Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics

Laura Foini, Jorge Kurchan, Silvia Pappalardi · 2026

Read Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics by Laura Foini, Jorge Kurchan, Silvia Pappalardi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19450.txt.

Introduction

Foini, Kurchan and Pappalardi ask what classical hydrodynamics demands of a quantum system. Reading the quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem in the time domain blurs fine correlation detail over a Planckian timescale. Tracking that blur along rays inside the light cone for diffusion, telegraph and mixed equations, they find the cone splits into classical and quantum regions where correlation and response part sharply. Keeping a finite classical region as temperature falls forces the relaxation rate to stay at least Planckian, bounding diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity.

Catalog record

CREATORLaura Foini, Jorge Kurchan, Silvia Pappalardi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42077
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19450

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics Laura Foini, Jorge Kurchan, Silvia Pappalardi Abstract In this work we ask what the self-consistency of a classical hydrodynamic description imposes on a quantum system. The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem, when read in the time domain, acts as a blurring of the fine details of the correlation functions on a Plankian time-scale. We track this blurring along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations – diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph – and find that the interior of the cone splits into a classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation, and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. Preserving a finite classical region as the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. In this way, Planckian scaling of the diffusion constant emerges not as a quantum constraint on microscopic dynamics, but as the price a system pays to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures. I Introduction A central puzzle in quantum many-body physics is why so many strongly correlated materials 11 ; 7 – from cuprates to heavy fermions to cold-atom gases – relax on a timescale set only by temperature and Planck’s constant, \tau_{\mathrm{Pl}}\;=\;\frac{\hbar}{k_{B}T}\ . (1) Whenever transport, thermalisation or chaos takes place on a time of order \tau_{\mathrm{Pl}} , one speaks of a Planckian bound 28 ; 11 . The appearance of \hbar and k_{B}T , without any material-specific constant, hints at a universal minimal timescale. Several incarnations of this idea have been discussed in the literature. On the transport side, the Kovtun–Son–Starinets bound \eta/s\geq\hbar/(4\pi k_{B}) 16 sets a universal lower limit on shear viscosity over entropy density. On the chaos side, Maldacena–Shenker–Stanford proved that the quantum Lyapunov exponent obeys \lambda_{L}\leq 2\pi k_{B}T/\hbar 21 . More recently, bounds on the local equilibration time have been proposed 10 ; 9 ; 25 , and a Planckian bound on the dynamical entropy has also been conjectured 4 . Despite this abundance of examples, what actually enforces these bounds at the microscopic level has remained elusive. A different point of view was put forward in Refs. 27 ; 23 : many known bounds, including the bound on chaos, follow as a direct consequence of the quantum fluctuation–dissipation theorem (FDT) once it is rewritten in the time domain. In that formulation, the quantum FDT relates the symmetrised correlator C(x,t) , the response R(x,t) – or its integrated version \Psi(x,t) – and the regulated correlator F(x,t) through a blurring of fine time-details on the intrinsic scale \frac{1}{\Omega}\;=\;\frac{\hbar\beta}{\pi}=\frac{\tau_{\rm Pl}}{\pi}, (2) where \Omega is the first Matsubara frequency. In the classical limit \hbar\beta\to 0 the blurring reduces to a Dirac delta, and one recovers the usual classical fluctuation-dissipation relation. At finite \hbar\beta , this blurring irons out structures shorter than the Planckian time, and it is precisely this operation that gives rise to bounds on how fast correlators can decay or grow. The present work applies this perspective to hydrodynamics . While we require long-time diffusive behaviour, we also assume the existence of a light cone with velocity v that restricts the propagation of information within the causal region x\leq vt . The emergence of an effective light cone is generic in locally interacting many-body systems; in the quantum case it is formalised by the Lieb–Robinson bound 19 . Numerous analytical, numerical and experimental studies 3 ; 18 ; 22 ; 14 ; 6 ; 17 have confirmed the robustness of such light-cone-like spreading. The tension between diffusion and finite-speed propagation also appears in relativistic hydrodynamics 2 ; 26 and has been used to bound diffusivity beyond that context 10 . Our starting observation is simple: hydrodynamics – the coarse-grained dynamics of the few slow, conserved quantities – is inherently a classical description. Even if derived from a quantum microscopic theory, the resulting equations for density, momentum or energy do not carry any explicit factor of \hbar . The question we ask is: given a hydrodynamic equation, up to what temperatures can its diffusive solution be consistently viewed as classical correlators, i.e. as correlators for which the quantum FDT reduces to its classical form? As an illustration, we study the dynamics on rays x=avt inside the light cone ( 0<a<1 ), using three representative phenomenological equations for a conserved density: the diffusion equation (instantaneous propagation), the telegraph equation (finite relaxation time, finite speed v , hard light cone) and the diffusive-telegraph equation (a softer version of the latter). In all of them the long-time behaviour of the correlator on a ray takes the form C(x=avt,t)\;\sim\;e^{-\lambda(a)\,t}\ , (3) with a rate \lambda(a) that vanishes as \lambda(a)=\lambda a^{2} on the time axis and grows as one approaches the light cone. Matching to the diffusive regime identifies \lambda=v^{2}/(4D) . The form ( 3 ) is compatible with a quadratic small- a structure of the large-deviation function, preserving an effectively diffusive (Gaussian) hydrodynamic core. The time-scale \lambda^{-1} can be seen as the relaxation time of the current introduced to correct the instantaneous Fick’s law; it is responsible for the emergence of a light-cone front, as in relativistic hydrodynamics 12 . The resulting picture is summarised in Fig. 1 . The Planckian blurring imposed by the quantum FDT is irrelevant whenever C(t),F(t),\Psi(t) vary slowly: there F\simeq C\simeq T\Psi , and the form of hydrodynamics is unaffected by quantum fluctuations. Conversely, when ( 3 ) enforces a rapid temporal variation, the blurring dominates: the other functions acquire a Planckian rate \Omega in some spatio-temporal regime, very different from the diffusive growth originally postulated. In the models we consider, the boundary between the two regimes is a critical ray x=a_{c}vt , inside which diffusive hydrodynamics can be read classically. Three scenarios occur: • a_{c}\to 1 (when \lambda^{-1}\gg\tau_{\rm Pl} ), the system is classical throughout the light cone; • a_{c}\to 0 (when \lambda^{-1}\ll\tau_{\rm Pl} ), the system is quantum for all rays; • a_{c} finite (when \lambda^{-1}\sim\tau_{\rm Pl} ) a critical cone separates the two regime. Since \lambda(a)\sim a^{2}v^{2}/(4D) at small a , demanding that a_{c} remain finite as T\to 0 imposes \frac{v^{2}}{4D}\;\lesssim\;\Omega\;=\;\frac{\pi}{\hbar\beta}\ , (4) a Planckian bound. The main novelty of the present perspective is that this scaling is not an extra quantum constraint imposed on top of hydrodynamics, but the minimal requirement for diffusive hydrodynamics to remain classical at low temperature in a finite region of space-time. x t \bm{x=vt} x=a_{c}vt classical hydro diffusive LD quantum quantum Figure 1: Cartoon of the mechanism. Inside the hydrodynamic light cone |x|<vt , correlators decay exponentially along a ray x=avt with a rate \lambda(a) that vanishes on the time axis and grows toward the cone. Starting from a classical large-deviation ansatz, the quantum FDT blurs the fine time-details at the Planckian scale \hbar\beta/\pi . Inside the inner (blue) cone the blurring is irrelevant and different correlation functions that classically coincide at equilibrium remain so. Beyond this boundary the blurring dominates: the constraints imposed by the quantum FDT, the presence of the light cone, and diffusivity compete and the resulting dynamics is Planckian. Keeping the classical region finite as \hbar\beta\to\infty forces v^{2}/D to be of order \Omega . The paper is organised as follows. In the

Read the complete text