Guardrail Selection in Line Charts to Contextualize Persuasive Visualizations Volume: 45 Issue: 3
K. A. Nadib 1 M. Kogan 1 A. Lex 2,1 M. Lisnic 3 1 University of Utah, USA 2 Graz University of Technology, Austria 3 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, USA · 2026
Read Guardrail Selection in Line Charts to Contextualize Persuasive Visualizations Volume: 45 Issue: 3 by K. A. Nadib 1 M. Kogan 1 A. Lex 2,1 M. Lisnic 3 1 University of Utah, USA 2 Graz University of Technology, Austria 3 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, USA (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-19017.txt.
Introduction
Khandaker Abrar Nadib, Marina Kogan, Alexander Lex and Maxim Lisnic test guard lines in charts that push a view. Such lines, set right in a chart, can blunt cherry picked data and sly captions that fool readers. Late fact checks land too late, since held views stick. In a planned study of COVID and stocks charts, guard lines raised trust, rank sense and full context sense.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | K. A. Nadib 1 M. Kogan 1 A. Lex 2,1 M. Lisnic 3 1 University of Utah, USA 2 Graz University of Technology, Austria 3 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, USA |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62274 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.19017
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Guardrail Selection in Line Charts to Contextualize Persuasive Visualizations Volume: 45 Issue: 3 K. A. Nadib 1 M. Kogan 1 A. Lex 2,1 M. Lisnic 3 1 University of Utah, USA 2 Graz University of Technology, Austria 3 Worcester Polytechnic Institute, USA Abstract Charts used for persuasion can easily veer into being outright misleading when, for instance, cherry-picked data is paired with a deceptive caption, as is commonly encountered on social media. The rise of interactive time-series data explorers for hotly debated topics makes such framing easy to produce and spread. Post-hoc interventions like fact-checking often arrive too late and suffer from persistence of belief. Prior work suggests that guardrails, in the form of contextual comparison lines embedded directly into charts, can reduce these effects. We propose and evaluate a practical set of guardrail sampling strategies for implementing such contextual lines in real systems. In a preregistered mixed-design study with two real-world scenarios (COVID-19 and Stocks), participants viewed persuasive charts with different sets of guardrails and reported trust, estimated rank in the dataset, expressed their perceived completeness of context, as well as subjective preference for different tasks. Across scenarios, guardrails improved trust, accuracy of performance judgments, and perceived completeness of context compared to the control. Taken together, the study offers practical guardrail sampling methods, evidence of their contextual benefits, and insights into participants’ preferences. \SpecialIssuePaper \CGFccby ccs Human-centered computing Visualization design and evaluation methods ccs Human-centered computing Empirical studies in visualization ccs Human-centered computing Visualization theory, concepts and paradigms ccs Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI ccs Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing † † year: 2026 † † year: 2026 † † editors: N. Andrienko, M. Chen, and B. Wang † † subject: Eurographics Conference on Visualization CGF Vol No † † orcid: 0009-0006-7940-501X † † orcid: 0000-0002-9200-6914 † † orcid: 0000-0001-6930-5468 † † orcid: 0000-0001-5329-4274 † † teaser: The five guardrails and the control condition evaluated in our experiment. We test different versions of statistical guardrails: (1) percentile markers, i.e., explicitly showing percentiles of the whole dataset over time; (2) percentile-based exemplars, i.e., showing concrete items that are close to a percentile value, (3) cluster representatives, i.e., showing items central to the clusters of the dataset, (4) exemplars with semantic similarities, i.e., based on higher-level knowledge about the data items; (5) randomly drawn exemplars, and (6) no guardrails. 1 Introduction Modern interactive time-series explorers make it easy for both novice and expert users to produce a factual, persuasive chart in seconds, before captioning it and sending it off over text or social media. Public health-related data exploration platforms, such as the Our World in Data COVID-19 Explorer [ 21 ] and the Johns Hopkins dashboards [ 9 ] , offer powerful controls for date windows, smoothing, and metric selection to inform users’ health decisions. Finance platforms such as TradingView [ 28 ] , Yahoo Finance [ 30 ] , and Google Finance [ 6 ] similarly provide range, overlays, and comparators for easy customization of views pertaining to personal finance choices. These platform affordances are essential for domain-specific analyses for both experts and lay people alike, but they also make it easy to produce and disseminate misleading charts [ 16 ] . The same affordances that allow users to zoom in and focus on data points of their interest when the interface is used for exploration purposes may also lead to intentional or unintentional cherry-picking that may mislead both the user and their audiences [ 14 ] . Deceptive visualizations and, consequently, visual misinformation are a pressing topic that has been attracting a growing body of work in the visualization community [ 12 , 16 , 17 , 24 ] . There are many tools at visualization authors’ disposal that assist in crafting misleading visualizations: framing and narrative choices in visualization expressed via titles, captions, selected time windows, axis ranges, and curated comparators may strongly shift reader interpretation and judgment, even when the underlying data are held constant [ 11 , 10 , 16 ] . Visualizations are also persuasive [ 23 ] and are commonly shared on social media. Once they go viral, “belief echoes”—residual attitudinal effects after correction—can persist even after misinformation is clearly retracted [ 27 ] . This reveals a pressing need to design and deploy in-chart preemptive interventions that meet readers at the point of viewing and interpretation rather than relying solely on downstream fact-checking . We initiated the work to design such preemptive interventions by previously introducing visualization guardrails : auxiliary context embedded directly into data explorer tools so that a focal item (the item a user has chosen to display) cannot be read or shared in isolation [ 14 ] . In our original evaluation of guardrail designs, we found that simple guardrails that match the visual language of the main data successfully encourage skepticism while not interfering with the main chart [ 14 ] . However, the question of what data to show and how to effectively sample it across data domains remains. For example, when exploring COVID-19 cases, it may matter which other countries are shown as guardrails: when a user is trying to understand Sweden’s COVID-19 response, showing similar countries in geographic proximity might make sense. When exploring the stock price of General Motors, showing exemplars at the 10th, 50th, and 90th percentiles may help situate the data against the larger market. This paper aims to fill this gap and take guardrails from design space to practice. To identify which data is best displayed as a guardrail relative to a single focal item , we selected five strategies from a larger set of options we considered, also illustrated in Figure : (1) Percentile Markers —markers representing the percentiles of the dataset; (2) Percentile-based Exemplars —example items that are close to statistical percentiles; (3) Cluster Representatives —example items that represent a cluster of the data; (4) Exemplars with Semantic Similarity —items that are similar to the primary item based on external world knowledge about the data; (5) Random Exemplars —a randomly-drawn subset of data, which we use as a naive baseline. In our experiments, we compare these to each other and to a No Guardrail control condition (6). As these guardrails are intended to be implemented by data exploration platforms, they span a spectrum with respect to the development effort and metadata needs: they range from simple statistical options to context-informed options. However, all of these methods can be precomputed as a new dataset is loaded and are feasible to integrate into existing explorers with minimal to no supervision. To test the effectiveness of the sampling methods, we ran a preregistered , mixed-design crowd-sourced study ( n=500 ) comparing the five methods across two domain scenarios (COVID-19 and Stocks). We organize our evaluation around the following main research question: How do different guardrail sampling methods compare in effectiveness? More specifically, we evaluated four outcomes: Trust —perceived chart trustworthiness, Accuracy —rank judgment of the focal item in the dataset, Context —a judgment of the sufficiency of context, and lastly Preference —participants’ personal preference of a guardrail method selected from a lineup. Our findings indicate that, overall, guardrails consistently outperform the No Guardrail control across all measures ,