Gravitational-wave constraints on H 0 H_{0} are robust to (putative) redshift evolution in the binary black hole mass spectrum at current sensitivity

Alessandro Agapito, Viola De Renzis, Michele Mancarella · 2026

Read Gravitational-wave constraints on H 0 H_{0} are robust to (putative) redshift evolution in the binary black hole mass spectrum at current sensitivity by Alessandro Agapito, Viola De Renzis, Michele Mancarella (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20112.txt.

Introduction

Alessandro Agapito, Viola De Renzis and Michele Mancarella test whether spectral-siren Hubble constraints survive redshift evolution of the black hole mass spectrum. Spectral sirens combine waveform distances with redshift information in mass-spectrum features, making the method sensitive to assumptions. With the GWTC-4.0 catalogue, letting main mass scales evolve with redshift, they find no evidence for evolution at current sensitivity. Evolution shifts the Hubble posterior downward, but not significantly. Constraints are thus robust to mass-spectrum redshift evolution at current sensitivity.

Catalog record

CREATORAlessandro Agapito, Viola De Renzis, Michele Mancarella
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81635
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20112

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational-wave constraints on H 0 H_{0} are robust to (putative) redshift evolution in the binary black hole mass spectrum at current sensitivity Alessandro Agapito, Viola De Renzis, Michele Mancarella Abstract Spectral-siren cosmology constrains the Hubble constant H 0 H_{0} using gravitational-wave observations of compact-binary coalescences. The method combines luminosity distances inferred from the waveform with redshift information statistically encoded in population features of the source-frame mass spectrum. Because the detector measures redshifted masses, structure in the intrinsic mass distribution acts as an internal “ruler”, making the inference sensitive to assumptions about the population model. In particular, redshift evolution of the mass spectrum is widely discussed as a potential systematic for H 0 H_{0} measurements. We revisit spectral-siren constraints with the GWTC-4.0 binary black hole catalog, explicitly allowing the main mass scales of a standard parametric mass model to evolve with redshift. We find no compelling evidence for evolution at current sensitivity. Allowing evolution produces a modest, non–statistically–significant shift of the H 0 H_{0} posterior toward lower values, which we interpret with targeted posterior and event-level diagnostics. Importantly, the associated systematic uncertainty is subdominant to that induced by alternative redshift-independent descriptions of the mass spectrum, such as the number of spectral features and the functional form used to model them. Our results indicate that, at current sensitivity, spectral-siren constraints on H 0 H_{0} are robust to redshift evolution of the mass spectrum within the flexibility explored here. Using injection studies, we show that this mild H 0 H_{0} shift is reproduced when a non-evolving underlying population is analyzed with an evolving model, consistent with an over-flexible population description at the present signal-to-noise. The sign and magnitude of the shift can, however, depend on detector sensitivity and redshift reach as the population features become increasingly constrained directly by the data, motivating targeted diagnostics for future catalogs. I Introduction Gravitational-wave (GW) observations of compact-binary coalescences provide an independent route to cosmology through the standard siren method Schutz 1986 ; Holz and Hughes 2005 : the strain amplitude directly encodes an absolute luminosity distance, d_{L} , inferred from the waveform with the binary’s intrinsic parameters. Combining distances with redshift information allows one to constrain the distance–redshift relation and therefore the Hubble constant H_{0} and, more generally, cosmological expansion and modified-propagation effects Belgacem et al. 2018a ; Belgacem et al. 2018b ; Belgacem et al. 2019 . This approach is complementary to electromagnetic distance ladders Riess et al. 2022 and to early-Universe probes Aghanim et al. 2020 , whose determination of H_{0} are currently in strong tension, and it is particularly valuable because it relies on different systematics. Most sources in the latest GW catalog released by the LIGO–Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) collaboration Aasi et al. 2015 ; Acernese et al. 2015 ; Akutsu et al. 2021 , GWTC-4.0 Abac et al. 2025a ; Abac et al. 2025b , are dark standard sirens, as their individual host galaxies are not identified and the redshift cannot be directly measured. In that case, redshift information must be obtained statistically. 1 1 1 The only exception is the binary neutron star (BNS) coalescence GW170817 Abbott et al. 2017a ; Abbott et al. 2017b , for which a coincident electromagnetic emission could be identified, leading to a direct measurement of H_{0} . Most of the cosmological information currently comes from spectral siren cosmology, in which the distribution of source-frame masses and redshifts is used to self-calibrate the redshift ( Taylor et al. 2012 ; Farr et al. 2019 ; Mastrogiovanni et al. 2021 ; Ezquiaga and Holz 2022 ) . The basic mechanism is that the detector measures redshifted (detector-frame) masses; converting to source-frame masses depends on (1+z) and therefore on cosmology. Distinct features in the mass spectrum—such as peaks or drops in the rate—act as “anchors” that correlate redshift with the observed spectrum, enabling cosmological inference without host identification. In particular, the most recent LVK analysis using the full GWTC-4.0 catalog relies largely on this principle Abac et al. 2025c . In those analyses, evidence is found for the mass distribution of Binary Black Holes (BBHs) to exhibit multiple features, including pronounced structure beyond a single power law (also evident in the related population analysis Abac et al. 2025d ), which is precisely what gives spectral sirens their leverage. At the same time, the reliance on population features makes the inference sensitive to assumptions about the BBH population model Pierra et al. 2024 ; Gennari et al. 2025 ; Abac et al. 2025c . Indeed, among the most discussed sources of systematic uncertainty for spectral-siren cosmology is the assumed form of the BBH mass function. LVK analyses Abbott et al. 2023a ; Abac et al. 2025c , and subsequent GWTC-4.0–based spectral-siren analyses Tagliazucchi et al. 2026a ; Pierra and Papadopoulos 2026 ; Bertheas et al. 2026 ; Gennari et al. 2026 (see also Mali and Essick 2025 for a thorough analysis on previous catalogs) so far have adopted redshift-independent mass distributions, and have explored the impact of adopting different functional forms which allow for more spectral features. An important complementary possibility, frequently raised in the literature Mukherjee 2022 ; Ray et al. 2023 ; Heinzel et al. 2025 ; Lalleman et al. 2025 ; Gennari et al. 2025 ; Tenorio et al. 2025 ; Afroz and Mukherjee 2025 , is that the BBH mass spectrum itself evolves with redshift. The observational status of BBH mass evolution and the impact on cosmology is currently open: analyses that fix cosmology generally find limited evidence for strong evolution in current catalogs Ray et al. 2023 ; Lalleman et al. 2025 ; Abac et al. 2025d ; Tenorio et al. 2025 ; Afroz and Mukherjee 2025 , while other works emphasize that even modest evolution can bias H_{0} when the mass model is used as the primary source of redshift information Mukherjee 2022 ; Agarwal et al. 2025 . This issue seems especially prominent in recent end-to-end mock-data studies that find population mis-modeling (specifically related to neglecting redshift evolution) to potentially propagate into cosmological posteriors Agarwal et al. 2025 ; Karathanasis et al. 2026 . In particular, even when population analyses at fixed cosmology report no evidence for redshift evolution of the BBH mass spectrum, such evolution might remain effectively hidden while still biasing spectral-siren H_{0} inference if not explicitly modeled Karathanasis et al. 2026 . These conclusions, however, depend on the assumed simulation setting. Motivated by these considerations, in this work we revisit GWTC-4.0 spectral-siren constraints on H_{0} while explicitly allowing for redshift evolution of the main scales of the BBH mass spectrum. We adopt a parametric primary-mass model matching the default LVK parametric choice Abac et al. 2025d , namely one that includes a broken power law plus two Gaussian peaks, and we allow the corresponding hyperparameters (peak locations and widths, power-law slopes and breaking point, and mixing fractions) to evolve smoothly with redshift through flexible transition functions, inspired by Ref. Lalleman et al. 2025 . First, we study the possibility of evolution assuming a fixed Planck cosmology Aghanim et al. 2020 . We then quantify how this additional freedom affects the inferred H_{0} relative to the redshift-independent baseline, and we present a set of diagnostics designed to make the effect of

Read the complete text