Modified electrodynamics and London-penetration tests F. Minotti, G. Modanese Abstract While standard minimal coupling works well for Dirac fermions, its application to scalar fields features a known “peculiarity”: the term linear in A μ A_{\mu} does not coincide with the conserved Noether current of the interacting theory. We recently proposed choosing a different principle for electromagnetic interactions, namely a linear coupling A μ J μ A_{\mu}J^{\mu} with J μ J^{\mu} a (globally) conserved current, accepting the consequence that one must abandon full local gauge invariance in the electromagnetic sector and adopt an extended electrodynamics (of Aharonov–Bohm type) that can couple consistently to non-locally-conserved currents. We first review the standard theory (scalar QED and the role of the A 2 | ϕ | 2 A^{2}|\phi|^{2} term), then present the physical motivations offered for proposing the modified coupling and discuss general consequences of reducing gauge invariance. We then focus on the central condensed-matter claim: for bosonic charged condensates, the modified framework predicts a rescaled magnetic penetration depth λ → λ / 2 \lambda\to\lambda/\sqrt{2} , while leaving other key qualitative features of superconducting electrodynamics and the type-I/type-II distinction unchanged (up to an equivalent rescaling of the GL parameter). Finally, we analyze experimental data for a London-length consistency check based on independent measurements of the ratio n s / m ∗ n_{s}/m^{\ast} between carrier density and effective mass. We compare for five materials an “optical” penetration depth λ opt \lambda_{\mathrm{opt}} inferred from IR/THz superfluid spectral weight with a “magnetic” depth λ mag \lambda_{\mathrm{mag}} obtained independently (LE- μ \mu SR, TF- μ \mu SR, microwave methods, etc.). Data for Nb, YBCO and Ba(Fe,Co) 2 As 2 confirm the hypothesis λ opt > λ mag \lambda_{\mathrm{opt}}>\lambda_{\mathrm{mag}} , with a ratio not far from 1.4; data for Pb are inconclusive while data for MgB 2 indicate λ opt ≃ λ mag \lambda_{\mathrm{opt}}\simeq\lambda_{\mathrm{mag}} as predicted by the standard theory. I Introduction Local gauge invariance (LGI) and minimal coupling are cornerstone principles of modern electrodynamics and of the Standard Model. In the familiar fermionic case (Dirac QED), replacing \partial_{\mu}\to\partial_{\mu}+i(q/\hbar)A_{\mu} produces an interaction term of the form -J_{\mu}A^{\mu} with J^{\mu}=q\bar{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi , which coincides with the conserved Noether current associated with global phase symmetry. This harmony among (i) LGI, (ii) strict local charge conservation, and (iii) the physical meaning of J^{\mu}A_{\mu} as interaction energy is aesthetically and technically compelling. For scalar fields, minimal coupling also works and produces a consistent gauge-invariant theory, but the bookkeeping of currents is less transparent. Expanding the covariant-derivative Lagrangian yields a term linear in A_{\mu} proportional to the free Noether current, plus a quadratic term A^{2}|\phi|^{2} . The conserved source current that enters the gauge-field equations is the derivative of the full action with respect to A_{\mu} , and it includes contributions from the A^{2}|\phi|^{2} term. This is a standard feature of derivative couplings and of gauging scalar fields. Nevertheless, in Ref. 15 we argued that one can adopt an alternative principle: electromagnetic interaction energy should always be expressible as J^{\mu}A_{\mu} where J^{\mu} is the conserved current resulting from global gauge invariance of the full Lagrangian. For scalar systems, enforcing this principle implies renouncing LGI in the electromagnetic sector and adopting an extended electrodynamics compatible with possible local nonconservation of charge. In that modified framework, new terms appear in the effective dynamics of charged bosons, and this has potentially observable consequences in superconductors, including a characteristic rescaling of the magnetic penetration depth by a factor 1/\sqrt{2} . This article develops the conceptual background of the alternative coupling proposed, and frames a concrete experimental test strategy. II Standard scalar QED and the status of the conserved current Consider a free complex scalar field \phi : \mathcal{L}_{0}=\partial_{\mu}\phi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\phi-m^{2}\phi^{\ast}\phi. (1) The global phase symmetry \phi\to e^{i\alpha}\phi yields the Noether current j^{\mu}_{\mathrm{free}}=iq\left(\phi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\phi-(\partial^{\mu}\phi^{\ast})\phi\right),\qquad\partial_{\mu}j^{\mu}_{\mathrm{free}}=0\ \ \text{(on-shell for the free equations).} (2) Minimal coupling introduces the covariant derivative D_{\mu}=\partial_{\mu}+iqA_{\mu} and the matter Lagrangian \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{mat}}=(D_{\mu}\phi)^{\ast}(D^{\mu}\phi)-m^{2}\phi^{\ast}\phi. (3) Expanding, (D_{\mu}\phi)^{\ast}(D^{\mu}\phi)=\partial_{\mu}\phi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\phi+iqA_{\mu}\left(\phi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\phi-(\partial^{\mu}\phi^{\ast})\phi\right)+q^{2}A_{\mu}A^{\mu}\,\phi^{\ast}\phi. (4) The linear term involves j^{\mu}_{\mathrm{free}} from Eq. ( 2 ), but the quadratic q^{2}A^{2}|\phi|^{2} term is essential for gauge invariance. In perturbation theory it yields the familiar “seagull” vertex for scalar QED. The electromagnetic source is obtained by varying the full Lagrangian with respect to A_{\mu} : J^{\mu}\equiv\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial A_{\mu}}=iq\!\left[\phi^{\ast}D^{\mu}\phi-(D^{\mu}\phi)^{\ast}\phi\right]=j^{\mu}_{\mathrm{free}}-2q^{2}A^{\mu}|\phi|^{2}. (5) This current is locally conserved as a consequence of gauge invariance and the structure of the field equations. Hence, the standard view is that scalar QED has no internal inconsistency; rather, it illustrates that “naively” identifying the coefficient of the linear term with the source current is incorrect for scalars. As stated in 15 , this is “not an inconsistency, just a feature” ensuring that the correct conserved current is the source of the gauge field. II.1 Why insist on a linear A_{\mu}J^{\mu} coupling with conserved J^{\mu} ? The proposal in 15 can be read as an attempt to elevate to a principle what is commonly true in fermionic QED and in classical electrodynamics: the interaction energy density is J^{\mu}A_{\mu} , and gauge invariance of this interaction term in a transformation A_{\mu}\to A_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}f is closely tied to current conservation (since, by integration by parts, J^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}f\to-f\,\partial_{\mu}J^{\mu} ). The fact that the interaction energy is not gauge invariant in standard scalar QED appears as a weak point of the theory in a semiclassical limit, where a proper expression for this energy is expected to be gauge-invariant and independent from whether, given a current, it is made of fermions or bosons. In ordinary Maxwell electrodynamics with strict local charge conservation, gauge transformations are allowed and the potentials are not unique. However, Aharonov and Bohm famously argued that potentials can have physical significance even in regions where F_{\mu\nu}=0 , as evidenced by the (gauge invariant) AB phase. In extended electrodynamics frameworks that reduce gauge freedom, A_{\mu} can be treated more directly as a physical field (modulo residual gauge transformations), and then J^{\mu}A_{\mu} becomes a natural candidate for a physically meaningful interaction energy density. Ref. 15 emphasizes that if one wants to treat J^{\mu}A_{\mu} as a well-defined physical quantity, one is led to link it to a conserved J^{\mu} . Maxwell theory with gauge invariance supports two transverse propagating photon polarizations. Reduced gauge invariance can allow additional longitudinal modes. In AB-type extended electrodynamics, an additional scalar field (or scalar-like degree of freedom in the potentials) can appear, namely S=\partial_{\mu}A^{\mu} , sourced by the local nonconservation measure I\equiv\partial_{t}\rho+\nabla\cdot\mathbf{J}, as discussed in the AB-electrodynamics literature 13 ; 12 . The extended Aharonov-Bohm electrodynamics with reduced gauge invariance can also be applied to effective theories with apparent local nonconservation. In many-body quantum mechanics and effective condensed-matter models, one sometimes encounters nonlocal potentials, coarse-graining, or open-system descriptions where the usual local continuity equation for an effective current can appear violated (even if the underlying microscopic theory is conservative). Ref. 15 connects this to the possibility that strict local charge conservation could fail in certain effective quantum models, and that an electromagnetic theory able to couple to such currents would be required (or at least meaningful as an effective description). Related discussions appear in our broader program on Aharonov–Bohm extended electrodynamics and “gauge waves” 13 ; 12 ; 14 . A recent complementary perspective is provided by Lenzi et al. , who study a generalized (fractional) Schrödinger dynamics