Looking at the Entropy in a Proton through a QGP Lens Preprint: MIT-CTP/6037

Dmitri E. Kharzeev, Krishna Rajagopal · 2026

Read Looking at the Entropy in a Proton through a QGP Lens Preprint: MIT-CTP/6037 by Dmitri E. Kharzeev, Krishna Rajagopal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19058.txt.

Introduction

Dmitri Kharzeev and Krishna Rajagopal track plasma heat as it cools into protons. Big Gibbs heat can not just fade; it shifts into plain hadron gas heat plus quantum links in each hadron. Bound bit tangle heat homes this shifted heat, squaring the drop with the second law. Three counts, from deep probe hits, proton wave shapes and Hagedorn tones, put proton tangle heat near its plasma drop heat.

Catalog record

CREATORDmitri E. Kharzeev, Krishna Rajagopal
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45745
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19058

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Looking at the Entropy in a Proton through a QGP Lens Preprint: MIT-CTP/6037 Dmitri E. Kharzeev, Krishna Rajagopal Abstract We investigate the interplay between the thermodynamic (Gibbs) entropy of quark–gluon plasma (QGP) and the quantum entanglement entropy characteristic of confined hadronic states across the quark–hadron phase transition. In the deconfined regime, entropy is well described by the statistical mechanics of colored quarks and gluons. Upon hadronization, however, the macroscopic Gibbs entropy of the plasma cannot simply vanish; instead, it is reorganized into the configurational entropy of a gas of colorless hadrons together with quantum correlations among the confined partons within each hadron. We show that the entanglement entropy of the internal partonic wave functions inside hadrons provides a natural repository for this “converted” thermodynamic entropy, reconciling the apparent reduction of macroscopic entropy with the second law of thermodynamics. Either by extrapolating from known facts about deep inelastic scattering, or starting from model descriptions of the proton wave function, or starting from the Hagedorn spectrum of its resonances, we provide three estimates of the magnitude of the entanglement entropy carried by a proton, with very different uncertainties. All three estimates indicate that the internal entanglement entropy of the proton is similar in magnitude to the Gibbs entropy of the QGP droplet from which the proton formed as QGP cools through the quark-hadron transition, as for example throughout the universe microseconds after the Big Bang. These results suggest that entanglement entropy offers a bridge between the quantum information content of hadronic states and the thermodynamic entropy of the quark–gluon plasma, providing a new lens on the microscopic mechanism of confinement and the nature of the QCD phase transition. I Introduction The first protons in the Universe formed from hot quark-gluon plasma (QGP) around ten microseconds after the Big Bang as the universe cooled through the QCD crossover temperature T_{c}\sim(155-160) MeV and the strongly coupled liquid QGP that filled the universe fell apart into a mist of hadrons. In this poetic sense, protons are born from QGP. But, does it make sense to think of protons as being made of QGP? Can protons be thought of as (very small) droplets of the primordial QGP from which they first formed? The energy density of a proton is comparable to that of QGP at or just above T_{c} and, as we shall discuss in Section III , lattice QCD calculations [ 35 , 36 , 16 ] and electron-scattering data [ 31 , 10 , 26 , 32 ] suggest that to the extent that the proton has an interior pressure it is comparable to the pressure of QGP at a temperature that we shall call T_{p} , with T_{p}\gtrsim T_{c} . Nevertheless, most would say that protons can be thought of as droplets of QGP only in a poetic sense because QGP is hot, with significant thermodynamic entropy, whereas protons are zero temperature pure states, eigenstates of the Hamiltonian of QCD. These considerations can, however, be turned on their head. If we take the poetic view seriously, we must ask about the apparent “entropy deficit”. Since protons formed from droplets of a high entropy liquid, where has the thermal entropy that they inherited from the hot QGP gone? How is the thermodynamic Gibbs entropy of the QGP from which the first protons formed reconciled with the quantum properties of confined hadrons, while respecting the second law of thermodynamics? In this paper, we propose that the missing entropy is reorganized into entanglement entropy carried by the partonic wave functions inside hadrons. This perspective provides a natural link between QCD thermodynamics and quantum information in QCD. After some further introduction to the conceptual basis for our considerations in Section II , we begin in Section III by taking the poetic question seriously and asking how much thermodynamic entropy each proton inherits from the QGP of which it formed. We find that, via this logic, each proton should have an entropy S_{\rm thermal}\sim(5-8)k_{B} . How does this compare to the entanglement entropy between one parton in a proton wave function and the rest of the partons in the proton? In previous literature [ 19 , 23 ] , the longitudinal component of the entanglement entropy has been estimated, and is \sim 2~k_{B} for partons with large longitudinal momentum fraction x whereas it is \gtrsim 3~k_{B} when one boosts to high rapidity and includes partons with smaller x . Since the complete entropy should reflect our ignorance of the transverse position and momentum of each parton as well as of their longitudinal position and momentum, and since there is no transverse analogue of boosting to high rapidity, the simplest estimate for the transverse entanglement entropy is that it should be roughly twice the large- x longitudinal entropy. Adding the longitudinal and transverse contributions yields the crude estimate that the entanglement entropy of a parton in the proton wave function is S^{(p)}_{\rm entanglement}\gtrsim 7k_{B} . In Section IV , we shall come at this from a different starting point, estimating the entanglement entropy inside a single proton using basic known facts about the internal structure of the proton in QCD, finding S^{(p)}_{\rm entanglement}\gtrsim(7-8)k_{B} — consistent with the crude estimate. Then, in Sections V and VI , we shall come at this from yet a third starting point that can be thought of as picturing the internal entropy of a proton as being in a certain sense both thermal and entanglement entropy. We start by taking seriously the notion that the proton has an effective internal temperature, which is to say that its reduced density matrix after tracing over unobserved degrees of freedom can be approximated as thermal, and use this as well as what is known about the Hagedorn density of resonance excitations of the proton to estimate its internal entanglement entropy. We show in Sections V and VI that positing such a perspective leads us to an alternative estimate of the entanglement entropy within a proton, S^{(p)}_{\rm entanglement}\sim(5-9)k_{B} . The three estimates that we have made of the entanglement entropy S^{(p)}_{\rm entanglement} of protons today are all qualitative, but the origins of the dominant uncertainties in each estimate are completely different. And, all three estimates are strikingly similar in magnitude to each other and to the thermal entropy S_{\rm thermal} of the droplet of QGP from which protons formed microseconds after the Big Bang. This suggests that there is no entropy deficit at all: entropy is in fact a common thread across the QCD transition, although the way in which it is woven into the fabric of the universe changes. With this perspective, entropy from the hot Big Bang is converted into entanglement entropy within protons (and other hadrons) as they form at the QCD phase transition. Billions of years later, when experimentalists collide nuclei at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) or the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), they are liberating the entanglement entropy within the incident protons and neutrons — as well as creating additional entropy — all of which becomes the thermodynamic entropy of the droplet of hot QGP created in a heavy ion collision. Or, when an experimentalist does a deep inelastic scattering experiment by measuring the scattered electron and gaining information about the longitudinal

Read the complete text