A Tutorial on Symbolic Structural Identifiability Analysis of ODE Models in Julia
Abdallah Alsammani · 2026
Read A Tutorial on Symbolic Structural Identifiability Analysis of ODE Models in Julia by Abdallah Alsammani (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18910.txt.
Introduction
Abdallah Alsammani teaches how to test whether the parameters of an ODE model can be pinned down from ideal data. This trait, called structural identifiability, must hold before results can be trusted. His Julia tutorial builds a reproducible workflow around StructuralIdentifiability.jl for local versus global cases, observability and parameter combinations. Six case studies from epidemiology, drug levels and viral dynamics show models that pass fully, pass only locally, or fail, plus fixes through added measurements, known starting values, fixed parameters or reworking.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abdallah Alsammani |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66562 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18910
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Tutorial on Symbolic Structural Identifiability Analysis of ODE Models in Julia Abdallah Alsammani Abstract Structural identifiability analysis determines whether the parameters of a mechanistic ordinary differential equation (ODE) model can be uniquely recovered from ideal observations and is therefore a fundamental prerequisite for reliable parameter estimation. This tutorial presents a modern, reproducible computational framework for symbolic structural identifiability analysis using the Julia package StructuralIdentifiability.jl . We provide a rigorous yet accessible introduction to local and global identifiability, observability, parameter-to-output mappings, and identifiable parameter combinations, together with a unified workflow based on the core functions @ODEmodel , assess_local_identifiability , assess_identifiability , and find_identifiable_functions . The framework is demonstrated through seven case studies from epidemiology, pharmacokinetics, and systems biology, illustrating globally identifiable systems, local-only identifiability, structural non-identifiability, and recovery of identifiability through additional measurements and reparameterization. Beyond the theoretical foundations, the tutorial emphasizes practical model reformulation, experimental design, and reproducible scientific workflows within the Julia SciML ecosystem, providing a comprehensive reference for researchers and graduate students working with mechanistic ODE models. Keywords: structural identifiability; ordinary differential equation models; symbolic computation; Julia; StructuralIdentifiability.jl ; reproducible scientific computing. 1. Introduction 1.1. Structural identifiability and mechanistic modelling Mechanistic ordinary differential equation (ODE) models constitute one of the principal mathematical frameworks for describing dynamical processes in epidemiology, systems biology, pharmacokinetics, ecology, neuroscience, and biomedical engineering. Such models encode scientific hypotheses regarding the mechanisms governing the temporal evolution of biological, chemical, or physical systems through interacting state variables and parameters. Once calibrated to experimental or observational data, mechanistic models are routinely employed for forecasting, intervention analysis, uncertainty quantification, optimal experimental design, and hypothesis testing [ 8 , 10 , 1 ] . The reliability of every downstream inference derived from a calibrated model depends fundamentally on whether the unknown model parameters can, in principle, be uniquely recovered from the available observations. This question is addressed by structural identifiability theory , which studies the uniqueness of parameter recovery under the assumption of ideal noise-free continuous measurements. A parameter is said to be structurally identifiable if distinct parameter values cannot generate identical model outputs [ 5 , 9 ] . When structural identifiability fails, parameter estimation procedures may produce multiple indistinguishable solutions that fit the data equally well, leading to non-unique parameter estimates, inflated uncertainty, ill-conditioned confidence intervals, and potentially misleading biological interpretation [ 1 , 18 , 27 ] . Structural identifiability should be distinguished from practical identifiability . Structural identifiability is an intrinsic property of the model equations and observation scheme, whereas practical identifiability concerns the numerical recoverability of parameters from finite, noisy, and discretely sampled data. Consequently, a model may be structurally identifiable yet practically unidentifiable because of insufficient data quality, poor experimental design, parameter correlations, or limited observation windows [ 1 , 28 , 29 ] . Structural identifiability is therefore a necessary prerequisite for meaningful parameter estimation, since no amount of additional data can recover parameters that are structurally non-identifiable under a fixed measurement scheme. The identifiability properties of an ODE model depend not only on the model equations themselves, but also on the available measurements, known inputs, and assumptions regarding initial conditions. In many applications, especially in epidemiology and systems biology, only a subset of the state variables can be observed directly. Latent compartments, partially observed populations, unknown initial conditions, and aggregated measurements frequently introduce hidden parameter symmetries and non-identifiable parameter combinations. Consequently, structural identifiability analysis plays a central role in model formulation, measurement selection, and experimental design [ 10 , 4 , 12 ] . 1.2. Challenges in epidemiology, systems biology, and biomedical modelling Identifiability issues are particularly pronounced in biomedical and epidemiological modelling. Compartmental epidemic models commonly include latent populations such as exposed, asymptomatic, hospitalized, or environmental compartments that cannot be observed directly. Similarly, systems biology and pharmacokinetic models often involve hidden molecular species, indirect measurements, nonlinear interaction terms, and unknown initial conditions. In many practical settings, available data correspond only to incidence-like aggregated quantities, rather than direct measurements of the full system state. These limitations can lead to severe parameter non-identifiability, even in comparatively simple models. Classical examples include SEIR-type epidemic systems, within-host viral dynamics models, vector-host transmission systems, and multi-compartment pharmacokinetic models, where multiple parameter combinations may generate identical observable trajectories [ 1 , 4 , 2 ] . As a result, parameter estimates may depend strongly on optimization algorithms, prior assumptions, regularization choices, or initial guesses rather than on the information content of the data itself. The increasing adoption of scientific machine learning, neural ordinary differential equations, differentiable programming, and hybrid mechanistic–data-driven modelling frameworks has further amplified the importance of rigorous identifiability analysis. In these settings, structurally non-identifiable parameterizations may produce unstable latent representations, ambiguous mechanistic interpretation, and misleading uncertainty estimates despite excellent predictive performance [ 30 , 20 ] . Consequently, modern computational modelling workflows increasingly require identifiability analysis as an essential preliminary step before parameter estimation, Bayesian inference, or uncertainty quantification. Structural identifiability analysis provides a mathematically rigorous framework for diagnosing these issues before model calibration. Importantly, identifiability analysis is not merely diagnostic, but also constructive. In addition to determining which parameters are uniquely recoverable, it identifies combinations of parameters that remain observable despite individual parameter non-identifiability. These identifiable combinations frequently suggest natural reparameterizations, additional measurements, or experimental redesigns that restore identifiability and improve model interpretability [ 16 , 29 , 19 ] . 1.3. Symbolic identifiability methods and computational approaches The mathematical theory of structural identifiability has developed over more than five decades, beginning with the foundational work of Bellman and Åström [ 5 ] , Pohjanpalo [ 6 ] , Cobelli and DiStefano [ 7 ] , Walter and Pronzato [ 8 ] , Ljung and Glad [ 9 ] , and Miao and colleagues [ 10 ] . A broad range of analytical and computational methodologies has since been developed for assessing parameter identifiability in nonlinear dynamical systems. Classical approaches include Taylor series expansion methods [ 6 ] , similarity transformation techniques for linear systems, differential algebra approaches based on input-to-output elimination [ 9 , 11 ] , observability-based Lie derivative methods [ 12 ] , and probabilistic algebraic approaches relying on Gröbner bases or differential elimination [ 13 , 14 ] . These methodologies have led to the development of several influential software packages for symbolic identifiability analysis, including DAISY [ 11 ] , GenSSI [ 15 ] , STRIKE-GOLDD [ 12 ] , COMBOS [ 16 ] , and SIAN [ 17 , 13 ] . Despite major algorithmic advances, symbolic structural identifiability analysis remains underutilized in applied scientific modelling. Several factors contribute to this limitation. First, many existing software platforms depend on proprietary computer algebra systems such as Maple or MATLAB, which restrict reproducibility and complicate integration with modern open-source computational workflows. Second, many symbolic methods require specialized mathematical expertise, creating a substantial barrier for researchers whose primary focus lies in biological or biomedical applications. Third, large-scale nonlinear models often present considerable computational challenges, especially for global identifiability analysis and the computation of identifiable parameter combinations [ 14 , 13 ] . Recent developments within the Julia scientific machine learning (SciML) ecosystem have substantially improved the accessibility and reproducibility of symbolic identifiability analysis. Structural Identifiability.jl [ 14 , 19