Language Mutations Sustain the Persistences of Conspiracy Theories on Social Media
Calvin Yixiang Cheng, Dorian Quelle, Scott A. Hale · 2026
Read Language Mutations Sustain the Persistences of Conspiracy Theories on Social Media by Calvin Yixiang Cheng, Dorian Quelle, Scott A. Hale (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-20050.txt.
Introduction
Calvin Yixiang Cheng, Dorian Quelle and Scott Hale track how conspiracy claims change wording over three years of posts on X. Claims with larger semantic mutations live substantially longer, and shifts in pronouns, social references, cognitive-process terms and risk- and health-related words all link to longer lifespans. Shifts in actor, action and target categories also extend lifespan, with simplification and assimilation as the two main mutation patterns. The authors argue moderation should weigh how mutable a claim is and target core claims that cover their likely variants.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Calvin Yixiang Cheng, Dorian Quelle, Scott A. Hale |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91967 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.20050
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Language Mutations Sustain the Persistences of Conspiracy Theories on Social Media Calvin Yixiang Cheng, Dorian Quelle, Scott A. Hale Abstract This study investigates how language mutations affect the persistent diffusion of conspiracy theories on social media. Drawing on a three-year dataset of conspiracy-related posts from X, and applying computational linguistic analysis alongside survival modelling, we find that conspiracy claims with greater semantic mutations have substantially longer lifespans. Mutations in psycholinguistic properties, including pronouns, social reference words, cognitive process terms, risk- and health- related vocabularies, are associated with extended lifespans. Mutations in actor, action and target (AAT) categories are associated with longer lifespans as well. Qualitative analysis identifies two predominant mutation patterns: simplification and assimilation, at both linguistic and AAT structural levels. Taken together, the results advance our understanding of how language mutations contribute to conspiracy persistence online and shed lights on longitudinal content moderation strategies. We argue that content moderation should consider the mutability of conspiracy claims and focus on the core claims that can address their potential variations. [orcid=0000-0003-4897-3293] cor1 keywords conspiracy theory ,persistence ,language mutation ,psycholinguistics ,actor-action-target † † credit: Conceptualization, literature review, study design, computation, writing. † † credit: Methodology, formal analysis, writing review and editing. † † credit: Supervision, methodology, writing review and editing. † † corresponding: Corresponding author 1 Introduction Conspiracy theories, defined as explanatory content that attribute social events to secret plots by malicious people [ 19 , 59 , 58 ] , have demonstrated surprising persistence on social media where many of them continue to re-emerge despite repeated debunking [ 2 , 5 , 20 ] . A notable pattern underlying this persistence is linguistic mutation during transmission: many conspiracy theories reappear in modified forms, undergoing explicit semantic and structural changes as they circulate online [ 49 , 50 ] . Prior research on persistence has primarily focused on individual psychological characteristics [ 17 , 54 ] or the viral diffusion of static content [ 61 ] . It remains unclear to what extent language mutations contribute to the persistent diffusion of conspiracy theories. 1 1 1 All scripts used in the analyses presented in this article is made available on the Open Science Framework (OSF) https://osf.io/usqxn/?view_only=64270fbc195e475381641a146316b59e repository to facilitate sharing and replication (Anonymous link for peer review). Language mutations refer to linguistic changes in information during transmission. They occur naturally in human communication systems. As information spreads, human transmitters often introduce various language changes, such as simplifying the content, selectively emphasizing linguistic elements, or distorting semantics to align with their prior beliefs [ 1 ] . 11 theorized such a phenomenon of language mutations as “systematic errors” in communication systems, arising from human cognitive constraints in perception, memory and information processing. Importantly, such mutations may sustain the persistent diffusion of information. By introducing variation and novelty, mutated misleading information can reduce information fatigue and renew audience attention [ 53 ] . This issue is particularly concerning in today’s digital environments, where social media platforms enable rapid, large-scale diffusion while simultaneously offering mechanisms for modification through, for example, quoting, and user-generated variants. These affordances create fertile ground for conspiracies to proliferate, adapt, and exert long-term impact [ 15 , 19 ] . Despite good theory, there is little empirical evidence quantifying the impact of language mutations on the persistent diffusion of conspiracy theories, and it is unclear what language features can predict such persistence. This paper addresses these gaps by empirically examining the relationship between language mutations in conspiracy claims and their persistence online. Using a dataset of 446,829 COVID-19 related conspiracy posts collected over three years from X (formerly Twitter), we analysed how mutations within conspiracy claims relate to their lifespan. In this work, we focused on the persistence of claims — a cluster of semantically similar conspiracy posts that can be debunked by a single fact-checking claim [ 28 ] . Mutations are examined at three analytical scales across various language granularities. Inspired by 56 ’s generative conspiracy framework, we operationalize mutation along three structured dimensions: semantic, psycholinguistic, and actor–action–target (AAT) mutations. Semantic mutations captures drift of conspiracy claims in embedding space, providing a fine-grained quantification of language mutation. Psycholinguistic mutations refer to changes in the distribution of vocabulary reflecting underlying psychological and cognitive states, such as emotional tone, moral judgment, and power dynamics. AAT mutations measure transformations in the narrative structure of claims by identifying changes in actors, actions, and targets categories. The persistence is modelled by survival analysis. Our findings show that language mutations are significantly associated with greater persistence. Claims exhibiting larger semantic mutations demonstrate substantially longer lifespans, with 27% higher likelihood to persist compared to non-mutating claims. Also, specific psycholinguistic and AAT category changes emerge as strong predictors of persistence. Moreover, our qualitative analyses reveal two prominent mutation patterns. These results advanced our understanding of how conspiracy claims adapt and persist on social media. They extend the information mutation framework to contemporary online communication contexts and offer practical implications for the detection and mitigation of persistent conspiracy theories. 2 Language Mutations and Persistent Diffusion Language mutations are widely observed among people’s engagements with conspiracy claims [ 29 , 49 , 46 , e.g.,] . These engagements can be broadly categorized into three types: duplicatory, translatory, and reductive [ 11 ] . Duplicatory transmission refers to the process where individuals intend to duplicate certain conspiracy claims. It is common during social crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic, when there were a lot of unknowns and uncertainties. For example, conspiracy claims such as “COVID is bioweapon from Wuhan lab” provided simple though false explanation for the situation and attracted much duplicatory transmission. Individuals may post, repost, like, or save these claims, leading to persistent diffusion. Translatory transmission refers to changing the modality of the input during output, but without an intended loss of complexity or information [ 11 ] . Many conspiracy claims circulate in multimedia forms beyond text, including memes, pictures, and videos. Translatory transmission can occur when individuals summarise a video in a text post, create an infographic from an article, or live-tweet a real-world event. Although the modality changes, the intent is usually to preserve the core meaning of the original content. Nevertheless, this process would also be shaped by users’ pre-existing knowledge and beliefs. Reductive transmission represents the transformation of complex input signals into simpler outputs. It involves user interpretation and assimilation and is often manifested through behaviours such as commenting, quoting, tagging, or adding hashtags, each of which can modify or reinterpret the original content. These actions can be shaped by a range of cognitive and emotional mechanisms, including the familiarity effect (where individuals are more likely to engage with familiar-sounding content) [ 48 , 47 ] , emotional contagion (where affective content elicits stronger reactions) [ 24 , 31 ] , moral arousal that prompts engagement [ 7 ] , and susceptibility to logical fallacies that reinforce conspiratorial thinking [ 54 ] . These language mutations may contribute to the persistent diffusion of conspiracy claims through two primary mechanisms: introducing novelty and reviving dormant memories. First, mutations can introduce novelty into existing claims, a factor shown to be critical for faster, deeper, and wider information diffusion in digital environments [ 61 ] .