Modular Lower Bounds on Reeh–Schlieder State Preparation

Javier Blanco-Romero, Florina Almenares Mendoza · 2026

Read Modular Lower Bounds on Reeh–Schlieder State Preparation by Javier Blanco-Romero, Florina Almenares Mendoza (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18640.txt.

Introduction

Javier Blanco-Romero and Florina Almenares Mendoza price Reeh-Schlieder preparation from the vacuum in a tiny region. One Tomita-Takesaki bound, they show, sets a model wide floor on that price. Deep negative modular energy forces large local operators, while shrinking an operator to a contraction converts the floor into postselection overhead. Known modular Hamiltonians make the floor explicit. Bisognano-Wichmann recasts it as wedge boost energy, Casini-Huerta-Myers as a stress tensor for bounded regions, and local unitaries reach only nonnegative modular energy states.

Catalog record

CREATORJavier Blanco-Romero, Florina Almenares Mendoza
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20119
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18640

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modular Lower Bounds on Reeh–Schlieder State Preparation Javier Blanco-Romero, Florina Almenares Mendoza Abstract The Reeh–Schlieder theorem says that every target vector can be approximated from the vacuum by an operator localized in an arbitrarily small spacetime region, but it gives no quantitative cost for doing so. This note isolates a standard Tomita–Takesaki estimate as a model-independent preparation bound. Targets with deeply negative modular energy require large local operators. After rescaling such an operator to a physical contraction, the same estimate becomes a lower bound on postselection overhead. In geometries where the modular Hamiltonian is known, the bound becomes explicit. Bisognano–Wichmann turns it into a boost energy statement for wedges, and the Casini–Huerta–Myers formula gives a stress-tensor version for bounded regions of conformal field theories. Local unitaries can only reach states of nonnegative modular energy. Negative modular sectors require nonunitary or postselected outcomes, giving a preparation cost bound that complements vacuum embezzlement in type III local algebras. I Introduction Let \mathcal{O} be a bounded open region of Minkowski space. In the Haag–Kastler framework a quantum field theory assigns to it a von Neumann algebra \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) acting on the vacuum Hilbert space 7 ; 8 . The Reeh–Schlieder theorem states that 9 \overline{\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O})\Omega}=\mathcal{H}. (1) Every vector in the Hilbert space can be approximated by acting on the vacuum inside \mathcal{O} alone. This is not a statement about efficient preparation. The theorem gives no bound on \|A\| , no bound on the energy of A\Omega , and no constructive way to find A . The gap matters because local algebras in QFT are type III factors, which support state-conversion phenomena absent from finite tensor-product systems. Relativistic quantum fields can act as universal entanglement embezzlers, drawing entanglement from the vacuum while disturbing a reference state arbitrarily little 12 ; 11 . The natural next question is not whether local state preparation is possible. Reeh–Schlieder already answers that. The question is how expensive the local operator must be. We ask one basic question. If A\in\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) prepares \xi=A\Omega , how large must \|A\| be? Modular theory supplies a canonical lower bound, controlled by the signed expectation of the vacuum modular Hamiltonian of \mathcal{O} in the target state. In geometries where this Hamiltonian is explicit, the bound becomes a quantitative statement about boost energy in wedges and about a weighted stress-tensor integral in conformal causal diamonds. II The modular bound Reeh–Schlieder establishes that \Omega is cyclic and separating for \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) . Cyclicity is the statement that \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O})\Omega is dense in \mathcal{H} , as expressed by Eq. ( 1 ). The separating property says that A\mapsto A\Omega is injective, and follows because \Omega is also cyclic for the commutant \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O})^{\prime}\supset\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}^{\prime}) . The Tomita operator is the antilinear map S_{\mathcal{O}}(A\Omega)=A^{*}\Omega,\qquad A\in\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}), (2) which is well defined precisely because \Omega is separating. This map is in general unbounded but closable. Let \overline{S}_{\mathcal{O}} denote its closure. Its polar decomposition is \overline{S}_{\mathcal{O}}=J_{\mathcal{O}}\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}, (3) where J_{\mathcal{O}} is the modular conjugation, an antiunitary involution, and \Delta_{\mathcal{O}} is the positive modular operator 10 ; 13 . We write K_{\mathcal{O}}=-\log\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}. (4) The Tomita operator S_{\mathcal{O}} compares a local excitation of the vacuum with the excitation produced by the adjoint operator. The polar decomposition is more than a normal form. Positivity of \Delta_{\mathcal{O}} makes its imaginary powers \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{it} unitary, and the Tomita–Takesaki theorem shows that conjugation by them preserves the same local algebra. Thus the state-algebra pair (\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}),\Omega) canonically determines a one-parameter automorphism group \sigma_{t}(A)=\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{it}A\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{-it}. (5) This is the modular flow, and t is modular time. Writing \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}=e^{-K_{\mathcal{O}}} gives \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{it}=e^{-itK_{\mathcal{O}}} , so K_{\mathcal{O}} generates this intrinsic time evolution exactly as an ordinary Hamiltonian generates ordinary time evolution. What singles out this generator is that \Omega is an equilibrium state for it. The correlator \langle\Omega|A\,\sigma_{t}(B)|\Omega\rangle has the same analytic continuation and imaginary-time periodicity as a Gibbs state, which is the Kubo–Martin–Schwinger (KMS) condition 6 . In this precise sense the vacuum looks thermal when probed by the algebra \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) , with K_{\mathcal{O}} playing the role of the Hamiltonian for the corresponding modular clock. In the geometric instances of Sec. IV this identification becomes literal, with K_{\mathcal{O}} a boost generator for wedges and a weighted energy density for CFT balls. The antiunitary factor J_{\mathcal{O}} in the polar decomposition maps \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) onto its commutant, relating the region to its causal complement. Proposition 1 (Modular lower bound) . Let A\in\mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) and set \xi=A\Omega . Then \|A\|\geq\|\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}\xi\|. (6) If \xi\neq 0 , \hat{\xi}=\xi/\|\xi\| , and \langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}} is finite, then \|A\|\geq\|\xi\|\exp\!\left[-\frac{1}{2}\langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}}\right]. (7) Proof. For vectors of the form A\Omega , the closed extension of the Tomita operator satisfies \overline{S}_{\mathcal{O}}A\Omega=A^{*}\Omega. (8) Using the polar decomposition of \overline{S}_{\mathcal{O}} , we get \|A^{*}\Omega\|=\|J_{\mathcal{O}}\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}A\Omega\|=\|\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}\xi\|. (9) Since \|A^{*}\Omega\|\leq\|A^{*}\|=\|A\| , Eq. ( 6 ) follows for every bounded local A . For the second claim, assume the stated expectation of K_{\mathcal{O}} is finite. The functional calculus for the self-adjoint operator K_{\mathcal{O}} associates to the state \hat{\xi} a probability measure \mu_{\hat{\xi}} on its spectrum such that \langle f(K_{\mathcal{O}})\rangle_{\hat{\xi}}=\int f(x)\,d\mu_{\hat{\xi}}(x) for any bounded Borel f . Applying this with f(x)=e^{-x} and using \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}=e^{-K_{\mathcal{O}}} , \|\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}\hat{\xi}\|^{2}=\langle e^{-K_{\mathcal{O}}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}}=\int e^{-x}\,d\mu_{\hat{\xi}}(x). (10) Since x\mapsto e^{-x} is convex, Jensen’s inequality gives \int e^{-x}\,d\mu_{\hat{\xi}}(x)\geq\exp\!\left[-\int x\,d\mu_{\hat{\xi}}(x)\right]=\exp[-\langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}}], (11) which proves Eq. ( 7 ). ∎ The proposition says that the Hilbert-space norm of the target is not the only scale relevant to local preparation. The same operator that creates A\Omega also has an adjoint action A^{*}\Omega , and Tomita theory identifies its size with the modular norm \|\Delta_{\mathcal{O}}^{1/2}\xi\| . Reeh–Schlieder allows approximation of any target vector, but vectors with large negative modular energy require large local operators. For a normalized target, the elementary bound \|A\|\geq\|A\Omega\| already gives \|A\|\geq 1 . If \langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}} is positive, Eq. ( 7 ) is weaker than this trivial estimate. If \langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}}\leq-M , it gives \|A\|\geq\|\xi\|e^{M/2}. (12) Thus the exponential cost comes from the negative modular sector. The sharper norm bound ( 6 ) may see more of the spectrum, but the expectation value bound has its physical bite when the signed modular energy is negative. The estimate is an elementary consequence of S(A\Omega)=A^{*}\Omega and Jensen’s inequality. It turns standard modular structure into a direct lower bound for local preparation and postselection in the type III setting. The quantity \langle K_{\mathcal{O}}\rangle_{\hat{\xi}} is a signed expectation value of the vacuum modular Hamiltonian. It is not the Araki relative entropy S(\omega_{\hat{\xi}}\,\|\,\omega_{\Omega}) 2 , which is a different, nonnegative object built from the relative modular operator. Negative modular energy therefore does not mean negative total Minkowski energy. It means negative energy with respect to the modular clock attached to the chosen algebra and the vacuum. III Postselection overhead The operator norm has a direct operational meaning. Recall that a contraction is a bounded operator B with \|B\|\leq 1 , equivalently \|B\psi\|\leq\|\psi\| for every \psi ; it need not be unitary or even isometric. Any nonzero bounded local operator A can be rescaled to the norm-one contraction B=\frac{A}{\|A\|}. (13) More generally, any local contraction B satisfies B^{*}B\leq I . Hence it can serve as the Kraus operator for the success outcome of a local two-outcome measurement. The other outcome has Kraus operator (I-B^{*}B)^{1/2} , which also lies in \mathcal{A}(\mathcal{O}) . Acting on the vacuum, the probability of the success outcome is p_{\rm succ}(B)=\|B\Omega\|^{2}. (14)

Read the complete text