Material for Thought: Generative AI as an Active Creative Medium Conference: CHI ’26 Tools for Thought Workshop; April 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction design theory, concepts and paradigms

Hugo Andersson, Niklas Elmqvist · 2026

Read Material for Thought: Generative AI as an Active Creative Medium Conference: CHI ’26 Tools for Thought Workshop; April 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction design theory, concepts and paradigms by Hugo Andersson, Niklas Elmqvist (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19832.txt.

Introduction

Andersson and Elmqvist argue generative AI should serve creative work as an active medium, not merely as a judgeable output. Decision support framing pushes people to evaluate correctness instead of exploring and shaping ideas. They turn to Schön's reflective practice: like a potter with clay, users shape, observe, stir and select their medium in ongoing conversation. Because generative AI tends toward convergence, human disruption and curation sustain creative quality. Their Loom probe, orchestrating simulated narrative agents in creative writing, illustrates the SOSS framework and its design implications.

Catalog record

CREATORHugo Andersson, Niklas Elmqvist
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20360
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19832

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Material for Thought: Generative AI as an Active Creative Medium Conference: CHI ’26 Tools for Thought Workshop; April 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction design theory, concepts and paradigms Hugo Andersson, Niklas Elmqvist Abstract . Human-AI collaboration research has largely positioned the human as a judge of AI output, centering effort on evaluating whether recommendations are reliable enough to accept. This decision-support framing leaves little room for the human as creator. We argue that for creative work, this framing misdirects human effort toward evaluating correctness rather than exploring and shaping the creative space. Drawing on Schön’s theory of reflective practice, we propose an alternative: treating generative AI as an active creative medium. As a potter works with clay, humans Shape, Observe, Stir, and Select ( SOSS ) their medium through ongoing conversation. Where generative AI actively tends toward convergence and resolution, the human role of disruption and curation becomes essential for sustaining creative quality. We present a creative writing probe, Loom , in which users orchestrate simulated narrative agents. We also introduce the SOSS framework for this mode of engagement, and discuss design implications. 1. Introduction What if generative AI is not a tool for thought, but the material for it? Large language models are no longer emerging technologies; they are routine tools and have become widespread in creative workflows ( 17 ) . The question is not whether writers, designers, and thinkers will work with generative AI, but whether the workflows we design around it will preserve or erode human agency, or at least keep a balance between the two. This makes the design of human-AI creative workflows a problem of today, not a speculative one. A potter does not command clay. They center it, press into it, feel how it resists and yields, and shape it through an ongoing exchange of intention and response. The clay has properties—weight, moisture, grain—that constrain and afford. It is not inert, but it has no agenda of its own. The creative act lives in the shaping: reading the material, recognizing possibility, knowing when to press and when to let the wheel carry. Schön, in his theory of reflective practice ( 14 ) , regards this as a conversation with the materials of the situation: the practitioner makes a move, the material talks back, and the practitioner responds to what they see and feel. The skill is not in planning the perfect action but in the interactive and emergent process between artist and medium. However, the prevailing approach to human-AI collaboration frames AI as an advisor and the human as a judge of its output, engaged in trust calibration ( 21 ; 19 ) : is this recommendation reliable enough to act on? This framing has driven extensive research into explainability, confidence communication, and decision support interfaces, all aimed at helping humans better assess when to rely on AI. Yet evidence suggests this approach is struggling. Bansal et al. found that AI explanations did not improve performance over simply displaying confidence; more troubling, explanations increased human agreement with AI recommendations regardless of their correctness ( 2 ) , suggesting that richer evaluative information may deepen rather than correct the problem. Buçinca et al. showed that cognitive forcing functions can reduce but not eliminate overreliance on AI, and that the most effective interventions were also the least preferred ( 3 ) . Zhang et al. found that while confidence scores can calibrate trust, even successful calibration failed to improve joint decision outcomes when human and AI error boundaries were aligned ( 21 ) . A recent meta-analysis consolidates these findings at scale: Vaccaro et al. synthesized 370 effect sizes across 106 experiments and found that human-AI combinations perform significantly worse than the best of human or AI alone ( 19 ) . However, Vaccaro et al.’s analysis also revealed a striking asymmetry. Decision tasks , where humans chose among options after receiving AI input, showed significant performance losses. Creation tasks , on the other hand, where humans generated open-ended content with AI, showed performance gains. The difference was statistically significant, yet creation tasks represented only about 10% of the studied configurations. Given this asymmetry, how should we design human-AI collaboration around shaping possibility rather than evaluating output? We propose AI as an active creative medium : systems in which AI does not advise a human decision-maker but simulates a possibility space that humans curate. Our contributions are: (1) a theoretical framing of generative AI as active creative medium, drawing on Schön’s reflective practice to reposition the human role from evaluator to orchestrator; (2) the SOSS framework (Shape, Observe, Stir, Select) operationalizing this mode of engagement; and (3) Loom , a creative writing probe in which authors orchestrate simulated narrative agents. 2. AI as Generative Medium What does it mean to treat generative AI as an active medium for creativity? We use medium to denote a mode of creative practice and material to denote the substance being worked: generative AI is the material, and orchestrating it constitutes the medium. The framing draws on Schön’s account of professional practice ( 14 ) . Schön argued that skilled practitioners do not solve problems by applying rules to well-defined inputs, but through an ongoing dialogue with their situation. An architect sketches a layout, reads what the sketch reveals, and revises; a therapist offers an interpretation, observes the client’s response, and adjusts. In each case, the practitioner’s expertise lies not in producing correct outputs but in sustaining a productive conversation with complex, responsive material. The idea that AI capabilities function as a design material is not new. Yang et al. explored how NLP presents unique challenges as a design material, requiring new sketching methods to reason about language interactions at appropriate levels of abstraction ( 20 ) . Kulkarni et al. found empirically that text-to-image prompts serve as reflective design material, facilitating the kind of exploration and iteration that Schön described ( 8 ) . Dalsgaard frames generative AI through pragmatist philosophy as providing “instruments of inquiry” that shape designers’ perception and conception of a problem space, while warning that the fidelity of AI outputs risks fixating designers on surface refinement rather than problem framing ( 4 ) . From cognitive science, Davis et al. proposed an enactive model of creativity grounded in the theory that creative cognition emerges through continuous, embodied interaction between agent and environment—not through planning followed by execution ( 6 ) . Their model foregrounds directives (vague creative intentions refined through interaction) over goals (linear plans), and emphasizes participatory sense-making as the locus of creative collaboration. Our framing builds on these foundations but addresses a challenge they did not face: the active convergence tendency of large language models. Where prior accounts of AI-as-material treat the material as essentially passive or neutral, generative AI actively drifts toward resolution. The medium framing therefore adds disruption and emergent recognition as first-class cognitive moves, operationalized in SOSS. Moreover, where Davis et al.’s enactive model positions human and computer as co-creative partners sharing the creative act, the medium approach maintains a clearer asymmetry: the human orchestrates the conditions for emergence while the AI simulates possibilities within those conditions. This preserves a form of authorial ownership that co-creative framings can

Read the complete text