PAVE: A Cognitive Architecture for Legitimate Violation in Generative Agent Societies

Ahmad Yehia, Abduallah Mohamed, Kun Qian, Tianyi Wang, Jiseop Byeon, Omar Hassanin, Christian Claudel, [6pt] The University of Texas at Austin · 2026

Read PAVE: A Cognitive Architecture for Legitimate Violation in Generative Agent Societies by Ahmad Yehia, Abduallah Mohamed, Kun Qian, Tianyi Wang, Jiseop Byeon, Omar Hassanin, Christian Claudel, [6pt] The University of Texas at Austin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19351.txt.

Introduction

Ahmad Yehia and colleagues ask when language-model agents may break rules in a genuine emergency, such as a fire evacuation. Their PAVE design splits the choice into four stages. It senses context, scores necessity and proportionality, then issues a comply-or-violate verdict under a hard legitimacy gate. It scopes any breach to the justified rule alone. In a traffic town, across three scenarios and four backbones, PAVE agents violate only with justification, defer to officers, stay bounded, and recover, beating vanilla agents on all four counts.

Catalog record

CREATORAhmad Yehia, Abduallah Mohamed, Kun Qian, Tianyi Wang, Jiseop Byeon, Omar Hassanin, Christian Claudel, [6pt] The University of Texas at Austin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72166
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19351

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

PAVE: A Cognitive Architecture for Legitimate Violation in Generative Agent Societies Ahmad Yehia, Abduallah Mohamed, Kun Qian, Tianyi Wang, Jiseop Byeon, Omar Hassanin, Christian Claudel, [6pt] The University of Texas at Austin Abstract Generative agents based on large language models reproduce believable human behavior in cooperative settings, but how they should reason in situations where rule-breaking may be required, such as fire evacuation or authority-supervised emergency, remains poorly characterized. We propose Pave (Perception, Assessment, Verdict, Emulation), a novel four-module cognitive architecture that addresses this gap end to end: (i) Perception extracts a structured context with explicit authority distance, peer behaviors, and severity-tagged situational cues; (ii) Assessment scores the context along five scalars including an explicit legitimacy judgment that checks necessity, proportionality, and absence of alternatives; (iii) Verdict decides to comply or violate under a hard legitimacy gate, with a per-agent threshold elicited from the persona; (iv) Emulation enacts the verdict and scopes the violation to the rule the trigger justifies. We instantiate Pave in Voville , a tile-based traffic environment forked from Smallville, and evaluate across three scenarios, four LLM backbones, and a focused ablation. Pave agents satisfy four properties simultaneously: legitimate violation (only when a trigger justifies it), authority deference (officer instructions override even high legitimacy), bounded scope (violations confined to the targeted rule), and recovery (baseline restored once the trigger ends). Pave agents make more structured and interpretable decisions than vanilla across all four properties, and human evaluators rate them as more plausible. Ablating the legitimacy gate reproduces vanilla-like failures. We release Voville , the Pave prompts and code, and the evaluation pipeline. 1 Introduction Generative Agents have demonstrated impressive abilities to simulate human behavior across wide complex domains ranging from competitive games to medical diagnostics ( 19 ; 28 ; 29 ) . The landmark paper on Generative Agents ( 18 ) showed that large language model (LLM)-driven agents can reproduce believable human behavior in a shared sandbox. This result has sparked a broader effort to model social dynamics through LLM systems. While LLMs have achieved human-level performance on many basic tasks, their ability to handle complex decision-making and survival-driven scenarios remains limited ( 22 ) . For instance, during a fire evacuation or a flood, should an LLM-powered self-driving car violate a red traffic light to escape safely, or wait and act in accordance with traffic rules? Such scenarios demand reasoning beyond language, involving ethical trade-offs among compliance, urgency, and authority. Understanding how LLM agents behave in such contexts, where norm or rule violations are sometimes necessary, is essential to deploying them safely. Figure 1: Two motivating scenarios for Pave . (a) Fire emergency: agents cross against the red signal to escape, and decline to take an unattended bike. (b) Peer pressure with authority: a Pave pedestrian resists a scripted jaywalker (yellow bubble), and a Pave driver defers to a traffic officer’s signal. Yellow bubbles are scripted Non Player Characters (NPCs), and gray ones are Pave reasoning traces. Prior work on Generative Agent societies has concentrated almost exclusively on norm compliance and cooperation. Recent studies have shown that multi-agent systems (MASs) can reproduce believable social behaviors such as spreading party invitations ( 18 ) , propagating positive norms through observation ( 25 ) , sustaining cooperation under resource pressure ( 20 ) , and solving complex coding tasks ( 13 ) . However, prior studies show that LLMs do not adequately understand when norms or rules should be suspended or overridden ( 23 ; 12 ) . In addition, existing MASs focus almost entirely on cooperative settings and overlook how rule violations reshape social dynamics. It remains largely unaddressed whether the social fabric recovers once the triggering condition subsides, or whether the violation leaves lasting effects on inter-agent trust. To address these gaps, we introduce Pave , a novel cognitive architecture for Generative Agents with four modules: P erception, A ssessment, V erdict, and E mulation. Pave extended the memory–reflection–planning loop of 18 to test whether Generative Agents reproduce the human dynamics of rule-breaking in spatially grounded settings. Specifically, through the Perception module, agents observe the rule in force and the surrounding context, including the presence of other agents, hazards, and authority figures. Through the Assessment module, agents weigh the competing pressures of urgency, peer behavior, and authority proximity against the salience of the rule. With the Verdict module, agents decide whether to comply or violate, producing an observable action. Lastly, the Emulation module allows nearby agents to witness the action and update their own subsequent assessments, closing the loop of behavioral contagion. To support this investigation, we extended the Smallville sandbox of 18 into Voville , a generative agent-based simulation of traffic rule violation under emergency, peer influence, and authority. Unlike Smallville agents, which reason over GPT-narrated scene descriptions, Voville agents perceive tile-level position and nearby tile state directly from the sandbox environment. Figure 1 shows Pave agents reasoning through two such scenarios. In this study, within Voville , we designed three scenarios and a five-condition ablation, tested across four LLM backbones. The scenarios isolated (1) emergency-driven violation, in which we measured whether agents violated traffic rules to escape, and whether compliant behavior recovered once the hazard subsides; (2) authority suppression, in which we examined how authority suppressed violation by stationing traffic officers along the evacuation route; and (3) peer contagion, in which we explored whether agents resisted peer-driven imitation by seeding the focal intersection with scripted jaywalkers under time pressure. In summary, our contributions are as follows: 1. We propose and open-source Pave , a novel Generative Agent cognitive architecture that jointly models emergency-triggered rule violation, peer contagion, and authority suppression, extending the work of 18 with dedicated rule-violation reasoning modules. 2. We release Voville , a spatially grounded Generative Agent simulation environment adapted from the Smallville sandbox with tile-level traffic infrastructure, enabling physically observable compliance and violation events rather than purely conversational ones. 3. Through ablation across three scenarios, five conditions, and four LLM backbones, we characterize the conditions under which Generative Agents violate and suppress rule-breaking, revealing how each Pave module contributes to the full loop of violation. 2 Related Work 2.1 Generative Agents and the Simulation of Human Behavior A growing body of research uses LLM-driven agents to simulate human behavior in social and decision-making contexts ( 18 ; 19 ) . Horton ( 14 ) argued that LLMs can be treated as homo silicus , implicit computational models of humans usable as proxies for the populations they mimic. Manning and Horton ( 16 ) further showed that theory-grounded instructions let LLM agents generalize to new environments and predict human behavior more accurately than standard behavioral and game-theoretic baselines. 18 introduced the foundational architecture, combining a memory stream, reflection, and recursive plan decomposition to produce believable behavior in a sandbox inspired by The Sims. A parallel line of work investigates how multi-agent populations of LLM-driven agents interact freely to produce collective social dynamics, with applications to opinion dynamics ( 8 ) , trust games ( 26 ) , negotiation ( 4 ) , and the encoding of social norms and values ( 27 ; 6 ) . 2 showed that LLM populations develop shared conventions, but small adversarial minorities can flip

Read the complete text