Phonon-bottlenecked spin relaxation of Er 3+ :CaWO 4 at milliKelvin temperatures

S. Rajendran 1, B. Mistri 1,2,3, P. K. Sharma 1, S. E. Kubatkin 4, A. V. Danilov 4, S. Dhomkar 2,3, S. E. de Graaf 5, V. Ranjan 1 · 2026

Read Phonon-bottlenecked spin relaxation of Er 3+ :CaWO 4 at milliKelvin temperatures by S. Rajendran 1, B. Mistri 1,2,3, P. K. Sharma 1, S. E. Kubatkin 4, A. V. Danilov 4, S. Dhomkar 2,3, S. E. de Graaf 5, V. Ranjan 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18208.txt.

Introduction

S. Rajendran's 2026 paper studies how erbium spins in calcium tungstate lose their spin order at millikelvin cold, read out via a small superconducting resonator. At high field, where phonon emission runs fast, decay times grow a lot as more spins are excited. The rise tracks a squared tanh law with temperature, the mark of a phonon bottleneck, where freed phonons cannot leave fast enough. The result matters for quantum gear that uses rare-earth spin groups as steady resources.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Rajendran 1, B. Mistri 1,2,3, P. K. Sharma 1, S. E. Kubatkin 4, A. V. Danilov 4, S. Dhomkar 2,3, S. E. de Graaf 5, V. Ranjan 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36746
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18208

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Phonon-bottlenecked spin relaxation of Er 3+ :CaWO 4 at milliKelvin temperatures S. Rajendran 1, B. Mistri 1,2,3, P. K. Sharma 1, S. E. Kubatkin 4, A. V. Danilov 4, S. Dhomkar 2,3, S. E. de Graaf 5, V. Ranjan 1 Abstract We study spin-lattice relaxation times of electron spins in Er 3 + : CaWO 4 \text{Er}^{3+}:\text{CaWO}_{4} at millikelvin temperature, detected via their coupling to a low-mode volume superconducting resonator. At large magnetic field supporting strong phonon-emission rates, we observe a noticeable increase in relaxation times with increasing spin-excitations, which exhibit a unique [ tanh ⁡ ( ℏ ​ ω 0 / k B ​ T ) ] 2 [\tanh(\hbar\omega_0/k_\text{B} T)]^{2} temperature dependence. These observations are typical of a phonon-bottlenecked spin relaxation, and have implications for quantum technologies that exploit rare-earth spin ensembles as coherent resources. Rare-earth ion doped crystals have emerged as promising candidates for quantum information processing as they enable microwave-to-optical transduction and the realization of optical quantum memories 28 ; 25 ; 45 ; 13 . Among these, \text{Er}^{3+} has garnered considerable interest due to its optical transition within the telecom C-band, making it well-suited for low-loss fiber-based quantum networks 42 ; 27 ; 49 ; 40 . Furthermore, GHz-range operation under sub-tesla magnetic fields positions this material as a viable platform for microwave quantum memories and coherent interfaces with superconducting qubit architectures 34 ; 18 ; 36 ; 39 ; 3 ; 24 . Practical implementation, however, requires cooling to millikelvin temperatures, both to suppress thermal noise and to mitigate spectral diffusion, the latter being especially critical in heavily doped samples where high concentrations are necessary for efficient photon absorption 2 ; 31 . Under such cryogenic conditions, spin coherence time reaching 23 ms 18 has been reported in erbium doped CaWO 4 crystals establishing them as a leading host material. The upper limit to spin coherence times is set by the spin to bath relaxation time T_{1} . For \text{Er}^{3+}:\text{CaWO}_{4} , the most notable study on T_{1} relaxation date back to the 1960s in which direct phonon and two-phonon Orbach processes were found as the dominant relaxation mechanisms in the temperature range 1-20 K 5 . Indeed, for Kramers ions, lattice phonons strongly couple to spins via thermal modulation of the crystal field and spin-orbit coupling. Consequently, fast relaxation rates can exist even at mK temperatures despite freezing of resonant phonons 1 . This is in contrast to other popular systems such as group V defects in diamond or silicon, where T_{1} is found to approach several hours under similar measurement conditions 6 ; 8 . Especially at mK temperatures, additional complications to direct phonon processes can arise since there are not enough resonant phonons available to transport the excitations from spins to the thermal bath. This so-called phonon bottleneck (PB) can have an unfavorable effect through a buildup of excitations in the resonant lattice modes, unintended re-excitation of spins, and subsequently a sudden release of spin energy via a phonon-avalanche 11 . These phenomena have parallels to an inverted gain medium for photons and their stimulated emission in two-level lasers and masers. However, a controlled PB can be turned into a resource, as recently illustrated through T_{1} enhancement of two-level system defects (TLSs) coupled to an engineered phononic bandgap 15 . PB effect was first predicted by van Vleck 47 , and since then measured in variety of magnetic systems 44 ; 41 ; 48 ; 16 ; 22 . It has recently regained attention in the context of quantum technologies 12 ; 46 ; 17 . Nonetheless, spin relaxation studies in highly doped rare-earth crystals at millikelvin temperatures remain challenging due to complications such as spin-spin interactions and cross-relaxation from other impurity spins or hyperfine transitions. In this Letter, we report the observation of phonon-bottleneck effects at dilution refrigerator temperatures and nW power excitation regimes in electron spin ensembles of \text{Er}^{3+}:\text{CaWO}_{4} . The PB leads to enhanced spin to bath relaxation times of the spins, and is most noticeably seen in the unique temperature dependence of spin polarization decay exponentials following [\tanh(\hbar\omega_0/k_\text{B} T)]^{2} , and is supported by spin excitation number and field dependencies. In particular, we find PB to be more pronounced with a narrower spin inhomogeneous linewidth. The magnetic field dependence of the spontaneous phonon emission is also studied, verifying weaker spin-phonon couplings at lower magnetic fields in Kramers ions. Our measurements are performed on a nominally 50 ppm doped erbium doped CaWO 4 crystal purchased from SurfaceNet Germany. The \text{Er}^{3+} ions substitute Ca 2+ sites and form an effective electron spin S=1/2 system at low temperatures. Though erbium has several isotopes with natural abundance, these can be categorized by distinct nuclear spins I=0 (78%) and I=7/2 (22%). Owing to highly anisotropic g-factors, though diagonalizable along crystallographic axes (g a = g b = 8.38, g c = 1.24) 21 ; 1 , the magnetic field position of spin resonances change with the relative orientation of the external magnetic field. This is also accompanied by changes in the inhomogeneous spin-linewidth from coupling to randomly distributed static charge defects 30 ; 18 . This, in turn, allows for different effective spin densities for different field orientations. In addition, the hyperfine transitions provide a naturally lower concentration of spin species in the same crystal environment. Figure 1: Measurement setup. (a) Schematics of excitation and subsequent relaxation of electron spins coupled to a superconducting resonator with a bandwidth \kappa\ll\Gamma_{\text{inh}} , the inhomogeneous spin linewidth. For large spin concentrations and at mK temperatures, excited spins are most likely to exit the detection volume via spin flip-flops ( T_{\text{1ff}} ), and only weakly via direct phonon emission ( T_{\text{1D}} ). \tau_{\text{ph}} is the average time for phonons to equilibrate with the cryostat. (b) Pulse sequences used for extracting spin relaxation by measuring resonator response following a long and strong saturation pump. The spin crystal is attached using vacuum grease on top of a NbN superconducting resonator 19 ; 29 fabricated on saphhire substrate, operating at a frequency \omega_{0}/2\pi=4.44 GHz and capacitively coupled to the feedline with a loss rate of \kappa_{c}/2\pi=2.5\pm 0.1~ MHz. The sample is mounted inside a dilution refrigerator with the base temperature of 20 mK. We apply magnetic field B_{\text{mag}} in the ac plane of the crystal at an angle \theta with the c -axis. The field is kept parallel to the superconducting thin film to avoid resonator losses from magnetic vortices. All spin relaxation measurements shown in the main text are performed on the I=0 transition, with control pulses generated using an arbitrary waveform generator, and signal quadratures acquired through homodyne demodulation at GSa/s. More details of the superconducting resonator and spin system are presented in our previous works 39 and the supplementary information. Figure 2: Spectroscopy of \text{Er}^{3+} spins in CaWO 4 . (a) Top: Energy eigenvalues of two isotopes of \text{Er}^{3+} with nuclear spin I=0 (dashed lines) and 7/2 (solid lines). m_{I} is the nuclear-spin projection on the B-field axis. Bottom: Color plot of transmission power |S_{21}|^{2} vs magnetic field at 80 mK. The field is aligned with the crystal c -axis. (b) Temperature dependence of g_{\text{ens}} (symbols: measurements, lines: theory) for the two transitions marked by double arrows in

Read the complete text