Planetary formation tracks on the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram
Benedikt Gottstein, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Christoph Mordasini · 2026
Read Planetary formation tracks on the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram by Benedikt Gottstein, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Christoph Mordasini (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18950.txt.
Introduction
Benedikt Gottstein, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau and Christoph Mordasini extend the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram from stars to forming planets. Using the Bern model coupled to radiation-hydro simulations, they track how accretion, cooling and migration shape brightness-temperature tracks. Shock heating that changes over time bears on whether planets start cold or hot. Tracks show three branches: rising during solid growth, near-flat after detachment when gas intake hits disk limits, and falling as cooling planets hold mass. The tracks match synthetic populations and broadly fit directly imaged planets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benedikt Gottstein, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Christoph Mordasini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 111466 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18950
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Planetary formation tracks on the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram Benedikt Gottstein, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Christoph Mordasini Abstract Context. The Hertzsprung–Russell Diagram (HRD) has been a cornerstone of astrophysics, illustrating the relationships between stars’ luminosity and effective temperature. Although HRDs have been instrumental in understanding stellar evolution, they have not been often applied to planetary formation. Aims. We extend the HRD framework to visualise planet formation, offering a novel perspective on the physical processes involved. Specifically, we investigate how gas and solid accretion, cooling and contraction, and orbital migration shape these tracks under different formation scenarios. Methods. We use the Bern model to calculate the interior structure of planets during their entire formation and evolution. Additionally, we couple this for the first time to the results of radiation-hydrodynamical simulations to calculate dynamically the accretion shock heating efficiency, providing insight into the cold- and hot-start ambiguity. Results. The planetary HRDs show three branches, each representing a distinct planet formation phase. The first phase, the ascending branch, is heavily influenced by the size of the smallest accreted bodies and the associated solid accretion rate and also orbital migration. HR tracks in this phase are directed steeply upward. For in-situ planetesimal accretion, one finds analytically L ∝ T 8 L\propto T^{8} . The second phase, the planetary horizontal branch, starts when the gas accretion rate becomes disk-limited and the planet detaches from the disk, subsequently contracting rapidly. The planets move nearly horizontally to the left, with hot accretion, more massive planets, and a pebble accretion scenario leading to an upward bending. The planetary interiors are nearly an ideal gas at detachment, but the increasing electron degeneracy lets the central temperatures decrease, stabilising the radii and halting the rapid movement to the left. The third phase, the descending branch, starts when the effective temperature begins to decrease. In this phase, gas accretion stops and planets join classical constant-mass cooling tracks. The radius changes only weakly, making these tracks go diagonally downwards, with L ∼ T 4 L{\sim}T^{4} . Also, there is substantial similarity between our analysed tracks, data from synthetic populations, and observational data. Conclusions. Planetary HRDs offer a unique way to link young planets’ luminosities and effective temperatures to their formation physics, with pebble and planetesimal accretion producing distinct early-time tracks. Comparisons to currently directly-imaged planets are broadly consistent with our tracks, since these objects are mostly non-accreting or near the end of formation and thus expected to follow standard post-formation cooling evolution. However, observationally populating the short-lived early horizontal branch or ascending branch will be challenging, and interpreting embedded, actively accreting planets will require models that include accretion-shock emission and circumplanetary-disk reprocessing. Visualising the processes of giant planet growth 1 Introduction The Hertzsprung–Russell Diagram HRD, after 62 and 116 is a fundamental tool in astrophysics, traditionally used to illustrate the relationships between the luminosity of a star and its surface temperature 1 1 1 In precise terms, the original (observational) HRD represents the relationship between magnitude and spectral type. However, for the purposes of this paper, the term HRD is used interchangeably with the (theoretical) luminosity–temperature (LT) diagram. . This diagram has been instrumental in understanding stellar evolution, mapping the life cycle of stars from their formation to their final stages. It provides insights into key physical processes, including nuclear fusion, interior structure, and energy transport, making it an indispensable framework in the field. However, while the HRD has been extensively used for studying stars, its application in the context of giant planet formation remains largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by employing the HRD to explain and illustrate the formation process from another perspective. Our concept of the planetary HRD is intended to serve as a step towards a basic framework for future classifications of observed young and forming planets. Until recently, there was no direct observation of the planetary formation process nor of these objects. However, a new era of observations has begun lately in which this is – although difficult – possible. Such detections have opened avenues to explore the formation of planets in unprecedented detail and in a direct way. These observations come in three different types: kinematic detections ( 109 ; 108 ) , potential gap planets ( 148 ; 74 ; 6 ; 117 ) , and directly imaged planets. For the last, the first unambiguous direct discovery of two forming planets was made with PDS70 b ( 69 ) and PDS70 c ( 56 ) , and more recently WISPIT 2 b ( 134 ; 34 ) and V2376 Ori b ( 137 ) were added to the short list. The planets are detected at several wavelengths, revealing not only the photosphere ( 96 ) but also the gas accretion shock ( 139 ; 58 ; 149 ) and the circumplanetary disk ( 68 ; 32 ; 13 ; 124 ) . These multi-wavelength observations are pivotal for testing and refining theoretical models. Expanding on this topic is essential also for current instruments like SPHERE or ALMA, or future ones like RISTRETTO ( 76 ; 77 ; Blackman et al., subm.), the SPHERE+ project ( 20 ; 88 ) , and several instruments at the Extremely Large Telescope (ELT), for example the Mid-infrared ELT Imager and Spectrograph (METIS; e.g., 101 ; 43 ; 130 ; 83 ). This work is a first step in taking up this challenge by investigating on the theoretical side the bolometric luminosity and surface temperature evolution of planets during their full formation and evolution process. We use a global model that does this in a self-consistently coupled way, the Bern Model (see review e.g. in 25 ), extended by a number of new elements. While clearly an approximation, our approach with a low-dimensional 1D model is not facing the limitations experienced by 2D or 3D hydrodynamic simulations, which currently can run only selected cases for a short time. Our approach allows us to track long-term evolutionary processes and derive population-level insights, similar to how the stellar HRD makes it possible to track certain phases of the life of a star and ultimately link them to its interior physics. In the present paper, we focus on the forming planet itself – by definition of the HRD – and assume spherically symmetric accretion. Other aspects such as a potential circumplanetary disc, non-spherical gas accretion or the effects of the surrounding protoplanetary disc and infalling gas on the observability will be addressed in subsequent works. This paper is structured as follows. We review in Section 2 the main approach for the calculation of the luminosity L and the surface temperature T . In this work, we have extended the model to address the cold-hot-start ambiguity arising from gas accretion at the accretion shock using the results of 86 , and describe this in Section 2.2.4 . It yields the fraction of accretion luminosity that is radiated away or alternatively incorporated into the growing planet. In Section 3 , we describe our nominal initial conditions, resulting in an HRD of our so-called default case, and then compare and discuss variations in the setup to help understand different processes or explore new parameter spaces. In particular, in Section 3.6 then we introduce a new formation scenario