How High-Specific-Energy Winds Regulate the Circumgalactic Medium of Dwarf Galaxies Facilities: Anvil (Purdue RCAC), Frontera (TACC), Ginsburg & Insomnia Cluster (Columbia University) enzo ( 16 ) , music ( 47 ) , yt ( 123 ) , trident ( 48 ) , Astropy ( 5 )
Michael Messere, Greg L. Bryan · 2026
Read How High-Specific-Energy Winds Regulate the Circumgalactic Medium of Dwarf Galaxies Facilities: Anvil (Purdue RCAC), Frontera (TACC), Ginsburg & Insomnia Cluster (Columbia University) enzo ( 16 ) , music ( 47 ) , yt ( 123 ) , trident ( 48 ) , Astropy ( 5 ) by Michael Messere, Greg L. Bryan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18987.txt.
Introduction
Michael Messere and Greg Bryan trace high energy winds around dwarf galaxies. Star blast bursts hold halo gas near halo heat, with cool time past ten times fall time. Hot winds carry most energy, cross the halo, leave it and warm nearby gas. Warm winds carry most mass but fall back to feed new stars, and near five billion years inflow block stops about three quarters of gas.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Messere, Greg L. Bryan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 138206 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18987
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How High-Specific-Energy Winds Regulate the Circumgalactic Medium of Dwarf Galaxies Facilities: Anvil (Purdue RCAC), Frontera (TACC), Ginsburg & Insomnia Cluster (Columbia University) enzo ( 16 ) , music ( 47 ) , yt ( 123 ) , trident ( 48 ) , Astropy ( 5 ) Michael Messere, Greg L. Bryan Abstract We investigate the role of ejective and preventive feedback in ∼ 10 10 − 10 11 M ⊙ \mathrm{\sim 10^{10}-10^{11}\,M_{\odot}} dwarf halos using cosmological zoom-in simulations. These simulations use adaptive mesh refinement to capture high-specific-energy outflows, together with an implementation of discrete supernovae (SNe). We show that episodic, SNe-driven shock heating sustains the circumgalactic medium (CGM) at ∼ T vir \mathrm{\sim T_{vir}} . This process also increases the ratio t cool / t ff > 10 \mathrm{t_{cool}/t_{ff}>10} in the outer CGM and intergalactic medium (IGM), placing the gas in a radiatively stable regime. Hot outflows ( ≳ 10 5 K \mathrm{\gtrsim 10^{5}\,K} ) dominate the energy budget, and their high specific energy allows them to traverse the CGM, escape the halo, and heat the IGM. In contrast, warm outflows ( ≲ 10 5 K \mathrm{\lesssim 10^{5}\,K} ) dominate the mass budget and are largely recycled back into the interstellar medium (ISM), where they fuel future star formation. We identify a gradual transition at ∼ 5 Gyr \mathrm{\sim 5\,Gyr} that marks a shift in the balance between ejective and preventive feedback. At early times ( < 5 Gyr \mathrm{<5\,Gyr} ), although the CGM cooling rate dominates for a larger fraction of time, the infrequent yet powerful SNe energy injection into the CGM is able to quickly dominate the cumulative energy balance. These outflows and their high specific energy are able to ‘sweep’ up mass in the CGM and IGM. At late times ( > 5 Gyr \mathrm{>5\,Gyr} ), the CGM baryon fraction is only ∼ 0.1 \mathrm{\sim 0.1} , leading to a transition toward a preventive feedback mode in which SNe maintain t cool / t ff > 10 \mathrm{t_{cool}/t_{ff}>10} and prevent ∼ 75 % \mathrm{\sim 75\%} of the expected baryon accretion rate. I Introduction How did the gas in and around galaxies get there? This simple question has become central to one of the most important (yet elusive) topics in galaxy formation and evolution –– feedback. In order to form a galaxy, the rate of radiative cooling ( \mathrm{t_{cool}} ) for some fraction of the baryon content must be less than the age of the Universe ( 111 ) . Yet, early models of galaxy formation revealed that, without feedback, gas cools too efficiently, leading to excessive star formation – an issue known as the “overcooling” problem ( 30 ; 132 ; 51 ) . Feedback, which encompasses processes such as stellar winds, supernova (SNe), radiation, and active galactic nucleus (AGN) outflows, plays a critical role in regulating star formation. A direct consequence of feedback is that gas does not always trace dark matter. Instead, the difference between the expected cosmic baryon fraction ( \mathrm{\mathit{f}_{b}=\Omega_{b}/\Omega_{m}} ) and the observed gas fraction within the CGM ( f_{\mathrm{CGM}} ) reflects the extent to which feedback has redistributed the gas ( 29 ; 134 , see review articles from) . The advent of the Cosmic Origins Spectrograph (COS) aboard the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and large-scale galaxy surveys has allowed astronomers to study the circumgalactic medium (CGM) and its connection to the interstellar medium (ISM) and intergalactic medium (IGM) in unprecedented detail ( 21 ; 120 ; 121 ; 131 ) . However, the sightline approach of HST/COS has made it difficult to directly link these observations to feedback-driven processes. For example, absorption lines probe individual lines of sight which may not trace the gas phase carrying most of the energy from feedback. To help, astronomers have turned to recent advances in computation, enabling the detailed study of gas at various scales: from the interaction between the cold and hot phase at the parsec level ( 44 ; 69 ; 1 ) to cosmological simulations tracking large-scale gas accretion ( 85 ; 82 ) . These cosmological simulations now routinely reproduce many properties of galaxies, including a star-formation rate that correctly places them on the stellar-to-halo mass relation ( 79 ; 11 , SHMR;) . However, there are two very different ways this can be done, resulting in very distinct gas distributions and fraction of gas retained in the halo: ejective feedback and preventive feedback. I.1 The Importance of Energy In ejective feedback models, strong galactic winds remove gas from the ISM and deposit it into the CGM and IGM. In order to avoid too much star formation in the ISM, these models require a high ( \gg 1 ) mass-loading factor ( \mathrm{\eta_{M}} ): \displaystyle\mathrm{\dot{M}_{out}=\eta_{M}\dot{M}_{*}} (1) which quantifies the rate of mass ejection ( \mathrm{\dot{M}_{out}} ) through galactic winds just outside the galactic disk relative to the star-formation rate ( \mathrm{\dot{M}_{\ast}} ). Ejective feedback typically results in gas-rich CGMs, since the gas that doesn’t form stars in the ISM is ejected back to the CGM. However, recent observations indicate that dwarf galaxies ( 22 ; 71 ; 24 ; 67 ; 50 ) tend to have low \mathrm{\eta_{M}} , often an order of magnitude lower than what is measured in IllustrisTNG ( 94 ; 84 ) or FIRE and FIRE-2 ( 81 ; 2 ; 90 ; 96 ) . In addition, idealized galaxy and tall-box (or “patch”) simulation work that explored the low mass halo regime has independently found that \mathrm{\eta_{M}} is low ( \sim 1 ; in agreement with observational work) and driven by cool-warm outflow ( 101 ; 53 ; 112 ) . In comparison with a typical cosmological simulation where the gas cell resolution is low (e.g., \sim 10^{5}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} ; TNG50-1) and an effective equation of state is assumed, idealized galaxy and patch simulations are able to better resolve the interaction between the cold and hot phase since their gas cell resolution is high ( 107 ; 112 , e.g., \mathrm{\sim 4\,M_{\odot}} ;) . For example, in an idealized simulation of an isolated \mathrm{M_{h}\sim 10^{11}\,M_{\odot}} galaxy, 112 find \mathrm{\eta_{M}=0.1-1} at 10 kpc ( \mathrm{\sim 0.1\,R_{vir}} ) and 1 kpc above the disk, respectively, where most of the mass is locked in the ‘warm’ phase ( \mathrm{<5\times 10^{5}\,K} ). In contrast to the mass removal (high \mathrm{\eta_{M}} ) in ejective feedback, the focus of preventive feedback is galactic wind energy transport. Therefore, the emphasis is on the energy-loading factor ( \mathrm{\eta_{E}} ) in preventive feedback: \displaystyle\mathrm{\dot{E}_{out}=\eta_{E}\frac{\dot{M}_{*}E_{SN}}{m_{*}}} (2) where \mathrm{E_{SN}} is the energy available from each core-collapse SNe and \mathrm{m_{*}} is the mass required to produce one core-collapse SNe. \mathrm{\eta_{E}} is therefore a measure of the amount of energy available from SNe to enter the CGM and IGM. In a review, 32 discuss the importance of energy in heating and expanding the CGM, which in turn will prevent the further accretion of gas (see their Section 5). As a result, preventive feedback will often leave the CGM gas-depleted. The prevention of gas accretion can occur at both the CGM-scale (IGM \rightarrow CGM) and ISM-scale (CGM \rightarrow ISM). This is explored in 134 , where they calculated the mass inflow rate at the