Interoceptive Divergence in Aesthetic Evaluation and Implications for Human-AI Alignment

Yoshia Abe, Tatsuya Daikoku, Yasuo Kuniyoshi · 2026

Read Interoceptive Divergence in Aesthetic Evaluation and Implications for Human-AI Alignment by Yoshia Abe, Tatsuya Daikoku, Yasuo Kuniyoshi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18759.txt.

Introduction

Yoshia Abe, Tatsuya Daikoku, and Yasuo Kuniyoshi compare, in their 2026 study, human and AI beauty judgment. Beauty judgment rests on image traits and on inner processes in the viewer. Using prior human items on beauty ratings, bodily sensations, and emotions, they quiz language models. Humans and AI show similar links between beauty ratings and emotions, and similar favored image traits. But they split on emotional spread and on the beauty-bodily sensation link. The authors read this as a gap in interoceptive representation, a challenge for alignment.

Catalog record

CREATORYoshia Abe, Tatsuya Daikoku, Yasuo Kuniyoshi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57481
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18759

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interoceptive Divergence in Aesthetic Evaluation and Implications for Human-AI Alignment Yoshia Abe, Tatsuya Daikoku, Yasuo Kuniyoshi Abstract Artificial intelligence (AI), exemplified by large language models (LLMs), is rapidly approaching and in some cases surpassing human performance across a wide range of cognitive tasks. However, human nature is not limited to intelligence alone; it also encompasses sensibility, including the capacity to perceive and experience beauty in visual scenes or abstract ideas. This raises a fundamental question: how humans and AI systems converge or diverge in such aesthetic experiences. As part of ongoing efforts in AI alignment aimed at harmonizing AI systems with human values, this study investigates the similarities and differences between humans and AI in aesthetic evaluation tasks involving visual stimuli. Aesthetic evaluation depends not only on objective properties of images but also on internal processes within the observer. Building upon prior human studies that have examined the relationship between beauty ratings, bodily sensations, and emotions, we adopt a comparable set of questionnaire items and present them to LLMs, enabling a direct comparison between human and AI responses. Our comparative analyses revealed that, while humans and AI exhibited broadly similar patterns in the correlations between beauty ratings and emotions, as well as in the image features they prioritized, notable divergences emerged in both the distribution of emotional responses and the relationship between beauty ratings and bodily sensations. These findings suggest that state-of-the-art LLMs, trained on large-scale textual data, can approximate average human tendencies in aesthetic evaluation to a certain extent. However, they also indicate limitations, particularly in relation to interoceptive aspects, which may reflect insufficient representation in training data or unintended consequences of alignment processes. These findings highlight key challenges for AI alignment and suggest important directions for developing AI systems with human-like aesthetic processing. 1 Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), has approached–and in some cases surpassed–human-level performance across a wide range of domains (e.g., in higher-order cognitive tasks such as scientific reasoning and systematic thinking [ 24 ] ). This development prompts a reconsideration of the human position in these domains. These tasks nevertheless remain fundamentally intellectual and can be evaluated using objective, quantifiable metrics. Human nature, by contrast, is not confined to intellectual abilities alone. In everyday life, humans perceive beauty and pleasantness in scenes and ideas they encounter. In tasks that require such sensibility, the relevant question is not whether humans or AI are superior, but how closely AI resembles humans. It is sometimes debated whether non-human animals may also possess similar sensibilities, but what about AI, which has been trained on data prepared by humans? To address this question, we compare the behavior of humans and AI, particularly LLMs, from the perspective of aesthetic evaluation of visual stimuli. Through this comparison, we aim to identify potential misalignment between human aesthetic values, shaped through the embodied developmental process, and those of AI, acquired through learning from textual data. The concept of beauty has been extensively studied from the perspective of experimental aesthetics, including approaches in neuroscience and psychology [ 42 ] . Numerous studies have investigated human behavior in aesthetic evaluation of visual stimuli, including those examining patterns of aesthetic experience through behavioral experiments (as summarized in [ 32 ] ), as well as studies that have identified core brain regions involved in the perception of beauty using neuroscientific methods [ 21 , 19 ] . On the other hand, computational aesthetics has emerged as an approach to approximate the process of aesthetic evaluation using computational models [ 15 ] , and with the advent of deep learning technologies, a variety of AI models have been proposed [ 39 ] . Within the era dominated by deep learning, studies by Iigaya et al. [ 17 , 18 ] have examined the similarity between humans and AI in aesthetic evaluation of visual stimuli. Through comparisons between brain activity measurements and the processing of deep convolutional neural networks, their work has provided insights into the neural mechanisms underlying aesthetic value computation, such as the hierarchical representation of low- and high-level features and their integration in computing aesthetic value. In the 2020s, the dominant paradigm in AI models has shifted to LLMs. By learning from vast amounts of textual data, LLMs have acquired human-like general knowledge as well as capabilities for semantic and contextual understanding [ 16 ] , and have increasingly become capable of processing inputs from the image modality [ 46 ] . Although LLMs produce outputs in the modality of text, through integration with external tools they are evolving into agents that can actively interact with and influence human society [ 43 ] . Accordingly, efforts in AI alignment, which aim to align the behavior of LLMs with human values, have become increasingly important [ 20 ] . Among efforts in AI alignment, a substantial body of research has focused on tuning methods to ensure that LLM outputs are helpful, honest, and harmless to humans [ 4 , 5 , 31 ] . However, there remains a limited amount of detailed knowledge regarding the extent to which affective or perceptual evaluations of images are aligned with human values [ 35 ] . In particular, aesthetic evaluation lacks clearly defined correct answers, unlike domains such as mathematics, and varies widely across individuals; therefore, it remains unclear to what extent such evaluations can be learned from large-scale textual data as a form of collective intelligence. Several studies have recently begun to investigate the effectiveness and limitations of LLMs in the task of predicting aesthetic evaluations of images. For example, it has been shown that LLMs can achieve aesthetic prediction performance exceeding chance level without requiring task-specific training [ 1 ] . Moreover, in a study where multiple LLMs were prompted to generate aesthetic evaluations conditioned on demographic attributes, it was found that stereotype bias exists in the outputs, and that its magnitude varies depending on model size [ 25 ] . However, there have been few studies that examine in detail the internal process underlying aesthetic evaluation in LLMs. Human aesthetic evaluation is not formed solely based on objective image features; rather, it is influenced by internal processes within individuals [ 34 ] , likely including emotions and bodily sensations involved in processing the visual stimulus. A study by Washizu et al. [ 41 ] investigated these relationships in human aesthetic experience. In the study, more than 500 participants were presented with visual stimuli, and their aesthetic ratings were collected alongside measures of emotional categories and subjective bodily sensations, enabling an analysis of the relationships among these factors. Building on their work, the present study presents LLMs with comparable questions as those given to human participants, to investigate which aspects differentiate humans and LLMs in the process of aesthetic evaluation of visual stimuli. 2 Results In this study, we compared the responses of human participants and multiple LLMs. The human behavioral data were obtained from [ 41 ] . In that study, human participants were asked to provide beauty, valence, and arousal scores, emotion labels, and reports of bodily sensations for 347 images selected from the PARA dataset [ 45 ] . We posed the same set of questions to LLMs and collected their behavioral

Read the complete text