Matrix structure and convergence behaviour of the matched eigenfunction method for computing heave wave forces on generalized concentric bodies

Yinghui Bimali \aff 1,†, Rebecca McCabe \aff 2,†, Collin Treacy \aff 3, Kapil Khanal \aff 4, En Lo \aff 5,6, Maha Haji \aff 2,3 · 2026

Read Matrix structure and convergence behaviour of the matched eigenfunction method for computing heave wave forces on generalized concentric bodies by Yinghui Bimali \aff 1,†, Rebecca McCabe \aff 2,†, Collin Treacy \aff 3, Kapil Khanal \aff 4, En Lo \aff 5,6, Maha Haji \aff 2,3 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19730.txt.

Introduction

Bimali, McCabe, Treacy, Khanal, Lo and Haji unify the matched eigenfunction method for wave forces on fixed or heaving ring-shaped offshore bodies. Traditional boundary-element solvers bottleneck on added mass, damping and excitation coefficients, while this semi-analytical alternative was never directly benchmarked against them. Their framework handles arbitrary numbers of annular cylinders with smooth radial profiles and maps its matrix structure and convergence. Slanted shapes land within five percent of the Capytaine solver, and convergence arrives an order of magnitude faster with far smaller matrices.

Catalog record

CREATORYinghui Bimali \aff 1,†, Rebecca McCabe \aff 2,†, Collin Treacy \aff 3, Kapil Khanal \aff 4, En Lo \aff 5,6, Maha Haji \aff 2,3
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE118886
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19730

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Matrix structure and convergence behaviour of the matched eigenfunction method for computing heave wave forces on generalized concentric bodies Yinghui Bimali \aff 1,†, Rebecca McCabe \aff 2,†, Collin Treacy \aff 3, Kapil Khanal \aff 4, En Lo \aff 5,6, Maha Haji \aff 2,3 Abstract Structural survival of offshore structures is crucial for the growing marine economy. Calculating the added mass, radiation damping, and excitation coefficients to quantify wave loads with the traditional boundary element method (BEM) presents a computational bottleneck. The matched eigenfunction expansion method (MEEM), a long-known but rarely-used alternative, offers computational benefits due to its semi-analytical nature. However, previous work fails to directly compare its accuracy and computational performance with BEM, leaving the extent of its utility unknown. Furthermore, the geometry-dependent convergence for cylindrical and slanted geometries has not yet been documented, making the method’s practicality for general geometries unclear. This paper presents a unifying MEEM framework for modelling an arbitrary number of fixed or heaving surface-piercing annular cylinders with continuous and radially-monotonic body profiles, and explores the method’s block matrix structure, convergence behaviour, ability to accurately approximate slanted geometries, and computational advantages over the BEM solver Capytaine. The numerical experiments show that MEEM can compute hydrodynamic coefficients of slanted geometries within 5% of Capytaine, even for angles as steep as 15 ∘ 15^{\circ} from vertical. Finally, MEEM can achieve 2% convergence of its hydrodynamic coefficients an order of magnitude faster than Capytaine with a matrix size two orders of magnitude smaller, making it a computationally effective alternative to traditional BEM solvers. These contributions enable hydrodynamic analysis of a broad range of shapes with increased speed and confidence, paving the way for future optimization studies to yield improved designs. \lefttitle Y. Bimali, R. McCabe, C. Treacy, K. Khanal, E. Lo, and M. N. Haji \righttitle Journal of Fluid Mechanics \corresau Rebecca McCabe, keywords Authors should not enter keywords on the manuscript, as these must be chosen by the author during the online submission process and will then be added during the typesetting process (see Keyword PDF for the full list). Other classifications will be added at the same time. 1 Introduction Linear potential flow theory is a simplification of the Navier-Stokes equations widely used to model wave-structure interactions. Early analytical solutions for the wave force on vertical cylindrical bodies under linear potential flow include solutions for infinite cylinders in infinite depth ( Havelock 1936 ) and bottom-mounted cylinders in finite depth ( Fuchs & MacCamy 1954 ) . Both take advantage of the separability of the Laplace equation in cylindrical coordinates. Fully analytical solutions are not available for truncated cylinders (those whose bottoms do not touch the sea floor) since it is impossible to analytically enforce continuity of potential between the water under the body and the water surrounding it. Yeung 1981 presents a semi-analytical method called the matched eigenfunction expansion method (MEEM) to address this challenge. The solution in each fluid region is obtained analytically in terms of unknown coefficients, and these coefficients are found numerically by enforcing continuity of potential and radial velocity at region boundaries. The method received thorough coverage in a recent analytical hydrodynamics textbook ( Chatzigeorgiou 2018 ) and has been extended to cover increasingly complex concentric geometries, including two truncated cylinders ( Mavrakos 2004 ; Chau & Yeung 2012 ) , three truncated cylinders ( Zhang et al. 2024 ) , damping plates ( Olaya et al. 2015 ) , and many cylinders approximating complex concentric bodies ( Kokkinowrachos et al. 1986 ) . Despite this interest from hydrodynamics researchers, MEEM has not been widely adopted by the offshore engineering community, likely due to the complexity of its implementation and the rise of boundary element method (BEM) software packages that are easier to use and applicable to arbitrary geometries, albeit more computationally costly. With the growing need for efficient hydrodynamic analysis tools to enable advanced design procedures like optimization, interest in MEEM has resurged, particularly in the offshore renewable energy space. Pavlidou & Angelides 2022 performed multi-objective optimization for a two-body wave energy converter (WEC) using MEEM to compute the hydrodynamic coefficients of a cylinder. Zhang et al. 2016 optimized the shape of the wetted surface of a point absorber WEC using MEEM to model cylindrical, hemispherical, paraboloid, and conical geometries. Mavrakos & Konispoliatis 2012 used MEEM to compute the first-order and mean second-order loads on a vertical axisymmetric oscillating water column WEC. However, the benefits of MEEM over traditional BEM solvers remain unclear, as the tradeoffs between accuracy and computational performance of the methods are seldom compared in the literature. Additionally, previous work does not directly address the convergence behaviour and angle-dependent discretization of slanted geometries, making its ability to accurately model more general geometries uncertain. This work presents a unifying MEEM framework that arranges equations into an organized sparse matrix structure. This framework is used to model an arbitrary number of fixed or heaving surface-piercing annular cylinders with continuous radially-monotonic profiles. The method’s convergence behaviour, ability to accurately approximate slanted bodies, and computational advantages over the BEM solver Capytaine are explored. The authors build on their preliminary work ( McCabe et al. 2024 ) and have developed an open-source Python package called OpenFLASH (Flexible Library for Analytical & Semi-analytical Hydrodynamics, ( Best et al. 2026a ; Best et al. 2026b ) ) that is used for numerical studies herein. Section 2 formulates the mathematics, unifies the aforementioned literature in a consistent notation, explains the method for an audience unfamiliar with analytical hydrodynamics, clarifies the block matrix structure and asymptotic behaviour for small and large frequencies, discusses numerical subtleties needed to avoid overflow and finite precision effects, and validates the results of OpenFLASH against those of Capytaine. Section 3 details the novel results of a convergence study and provides guidance on the number of terms required to achieve a desired accuracy for a given geometric configuration. Section 4 extends the method to bodies with slanted (conical) surfaces, evaluating the relationship between slant angle, geometric discretization resolution, and error in potential and forces. Finally, section 5 benchmarks computational runtime and accuracy and offers techniques to improve speed while preserving accuracy. We conclude in section 6 with a summary of findings and outlook on future work. 2 Mathematical Formulation and Validation The objective of this method is to determine the first-order hydrodynamic forces on a series of M fixed or heaving surface-piercing concentric annular cylinders, as shown in Fig. 1 . The internal fluid regions underneath each cylindrical ring are denoted by i_{1} , i_{2} , \dots,i_{M} . Each cylindrical ring can be an independent body or rigidly fixed to any other cylindrical ring. The external fluid region surrounding the body is denoted by e . The geometry of the m th internal region is defined in terms of the radius a_{m} measured from the axis of symmetry and the draft d_{m} measured from the mean free surface. The origin O is located at the intersection of the body axis of symmetry and the mean free surface of the fluid. It is assumed that a_{m+1}>a_{m} and d_{m}<h for all m , where h is the sea depth. This geometry can be used to model more general bodies by discretizing slanted sections into a

Read the complete text