Dynamic Gradient-Based Calibration for Robust and Accurate Traffic Macrosimulation
Shreyaa Raghavan, Cameron Hickert, Monica Chan, Cathy Wu · 2026
Read Dynamic Gradient-Based Calibration for Robust and Accurate Traffic Macrosimulation by Shreyaa Raghavan, Cameron Hickert, Monica Chan, Cathy Wu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19056.txt.
Introduction
Shreyaa Raghavan, Cameron Hickert, Monica Chan and Cathy Wu swap one shot traffic tune for a rolling view. Plain one shot fits on bumpy cost land oft yield wobbly fake traffic, denting trust and what if tests. Cast as a live control task, fits hold shape and truth amid noise. On real I-24 MOTION data, the live view lifts forecast truth by forty eight percent and stands up better to knocks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shreyaa Raghavan, Cameron Hickert, Monica Chan, Cathy Wu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27938 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19056
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dynamic Gradient-Based Calibration for Robust and Accurate Traffic Macrosimulation Shreyaa Raghavan, Cameron Hickert, Monica Chan, Cathy Wu Abstract Robust and accurate calibration of macroscopic traffic flow models such as METANET is critical for reliable prediction and effective control. While gradient-based methods are desirable for high-dimensional parameter spaces, their application to real-world traffic scenarios is hindered by highly nonconvex optimization landscapes. Consequently, standard static calibration frequently yields parameter sets that produce unstable, unrealistic traffic dynamics, undermining confidence in the estimated parameters and compromising the simulation’s utility for counterfactual scenario testing. To address this, we propose a dynamic, rolling-horizon calibration framework. By reformulating static one-time estimation into a dynamic control problem, parameters better maintain stability and accuracy amid measurement noise. Using real-world data from the I-24 MOTION testbed, this work empirically characterizes the instability of standard methods. It then shows that the proposed approach simultaneously enhances robustness to perturbations and achieves a 48% improvement in predictive accuracy over conventional static calibration. I Introduction Traffic simulation is foundational to the design, assessment, and management of Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS). Among the available modeling paradigms, macroscopic simulations—which aggregate traffic behavior into continuous fluid dynamics rather than tracking individual vehicles—are particularly valuable due to their fast computation times and scalability. Various studies rely on macroscopic models for traffic state estimation and control [ 14 ] , with METANET emerging as one of the most popular and performant models [ 9 , 12 ] . The validity of any traffic macrosimulation is predicated upon its effective calibration. Gradient-based optimization methods are desirable for this task. Compared to gradient-free alternatives, gradient-based methods can scale much more efficiently when dealing with the high-dimensional parameter spaces inherent to complex traffic networks [ 2 , 17 ] . However, standard gradient-based calibration often struggles when applied to real-world scenarios with multi-segment networks and noisy data [ 16 ] . The parameter landscapes of macroscopic models like METANET in these settings are highly nonlinear and extremely nonconvex. As a result, gradient-based approaches frequently converge to local minima, yielding parameter sets that produce unstable and unrealistic traffic dynamics [ 4 ] . As a result of the challenges posed by the optimization landscape, we show that a calibrated METANET may exhibit a severe sensitivity to variations in boundary conditions. Even tiny perturbations or system noise can rapidly destabilize the simulated traffic state or generate nonphysical behaviors. Under standard static calibration, where parameters are fixed over time, these small disturbances can compound, compromising the simulation’s utility for counterfactual scenario testing and undermining confidence in the estimated parameters. While preliminary observations of this instability have been noted in the literature (e.g., in [ 12 ] ), many studies calibrating METANET do not explicitly account for this sensitivity. This tendency often arises naturally from the standard practice of treating calibration as an isolated, one-time estimation task. By focusing on fitting models to historical training datasets, static approaches can inadvertently bypass the need for out-of-sample stress testing against dynamic, real-world noise. To address these limitations, this paper proposes shifting from static parameter estimation to a dynamic approach. This method is motivated by the observation that traffic model parameters, such as capacity, free flow speed, and headway, are not in fact fixed over time, but in reality, they vary with exogenous features such as weather, sun exposure, and time of day [ 8 ] . Literature in traffic state estimation has also shown that methods that adapt to external, time-varying conditions perform better than a fixed estimator [ 18 ] . We extend this to macrosimulation calibration, where instead of a one-time optimization problem, we treat it as a dynamic calibration problem where parameters vary over time and solve it using a rolling-horizon optimization framework to prevent myopic parameter selections. Beyond allowing for a more expressive model, this dynamic formulation also improves the robustness of the calibrated macrosimulation since each calibration step is solved over a shorter horizon, potentially allowing the solver to search an easier and smoother landscape. We show that by dynamically assigning METANET parameters that change over time, the simulation is able to better replicate traffic phenomena of interest and do so under nontrivial amounts of measurement noise. This paper makes three main contributions: • Empirical characterization of instability: We empirically characterize the instability and sensitivity to perturbations inherent in standard, gradient-based calibration of the METANET macroscopic model. • Methodological reformulation: We reformulate macroscopic model calibration from a static, fixed-parameter estimation task into a dynamic control problem and solve this using a rolling-horizon approach. • Real-world validation: Using real-world trajectory data from the I-24 Mobility Technology Interstate Observation Network (MOTION) testbed, we demonstrate that the proposed dynamic calibration method simultaneously enhances model robustness to perturbations and achieves a 48% improvement in predictive accuracy over conventional static calibration. II Background II-A METANET METANET was proposed in [ 11 ] and is both popular and performant. The original paper has over 700 citations. The benchmarking work in [ 12 ] found METANET to substantially outperform the six other macroscopic traffic models evaluated. It is a discrete-time, link-based model, meaning the highway section of interest is split into links of equal length L and the macroscopic traffic variables—density ( \rho ), velocity ( v ), and flow ( q )—are tracked for each link \ell\in\mathcal{L} at each time step t\in\mathcal{T} . The explicit dynamics equations of METANET are as follows: \displaystyle\rho_{t+1}(\ell) \displaystyle=\rho_{t}(\ell)+\frac{\delta}{L\lambda_{\ell}}\left(q_{t}(\ell-1)-\frac{q_{t}(\ell)}{1-\beta_{\ell}}+r_{t}\right), (1) \displaystyle v_{t+1}(\ell) \displaystyle=v_{t}(\ell)+\frac{\delta}{\tau}(V[\rho_{t}(\ell)]-v_{t}(\ell)) (2) \displaystyle\quad\quad+\frac{\delta}{L}\,v_{t}(\ell)\left(v_{t}(\ell-1)-v_{t}(\ell)\right) \displaystyle\quad\quad-\frac{\nu\delta}{\tau L}\frac{\rho_{t}(\ell+1)-\rho_{t}(\ell)}{\rho_{t}(\ell)+\kappa}, \displaystyle q_{t}(\ell) \displaystyle=\rho_{t}(\ell)v_{t}(\ell)\lambda_{\ell}, (3) \displaystyle V[\rho_{t}(\ell)] \displaystyle=v_{free}\exp\left[-\left(\frac{1}{a}\frac{\rho_{t}(\ell)}{\rho_{cr}}\right)^{a}\right], (4) with all METANET parameters not defined above described in Table 1. TABLE I: Parameter Definitions for METANET Parameter ( ∗ indicates parameter is subject to calibration) \delta Simulation time step in seconds L Segment length of each cell in km \tau^{*} Relaxation time constant \eta^{*} Anticipation coefficient \kappa^{*} Numerical stability constant a^{*} Exponential shape of fundamental diagram v_{free}^{*} Free flow speed of vehicles \rho_{cr}^{*} Critical density of the highway ( \rho>\rho_{cr} triggers congestion) \lambda_{\ell} Number lanes in segment \ell \beta_{\ell}^{*} Turning ratio if an off-ramp exists at link \ell r_{\ell}^{*} On-ramp inflow if an on-ramp exists at link \ell Parameters such as \delta and L are not subject to calibration and are selected to satisfy the Courant-Freidrichs-Lewy (CFL) Condition: \frac{L}{\delta}\geq v_{\text{free}} . \delta and L are also contingent on the fidelity of data available and desired granularity of simulation. Values for network-based parameters \lambda_{\ell} , \beta_{\ell} , and r_{\ell} are typically retrieved from network files (for lane counts and ramp locations) and ramp detector data (for turning ratios and on-ramp inflows). However, in this work, we assume that ground truth ramp data is unavailable or unreliable, which is often the case [ 13 ] . Therefore, we allow for the calibration of \beta and r along with the other 6 parameters. II-B Standard macrosimulation calibration Traditionally, macroscopic traffic simulation calibration is treated as an offline, nonlinear optimization problem. The goal is to find a single, optimal set of parameters that minimizes the discrepancy between simulated outputs and historical field data over a fixed time horizon H . While theoretically this may be done with gradient-based or gradient-free methods, in practice for multi-segment models with real-world data, gradient-based methods have been found to struggle and gradient-free methods have been preferred