Integral Planes and Unit-Norm Polytopes

Daniele Corradetti · 2026

Read Integral Planes and Unit-Norm Polytopes by Daniele Corradetti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18538.txt.

Introduction

Daniele Corradetti offers, in a 2026 paper, integral planes tied to crystal and non-crystal systems in real composition algebras. For ten crystal orders one uniform construction recovers root systems including 2A1, A2 plus A2, 4A1, D4 plus D4, 16A1, and E8 plus E8. For two non-crystal orders it yields H2 plus H2 and H4 plus H4 over the golden integers. A rank-obstruction theorem proves no indecomposable rank-eight golden octonion order can exist.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniele Corradetti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54359
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18538

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Integral Planes and Unit-Norm Polytopes Daniele Corradetti Abstract . We introduce and study integral planes associated with crystallographic and non-crystallographic integral systems in real composition algebras. For an integral order 𝒪 \mathcal{O} in such an algebra we define the plane 𝒪 2 \mathcal{O}^{2} with quadratic form Q ⁡ ( x , y ) = N ⁡ ( x ) + N ⁡ ( y ) Q(x,y)=N(x)+N(y) , the axis shell, the balanced shell, and the corresponding unit-normalised spherical polytopes. For ten crystallographic orders we recover, in one uniform construction, the orthogonal-direct-sum root systems 2 ​ A 1 2A_{1} , A 2 ⊕ A 2 A_{2}\oplus A_{2} , 4 ​ A 1 4A_{1} , D 4 ⊕ D 4 D_{4}\oplus D_{4} , 16 ​ A 1 16A_{1} , and E 8 ⊕ E 8 E_{8}\oplus E_{8} (with classical-polytope realisations including the square, the 16-cell, the 24-cell, and the Gosset polytope 4 21 4_{21} ); for two non-crystallographic orders we obtain H 2 ⊕ H 2 H_{2}\oplus H_{2} (decagonal tegum) and H 4 ⊕ H 4 H_{4}\oplus H_{4} (600-cell tegum) over ℤ ⁡ [ φ ] \mathbb{Z}[\varphi] . We prove a rank-obstruction theorem that closes, unconditionally and by a purely Coxeter-theoretic argument, the existence question for an indecomposable rank-eight golden octonion order: no such order can exist. On the balanced shell side, we identify the genuine algebraic Hopf map h A ​ ( a , b ) = ( 2 ​ a ​ b ¯ , N ⁡ ( a ) − N ⁡ ( b ) ) h_{A}(a,b)=(2a\bar{b},N(a)-N(b)) and prove that its restriction to the balanced shell is a finite principal fibration of the unit loop, valid both for the associative case and for the alternative Moufang case. Keywords: integral plane \cdot composition algebra \cdot root-shell system \cdot icosian ring \cdot finite principal fibration \cdot Moufang loop \cdot rank obstruction. MSC2020: 52B15, 17A75, 11H06, 20N05; 17D05, 51A45, 52B11, 11R52, 20F55. 1. Introduction and Motivation Unital composition algebras, also known as Hurwitz algebras, are indispensable tools in geometry. Even more so the four real division Hurwitz algebras that, up to isomorphism, are the reals \mathbb{R} , the complexes \mathbb{C} , the quaternions \mathbb{H} and the octonions \mathbb{O} . Inside each of them lives, in a canonical sense, an arithmetic skeleton: the Gaussian integers \mathbb{Z}[i] , the Eisenstein integers \mathbb{Z}[\omega] , the Hurwitz quaternions, and the Coxeter–Dickson integral octonions. These four arithmetic skeletons are familiar to algebraists, lattice theorists and crystallographers alike; they sit at the intersection of normed algebra, integral quadratic-form theory, and root-system combinatorics. A more recent development, in part motivated by aperiodic order and the geometry of icosahedral symmetry (see Patera [ 14 ] for a survey), enlarges the picture. If one is willing to let the coefficient ring grow from \mathbb{Z} to \mathbb{Z}[\varphi] , where \varphi=(1+\sqrt{5})/2 , then the non-crystallographic Coxeter systems H_{2} , H_{3} , H_{4} enter the same arithmetic stage; the relevant orders are the cyclotomic ring \mathbb{Z}[\zeta_{10}] inside \mathbb{C} and the icosian ring \mathbb{I} inside \mathbb{H} . Building on the recent axiomatic framework of non-crystallographic integral root-shell systems over \mathbb{Z}[\varphi] established in [ 8 ] , we ask in this paper a complementary question: what spherical polytopes appear if, instead of treating \mathcal{O} as an algebra in its own right, one considers the integral plane \mathcal{O}^{2} with the natural quadratic form Q(x,y)=N(x)+N(y) , and reads off the root system from the resulting unit shell? The present work proposes a single construction that organises these crystallographic and non-crystallographic arithmetic skeletons into one shared geometric object. Given an integral order \mathcal{O} in a real composition algebra, with quadratic norm N and polar form B , we consider the integral plane \mathcal{O}^{2}=\{(x,y):x,y\in\mathcal{O}\},\qquad Q(x,y)=N(x)+N(y). This pair (\mathcal{O}^{2},Q) is an integral quadratic R -module whose unit-norm shell \mathcal{S}_{1}(\mathcal{O}^{2}) is a finite spherical polytope. The same definition simultaneously yields the classical root-polytope doublings, 2A_{1} for \mathbb{Z} , A_{2}\oplus A_{2} for the Eisenstein integers, D_{4}\oplus D_{4} for the Hurwitz quaternions, E_{8}\oplus E_{8} for the Coxeter–Dickson integral octonions, and their non-crystallographic counterparts H_{2}\oplus H_{2} and H_{4}\oplus H_{4} . In order to give an introduction we have to say that three themes run through the paper. The first is the doubling theme . The integral plane is a uniform construction that produces, in one stroke, the orthogonal-direct-sum root systems R\oplus R for the root systems R realisable as unit shells of integral orders. We separate, throughout, the algebraic structure (root system over R ) from the geometric one (classical polytope, in the sense of Coxeter and Grünbaum). The unit shell of the Gaussian order, for example, is the root system 2A_{1} (two orthogonal copies of A_{1} , eight elements through length-doubling and centrality); as a polytope, its convex hull is the square, also known as the 2-cross polytope \beta_{2} . This distinction is sharpened in our synoptic Table 1 , which carries one column for the root system and a separate column for the classical polytope. The second is the obstruction theme . Once the integral plane is in hand, a natural question is whether a strong indecomposable rank-eight golden octonion order can play the role of \mathbb{O}_{CD} in the non-crystallographic case. Earlier bounded computational searches reported in [ 8 ] were negative within their range. Here we close the question unconditionally , by a purely Coxeter-theoretic argument: an indecomposable non-crystallographic root-shell system over \mathbb{Z}[\varphi] in the sense of Definition 2.3 has rank at most four; in particular, no rank-eight indecomposable golden octonion order exists. We dedicate § 6 to this rank-obstruction theorem, which is the main negative result of the article. The third is the fibration theme . The balanced shell \mathcal{D}(\mathcal{O})=\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\,\mathcal{S}_{1}(\mathcal{O})\times\mathcal{S}_{1}(\mathcal{O}) carries the discrete restriction of the algebraic Hopf map h_{A}(a,b)=(2a\bar{b},N(a)-N(b)) from S^{2d-1}\subset A^{2} to S^{d}\subset A\oplus\mathbb{R} . Restricted to \mathcal{D}(\mathcal{O}) the second coordinate vanishes and the image lies on the equator S^{d-1}\times\{0\}\subset S^{d} , recovering on this equator the principal fibration \pi(u,v)=u\bar{v} of the unit loop U=\mathcal{S}_{1}(\mathcal{O}) over itself. We prove that this principal fibration is well-defined both in the associative and in the alternative Moufang case, the latter using Artin’s two-generated associativity (Theorem 7.5 ). We deliberately distinguish this finite principal fibration from the topological Hopf fibration S^{2d-1}\to S^{d} : the two have different codomains and different geometric content, and conflating them would be a mistake. The plane construction \mathcal{O}^{2} with Q(x,y)=N(x)+N(y) sits at the crossroads of four otherwise separate strands: the classical lattices and orders (Conway and Sloane [ 6 ] ; Conway and Smith [ 7 ] ; Wilson [ 17 ] ); the non-crystallographic side (Moody and Patera [ 13 ] ; Champagne, Kjiri, Moody and Patera [ 4 ] ); the literature on composition algebras and their projective planes (Springer–Veldkamp [ 16 ] ; Baez [ 1 ] ; McCrimmon [ 12 ] ); and the recent axiomatic framework of non-crystallographic integral root-shell systems over \mathbb{Z}[\varphi] developed in [ 8 ] . The closest neighbour on the discrete-Hopf side is Castro Perelman [ 3 ] , who fibres the E_{8} lattice over a D_{4} -cross polytope with D_{4} fibres. What we contribute is a uniform plane construction that recovers the orthogonal-direct-sum root systems on both sides of the crystallographic–golden boundary; an unconditional rank-obstruction theorem closing the rank-eight

Read the complete text