Gravitational Entanglement in Optomechanics: Distinguishing Classical and Quantum Models

Samuel Schlegel, Ankit Kumar, Tomasz Paterek, Borivoje Dakić · 2026

Read Gravitational Entanglement in Optomechanics: Distinguishing Classical and Quantum Models by Samuel Schlegel, Ankit Kumar, Tomasz Paterek, Borivoje Dakić (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20330.txt.

Introduction

Samuel Schlegel and three co-workers study gravitational entanglement in optomechanics, classical versus quantum models. Gravity-born quantum entanglement is read as proof of non-classical gravity. Most lab work starts from Gaussian states, and weak gravity trims the quantum Newtonian potential to second order. That regime allows a classical Wigner-Weyl account, with traits tied to quantum entanglement. They weigh options and give tests for non-classicality via Wigner negativity and non-quantumness via Weyl operator negativity. Proving such entanglement demands more than once thought.

Catalog record

CREATORSamuel Schlegel, Ankit Kumar, Tomasz Paterek, Borivoje Dakić
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42617
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20330

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational Entanglement in Optomechanics: Distinguishing Classical and Quantum Models Samuel Schlegel, Ankit Kumar, Tomasz Paterek, Borivoje Dakić Abstract Observation of gravitationally induced quantum entanglement is often interpreted as a direct evidence of non-classical gravity. While the form and the degree of non-classicality have been rigorously studied from a foundational perspective, classical models reproducing experimental signatures of such entanglement remain underexplored. Motivated by the experimental simplicity, nearly all existing optomechanical approaches assume Gaussian initial states, and due to the weakness of gravity the quantum Newtonian potential is truncated at the second order. However, this regime admits a classical description in terms of the Wigner-Weyl representation, including features typically associated with quantum entanglement. A clear distinction between classical and quantum predictions emerges only beyond this setting. We comprehensively analyze the possibilities and provide operational witnesses for detection of non-classicality via Wigner negativity, and detection of non-quantumness via negativity of the Weyl operator. Our results demonstrate that the experimental requirements on certifying gravitational entanglement are more stringent than previously anticipated. 1 Introduction The idea that two masses could be entangled solely through their gravitational interaction dates back to Feynman [ 17 ] . Concrete proposals for realizing such experiments in the near future have emerged only recently [ 10 , 31 , 27 ] , and their foundational implications remain under active debate. Different models of the mass—field—mass system attribute gravitationally induced entanglement to different forms of non-classicality. For example, it has been linked to non-classical correlations with the mediator [ 28 ] , non-commuting field observables [ 31 ] , non-zero off-diagonal terms in coherent state basis [ 10 ] , and, more recently, to superpositions of geometries [ 13 ] and quantum features of spacetime [ 15 ] , and non-commuting field-particle couplings [ 23 ] . At the same time, hybrid models combining classical gravity with quantum matter [ 19 , 35 , 42 , 34 ] can also produce entanglement [ 43 ] , leading to the view that only detailed measurements can rule out such alternatives [ 4 , 18 ] . Here, we set aside these foundational questions and instead focus on a practical reason why the mere detection of certain signatures of gravitational entanglement is not sufficient to exclude classical gravity. A natural route towards observation of this form of correlation is to leverage the methods of optomechanics [ 3 ] , which enable preparation of near-ground Gaussian states in harmonic potentials and precise quadrature measurements [ 12 ] . Since gravity is weak, the relative displacement of the masses in such experiments is much smaller than their separation, and hence existing proposals typically rely on a second-order expansion of the quantum Newtonian potential in this small parameter. Although this approximation already predicts entanglement, in fact all signatures accessible through quadrature measurements in this regime also admit a classical explanation. This classical model is just the Newtonian evolution of phase-space distributions, obtained via the Wigner-Weyl transformation. This does not contradict the presence of quantum signatures, as the corresponding classical model involves states which would violate the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. To certify a genuinely quantum behavior, some of these assumptions must be relaxed. We comprehensively analyze two such routes: the preparation of non-classical initial states of the masses, and the inclusion of the third-order term in the gravitational potential. We also discuss additional possibilities, such as measurements beyond standard quadrature observables and the use of independent evidence that the individual masses themselves exhibit quantum behaviour. In all of these scenarios, classical and quantum predictions diverge. In particular, incorporating the cubic contribution to the quantum gravitational interaction generates both entanglement and negativity of the Wigner function, providing a direct signature of non-classicality. By contrast, the corresponding classical model retains a positive Wigner function while still reproducing entanglement signatures. However, the associated Weyl operator acquires negative eigenvalues, thereby signaling non-quantumness. We show how these features can be detected experimentally. Finally, we note that a systematic analysis of various notions of entanglement within the Wigner–Weyl framework was recently presented in Ref. [ 38 ] . As we show below, gravitational dynamics provides a natural setting in which all of these notions can arise. 2 Scenario and prerequisites From an experimental point of view, the simplest setup for observing gravitational entanglement consists of two identical spherical masses m constrained to move along one dimension x , with initial center-to-center separation L . The masses are independently prepared in suitable initial states, allowed to evolve under purely gravitational interaction, and finally measured using quadrature apparatus. This scenario is particularly interesting because it admits multiple modeling approaches, and the resulting measurements can be used to distinguish between them. Below, we compare predictions from quantum and classical mechanics and show that they overlap significantly under typical assumptions. We begin with the quantum description. Consider two identical masses prepared in a product of identical Gaussian states of width \sigma : \displaystyle\psi_{j}(x_{j}) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\quantity( 2 \pi\sigma^2 )^{1/4}}\exp\quantity( - \frac{x_j^2}{4 \sigma^2} ),\quad j=1,2, (1) where x_{1} and x_{2} are the respective displacements of the two masses from their initial average positions, and for simplicity we assumed the initial relative momentum as zero. In this notation, the Hamiltonian reads: \displaystyle H=-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\partial^{2}_{x_{1}}-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\partial^{2}_{x_{2}}-\frac{Gm^{2}}{L+x_{2}-x_{1}}. (2) For simplification we make a transformation to the center of mass (COM) frame of reference, where R=(x_{1}+x_{2})/2 , and r=x_{2}-x_{1} , are the displacements of the center of mass and the reduced mass, respectively. In these coordinates the Hamiltonian is separable in the two degress of freedom, H=H_{R}+H_{r} , where H_{R}=-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{4m}\partial^{2}_{R} and \displaystyle H_{r} \displaystyle=-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{m}\partial^{2}_{r}+V(r),\quad V(r)=-\frac{Gm^{2}}{L+r}. (3) The initial state remains a product of Gaussians \psi_{1}(x_{1})\psi_{2}(x_{2})=\psi_{R}(R)\psi_{r}(r) , where the position spreads of the COM and the reduced mass are \sigma/\sqrt{2} and \sigma\sqrt{2} , respectively. Given the separability, the COM wave function \psi_{R}(R) evolves freely, and hence the problem reduces to evolving the wavefunction of the relative motion \psi_{r}(r) under the potential that depends only on the relative distance. In the quantum model, the state of relative motion evolves according to the von Neumann equation: \displaystyle i\hbar\partial_{t}\rho(r,r^{\prime},t)= \displaystyle-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{m}\big(\partial^{2}_{r}-\partial^{2}_{r^{\prime}}\big)\rho(r,r^{\prime},t) \displaystyle+\big(V(r)-V(r^{\prime})\big)\rho(r,r^{\prime},t), (4) where \rho(r,r^{\prime},t) is the statistical operator in position representation. To compare classical and quantum dynamics on an equal footing, we employ the Wigner–Weyl transformation. The Wigner function maps quantum operators to phase-space quasi-probability distributions. For a state \rho this is given by \displaystyle W(x,p)=\frac{1}{2\pi\hbar}\int dy\,e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}py}\matrixelement{ x + \frac{y}{2} }{\rho}{ x - \frac{y}{2} }. (5) Conversely, any classical phase-space distribution f(x,p) can be mapped to a Weyl operator: \displaystyle\rho_{f}(x,x^{\prime})=\frac{1}{2\pi\hbar}\int dp\,e^{\frac{i}{\hbar}p(x-x^{\prime})}f\left(\frac{x+x^{\prime}}{2},p\right), (6) which need not be positive semi-definite. There are many possible such mappings [ 46 ] , but the Wigner function is especially useful because its reconstruction from quadrature measurements parallels the classical reconstruction of f(x,p) . Finally, following Bohm and Hiley [ 9 ] , the classical evolution under the Hamiltonian for the relative motion H_{r} , maps via the Wigner–Weyl transformation to the Weyl-operator evolution equation: \displaystyle i\hbar\partial_{t}\rho_{f}(r,r^{\prime},t)= \displaystyle-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{m}\left(\partial^{2}_{r}-\partial^{2}_{r^{\prime}}\right)\rho_{f}(r,r^{\prime},t) \displaystyle+(r-r^{\prime})\frac{dV}{dr}|_{\frac{r+r^{\prime}}{2}}\rho_{f}(r,r^{\prime},t). (7) 3 Classical model of experimental signatures of entanglement We are now in a position to explain how classical mechanics can reproduce signatures of entanglement. Recall that relative displacement r is much smaller than the initial separation L , which justifies expanding the Newtonian potential in powers of r/L : \displaystyle V(r)\approx V_{N}(r)=-\frac{1}{4}m\omega^{2}\sum_{n=0}^{N}(-1)^{n}\frac{r^{n}}{L^{n-2}}, (8) where \omega^{2}=4Gm/L^{3} characterizes

Read the complete text