Advanced Scientific Methodology Plays Rossini
Silvia Licciardi, Daniela Macchione, Emmanuel Caronna, Elisa Francomano · 2026
Read Advanced Scientific Methodology Plays Rossini by Silvia Licciardi, Daniela Macchione, Emmanuel Caronna, Elisa Francomano (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20220.txt.
Introduction
Silvia Licciardi and three co-workers apply scientific methods to music philology in a structural analysis of Rossini settings of the Metastasio arietta Mi lagnerò tacendo. A musical score gives performance instructions and sometimes implicit hints of the composer's aims, while variants and revisions complicate study. Through computational analysis with parsing, data mining and graph theory, they explore melodic, harmonic and textual choices in one Rossini setting. The results are a significant unicum, laying groundwork for systematic philological study and for generative models investigating the creative process.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Silvia Licciardi, Daniela Macchione, Emmanuel Caronna, Elisa Francomano |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45837 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20220
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Advanced Scientific Methodology Plays Rossini Silvia Licciardi, Daniela Macchione, Emmanuel Caronna, Elisa Francomano Abstract A musical score provides the essential instructions for its performance while containing indications – at times implicit – regarding the composer’s intentions. The presence of authorial variants, and even more so complex series of revisions associated with a single text, presents a challenging path for analytical study. This research, situated within the application of Scientific Methodologies to Music Philology, proposes a methodological approach oriented toward the structural analysis of one of the many settings composed by Gioachino Rossini on the same Metastasio arietta “Mi lagnerò tacendo”. Through Computational Analysis – incorporating parsing, data mining, and graph theory – the melodic, harmonic, and textual compositional choices have been rigorously explored. The results constitute a significant unicum in the field, laying the foundation for a systematic study that supports philological research and paves the way for the use of generative models to investigate the creative process. 0 0 footnotetext: MSC2020: Primary 05C90, 68P99; Secondary 62E99, 65K05. Keywords: Graph theory, Data mining, Statistical Distribution, Numerical methods. 1 Introduction While the scientific method finds transversal applications across many disciplines, the musical field (despite a wealth of existing studies [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] ) has not traditionally been the primary focus of its development. In recent years, however, a growing interest in the intersections between Scientific Calculus (SC) and the arts (specifically between SC and music) has catalyzed the development of numerous computational approaches for the automated analysis of musical language (see [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] and the refs therein). Various methodologies, including Machine Learning, Multivariate Numerical Analysis [ 9 ] , and modeling via Convolutional or Recurrent Neural Networks (CNN, RNN), have been implemented. Additionally, computational linguistics tools such as autoencoders and transformers have been employed for extracting melodic, rhythmic, or harmonic patterns, as well as for stylistic classification, authorship attribution, formal segmentation, tonal analysis, and even marketing strategies [ 2 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Most existing research, however, has focused on large-scale datasets or comparative analyses between different musical styles, adopting a macroscopic perspective of musical structure [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . The present work, while situated within this broader context, represents a significant unicum. It proposes an innovative approach to the computational modeling of authorial variants, a complex field of study where even subtle differences between versions of the same piece reflect a composer’s stylistic, interpretive, or developmental evolution. Ultimately, it is the creative process that drives a composer to conceive, elaborate, modify, or rewrite a musical work in its various forms. Rather than analyzing musical style in a broad sense, this study focuses on a specific and circumscribed case: a corpus of over one hundred compositions by Gioachino Rossini based on the same text, Metastasio’s arietta “Mi lagnerò tacendo”. Each variant possesses its own distinct character, duration, and musico-poetic features (see Section 2 ), yet all relate to a missing or implicit archetype. In particular, this work presents a rigorous microscopic analysis of a single variant to demonstrate the methodology applied to the entire corpus. By integrating analytical tools from music data mining [ 19 ] , multivariate numerical analysis [ 20 ] , graph theory [ 1 , 21 ] , and machine learning, alongside symbolic score analysis (e.g., via the MusicXML format [ 22 ] ), a methodological synthesis capable of identifying both recurring and unique patterns within the composer’s revisions is proposed. Unlike approaches that isolate individual elements such as melody, rhythm, or harmony, this study integrates multi-layered data. Specific attention is given to the text-music relationship to formally describe underlying compositional strategies. The results lay the foundation for a new perspective on the analysis of authorial variants, merging computational tools with classification, clustering, and predictive modeling applied to the entire set of works addressed as a cohesive whole. 2 Computational Proposal for Gioachino Rossini’s Variants The creative process (the path that transforms an initial idea into a finished work of art) is a field of inquiry that fascinates scholars across diverse disciplines, from the humanities and sciences to neuroscience. To peer into this ‘‘inner laboratory’’, tracing the mental, technical, and material trajectories of an artist, is to touch the very core of the aesthetic experience. In this context, authorial variants (the modifications, alternatives, and revisions a creator applies to their work) represent a tangible record of thought in action, and their study serves as a privileged methodology for observing this process. At the heart of the present research lies a case study that, by its very nature, challenges traditional philological disciplines: the vast and complex system of variants in Gioachino Rossini’s (1792--1868) settings of the arietta ‘‘Mi lagnerò tacendo’’ (MLT), from the libretto ‘‘Siroe, re di Persia’’ by Metastasio 1 1 1 The arietta from “Siroe” (Mi lagnerò tacendo / Del mio destino avaro / Ma ch’io non t’ami, o caro, / non lo sperar da me./ Crudele! In che t’offendo / Se resta a questo petto / Il misero diletto / Di sospirar per te? [I will lament in silence My cruel and miserly fate; But that I do not love you, my dear, Never hope for that from me. Cruel one! How do I offend you If in this breast remains The wretched pleasure Of sighing for you?]) achieved considerable success and was set to music by numerous composers besides Rossini, including, even before him, Mozart (in the Notturno K 437), Rossini’s first wife, Isabella Colbran, and her singing teacher, Girolamo Crescentini, as well as Felice Blangini. During the same years Rossini was using it, it was also set by his friend and collaborator, Giovanni Tadolini. (1698–1782) [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] . With approximately one hundred autograph versions known today, composed over an extended period between the 1830s and 1860s, this corpus does not constitute a sequence of preparatory drafts for a single final work. Instead, it forms a constellation of autonomous, finished realizations. Given the notorious scarcity of sketches and preparatory materials for Rossini’s grand operas, this corpus represents an invaluable document (an almost unique window into his creative workshop). Rossini’s settings of MLT are emblematic of a specific practice: these were not works for the general public, but musical cadeaux (personal gifts for friends, admirers, and patrons). They were deeply rooted in 19th-century salon culture, operatic fanaticism, and the burgeoning market for autograph collecting. As early as 1842, the Parisian musical journal “L’indépendant” noted more than one hundred such settings, a testament to the composer’s prolificacy. This insistence on a single text may also reveal a personal dimension, reflecting an “inner unease” during a period marked by professional transition and chronic health issues. The nature of this reticulated corpus eludes traditional philological frameworks. It does not fit the model of Italian “Authorial Philology” as defined in [ 29 ] , as each variant is a “released” work and an autonomous cadeau, rendering the notions of a “final intention” or unidirectional, successive choices problematic. Nor does it fully conform to French Genetic Criticism (critique génétique), which typically analyzes