Beyond Rational Illusion: Behaviorally Realistic Strategic Classification

Xinpeng Lv, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Chunyuan Zheng, Yikai Chen, Haoxuan Li, Yang Shi, Jinxuan Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Yuanlong Chen, Yuanxing Zhang, Shaowu Yang, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang · 2026

Read Beyond Rational Illusion: Behaviorally Realistic Strategic Classification by Xinpeng Lv, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Chunyuan Zheng, Yikai Chen, Haoxuan Li, Yang Shi, Jinxuan Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Yuanlong Chen, Yuanxing Zhang, Shaowu Yang, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19674.txt.

Introduction

Lv and team define behavior-based real-life strategic sorting, where agents gaming traits for better results stray from full reason. Existing models assume strictly logical agents, yet economics and mind study show real choices bend under thinking biases. Their Prospect-Guided Strategic Framework, grounded in prospect theory, recasts the Stackelberg play between agents and choice-maker around benefit-cost gaps, varied benchmarks and non-logical odds warps. Tests on fake and real sets show it as a behavior-based approach bridging machine learning and economics for more reliable use.

Catalog record

CREATORXinpeng Lv, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Chunyuan Zheng, Yikai Chen, Haoxuan Li, Yang Shi, Jinxuan Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Yuanlong Chen, Yuanxing Zhang, Shaowu Yang, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88604
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19674

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Beyond Rational Illusion: Behaviorally Realistic Strategic Classification Xinpeng Lv, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Chunyuan Zheng, Yikai Chen, Haoxuan Li, Yang Shi, Jinxuan Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Yuanlong Chen, Yuanxing Zhang, Shaowu Yang, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang Abstract Strategic classification (SC) studies the interaction between decision models and agents who strategically manipulate their features for favorable outcomes. Existing SC frameworks typically rely on the idealized assumption that agents are strictly rational. However, evidence from behavioral economics and psychology consistently shows that real-world decision-making is often shaped by cognitive biases, deviating from pure rationality. To formalize this limitation, we identify and define a new problem setting, termed the behaviorally realistic strategic classification problem , where agents’ strategic manipulations deviate from full rationality due to psychological biases. Motivated by the identified limitation, we propose the Prospect-Guided Strategic Framework (Pro-SF) to address the problem, a principled framework grounded in prospect theory to model and learn under behaviorally realistic strategic responses. Specifically, to capture behaviorally realistic strategic manipulations, our framework reformulates the Stackelberg-style interaction between agents and the decision-maker by incorporating three key mechanisms inspired by prospect theory, including the asymmetry between benefits and costs, different subjective reference points, and non-rational probability distortion. Experiments on synthetic and real-world datasets establish Pro-SF as a behaviorally grounded approach to strategic classification, bridging machine learning and behavioral economics for more reliable deployment in the real world. 1 Introduction Machine learning models are playing an increasingly critical role in diverse human-serving domains, such as hiring ( 61 ) , credit scoring ( 33 ) , and college admissions ( 38 ) . In such settings, individuals may strategically modify their observable features to obtain favorable decisions. This phenomenon reflects Goodhart’s Law ( 65 ) : “ When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure .” Once a model’s decision rule becomes known or anticipated, agents often engage in ’gaming’ behaviors to manipulate outcomes. For example, a loan applicant might temporarily inflate their reported income to appear more creditworthy. To anticipate such manipulations, strategic classification (SC) ( 24 ) provides a specialized machine learning (ML) framework by considering the Stackelberg-style interaction between decision makers and strategic agents ( 20 ; 64 ; 10 ) , serving as a key bridge between ML and social sciences. Figure 1 : Illustrative real-life scenarios of behavioral biases: (a) financial investment shaped by loss aversion, (b) credit scoring influenced by reference bias, and (c) disease screening affected by probability distortion. Given its growing influence, it is increasingly essential to critically examine the foundational principles of SC. To be specific, the framework of SC rests on a simplified assumption that agents are perfectly rational ( 24 ; 51 ) . Consequently, under this view, an agent modifies features if, and only if, the expected benefit outweighs the cost. However, like a double-edged sword, the assumption of fully rational agents might result in conflicts with realistic scenarios, as individuals often behave in ways that deviate sharply from rational utilities: • Example 1. In financial investment ( 2 ) , individuals often react more strongly to a potential $80 loss than to a potential $100 gain of equal probability. The same magnitude of outcome thus triggers disproportionate behavioral responses. • Example 2. In credit scoring ( 2 ) , consider loan approval requires applicants to exceed a threshold A . Those whose subjective reference point B is just below A tend to make marginal adjustments, whereas those far below the threshold usually forgo effort. • Example 3. In disease screening ( 12 ) , consider a rare disease with a true prevalence of only 0.5%. Although the objective probability of infection is negligible, some individuals persist in seeking repeated testing, subjectively inflating the small chance of illness. Unfortunately, the non-rational behaviors characterized in the three examples, i.e., asymmetry between the benefit and cost, behaviors based on different reference points, and distorted probability towards events, are not considered in conventional SC frameworks. More broadly, extensive evidence from behavioral economics and psychology shows that real-world decision making systematically deviates from rational optimization ( 7 ; 69 ; 34 ; 1 ) . Therefore, we highlight that the rational-agent assumption, while mathematically convenient, often collapses in real-world settings. This mismatch motivates the need for a refined SC framework to capture such realistic behavioral deviations more precisely, which raises a central research challenge: Can existing SC methods account for strategic manipulations shaped by psychological biases, beyond the conventional rational-utility paradigm? In response to this question, we first define behaviorally realistic strategic classification (BR-SC) as a new problem where agents’ manipulations reflect realistic behavioral patterns driven by psychological biases, rather than fully rational best-response rules. Accordingly, the classifier is designed to account for these manipulations, ensuring robustness in deployment. Fortunately, prospect theory ( 35 ) and followed behavioral economics highlight three pervasive mechanisms for realistic behaviors: (1) Loss aversion . Individuals tend to weigh potential losses more heavily than equivalent gains (see Fig. 1 (a)). (2) Reference bias . Individual decision depends on subjective reference points, which differ across individuals based on their personal circumstances, expectations, or prior experiences (Fig. 1 (b)). (3) Probability distortion . Individuals overweight small-probability events, showing a tendency to “gamble” on unlikely opportunities (see Fig. 1 (c)). These behavioral mechanisms result in two consequential failure modes for existing SC methods, over-defense and under-defense , which degrade robustness of decision models for SC (see detailed derivation in Sec. 4 ). Therefore, we propose the Prospect-Guided Strategic Framework (Pro-SF) to address the BR-SC problem. Pro-SF introduces a paradigm shift for SC by integrating three key principles (i.e., asymmetry between gains and losses, subjective reference points, and probability distortion) into the Stackelberg game framework of SC. This paradigm shift captures how agents actually manipulate their features in practice and redefines both the dynamics of agents’ strategic manipulation and the decision maker’s optimization objective. Our main contributions are summarized as follows: • We identify and formalize the limitations of the rational-agent assumption in strategic classification by introducing a new problem setting, termed behaviorally realistic strategic classification (BR-SC). We further characterize two failure modes induced by rational-agent modeling, namely over-defense and under-defense . • We propose the prospect-guided strategic framework (Pro-SF) , which integrates loss aversion, reference bias, and probability distortion into the Stackelberg game framework, providing a more realistic solution for strategic classification. • We conduct extensive experiments on synthetic and real-world datasets to demonstrate that Pro-SF achieves robust performance across diverse behavioral regimes. Ablation studies and sensitivity analyses further illustrate how each behavioral component contributes to robustness. 2 Related Work 2.1 Strategic Classification Strategic classification (SC) studies how individuals manipulate features to obtain favorable decisions ( 24 ) . Prior work largely focuses on designing decision rules that are robust to such manipulations ( 11 ; 62 ; 10 ; 26 ; 81 ; 68 ; 43 ; 46 ) , as well as leveraging strategic behavior to incentivize genuine improvement via causal or action-based formulations ( 50 ; 9 ; 31 ; 71 ; 14 ; 8 ; 74 ; 73 ; 78 ) . Related settings include performative prediction, where repeated deployment alters the data distribution ( 57 ; 60 ; 23 ; 48

Read the complete text