Gravitational lensing time delay beyond the Shapiro/geometry split
Luca Teodori, Kfir Blum, Zhaoyu Bai · 2026
Read Gravitational lensing time delay beyond the Shapiro/geometry split by Luca Teodori, Kfir Blum, Zhaoyu Bai (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18182.txt.
Introduction
Luca Teodori's 2026 paper re-derives strong-lensing time delays from exact light paths in the Schwarzschild-de Sitter metric. The familiar geometric-plus-Shapiro split emerges only as the first term of a small-angle series. The authors pin down the next correction to that split, and show it adds no fresh cosmological dependence: it is a higher-order effect of the Schwarzschild part alone. At this order the cosmological constant enters only via unlensed distance measures and the unlensed lens-redshift prefactor.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Luca Teodori, Kfir Blum, Zhaoyu Bai |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70314 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18182
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational lensing time delay beyond the Shapiro/geometry split Luca Teodori, Kfir Blum, Zhaoyu Bai Abstract Time delays are a key observable in strong gravitational lensing systems. Their theoretical expression is usually written as a sum of a geometrical delay and a Shapiro delay, with cosmology entering through angular diameter distances and a redshift prefactor. In this work we derive this structure from the exact null geodesics of the Schwarzschild-de Sitter metric. The standard formula is recovered as the leading term in a small-angle expansion, and we identify the first correction to the usual geometrical-plus-Shapiro split. Such correction does not introduce any new cosmological dependence: it corresponds instead to a higher-order correction intrinsic to the Schwarzschild part of the metric. As a consequence, up to this order, the cosmological constant enters only through the unlensed angular diameter distances and the unlensed lens-redshift prefactor. I Introduction One key prediction of Einstein’s general relativity is the deflection of light by intervening matter, which acts as a gravitational lens between an emitter and an observer. Important examples of gravitational lensing happen on cosmological scales, where the lens is a massive galaxy or cluster and the emitters are supernovae or quasars at Gpc distances. In such systems there is a large separation of scales between cosmological distances and the physical extent of the lens. This separation motivates the standard treatment in which the cosmological background and the local lens contribution are handled separately. In practice, in the thin-lens and weak-field approximations, the light deflection is assumed to happen only in the vicinity of the lens, where cosmological expansion can be neglected Schneider:1992 ; Seitz:1994xf ; Bartelmann:2010fz . Cosmology then enters the gravitational lensing observables through angular diameter distances. For most current strong-lensing applications, including quasar time-delay cosmography Suyu:2016qxx ; Millon:2019slk , this separation is an excellent approximation. Precision lensing measurements, however, motivate a more explicit understanding of the expansion behind it Sasaki:1993tu ; Wucknitz:2020spz . In particular, it is useful to ask which dimensionless parameter controls the usual formulae and what the first correction to them is. A useful exact setting for this question is the Schwarzschild-de Sitter (SdS) metric. The SdS metric (see e.g. Lake:1977ui ; Perlick:2004tq ) is an exact solution of the Einstein equations with a point mass, parametrized by the Schwarzschild radius r_{\rm s} , and a positive cosmological constant \Lambda . More generally, the same static point-mass solution with arbitrary sign of \Lambda is often called the Kottler metric 1918AnP…361..401K . The negative- \Lambda case is Schwarzschild-anti de Sitter. In this work we restrict to \Lambda>0 . The SdS metric is clearly idealized: realistic lensing systems are not exactly de Sitter and their lenses are not point masses. Its advantage is that the null geodesics are sufficiently explicit to let us compare exact expressions with the standard lensing expansion. This metric has been studied extensively in connection with the deflection angle and the question of whether \Lambda has an independent lensing effect Piattella:2016nzt ; Rindler:2007zz ; Ishak:2010zh ; Aghili:2014aga ; Hu:2021yzn ; Sereno:2008kk ; Arakida:2011ty , beyond its effect on angular diameter distances and redshift expressions. We find no independent \Lambda contribution to the lens equation through the order relevant here, in agreement with Ref. Butcher:2016yrs . Time delays provide a second central strong-lensing observable 1975ApJ…195L..11C , used both for lens modeling and for cosmology Refsdal:1964nw ; Millon:2019slk . The role of \Lambda in time-delay calculations has received less systematic attention than in deflection-angle calculations. Earlier work includes discussions of Shapiro time delay in SdS for solar-system settings Kagramanova:2006ax , applications to galaxy lensing in SdS Schucker:2008jv , and studies in related McVittie or Einstein-Straus geometries McVittie:1933zz ; Kaloper:2010ec ; Park:2008ih ; Piattella:2016nzt ; Bessa:2022sdh ; Arakida:2011st ; Einstein:1945id ; 1954ZPhy..137..595S ; Schucker:2008bc ; Boudjemaa:2011ab ; Chen:2010gi (see also Alchera:2017sjt ; Alchera:2018ijo for a different approach to get corrections to the standard time delay formula). Here we keep the simple SdS setting. Our goal is to derive the standard lens equation and time-delay formula as the leading terms of the exact SdS geodesic expressions. We work with a comoving emitter and observer in static coordinates and expand in the small parameter x=r_{\rm s}/r_{\rm c}\sim\theta , where r_{\rm c} is the closest-approach radius of the light ray. We show how the familiar division of the time delay into a geometrical term and a Shapiro term appears after the small-angle and large-distance expansion, and after rewriting the answer in terms of image positions and angular diameter distances, and identify the first correction to this split. This correction does not introduce independent \Lambda contributions to the time-delay expression, and it can be traced back to the Schwarzschild part of the metric. This paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II we collect the exact SdS equations for light deflection and time delays. In Sec. III we derive the small-angle, large-distance expansion and obtain the leading time-delay formula together with its first correction. We conclude in Sec. IV . The appendices collect supporting material on peculiar velocities, the FLRW redshift limit, angular diameter distances, astrophysical values of the expansion parameter, and miscellaneous technical aspect of some calculations, respectively. II Light deflection and time delays in the Schwarzschild-de Sitter metric In this section we collect the exact expressions for light deflection and time delays in the SdS metric. II.1 Geodesic equations The SdS metric in static coordinates reads \displaystyle\differential{s^2}=-A(r)\differential{t^2}+A^{-1}(r)\differential{r^2}+r^{2}\differential{\Omega^2}\ ,\ A(r):=1-\frac{r_{\rm s}}{r}-H^{2}r^{2}\ ,\ \differential{\Omega}:=\differential{\phi}^{2}+\sin^{2}\phi\differential{\varphi}^{2}\ , (1) where r_{\rm s} is the Schwarzschild radius and H is the Hubble constant (connected to the cosmological constant \Lambda via H^{2}=\Lambda/3 ). We focus on the case \Lambda>0 . Horizons arise at r=r_{\rm h} defined by the solutions of \displaystyle A(r_{\rm h})=0\implies H^{2}\frac{r^{3}_{\rm h}}{r_{\rm s}}-\frac{r_{\rm h}}{r_{\rm s}}+1=0\ . (2) In the regime r_{\rm s}H\ll 1 , the two positive real solutions r_{\rm h}\approx r_{\rm s} and r_{\rm h}\approx 1/H are the point mass event horizon and the cosmological horizon respectively. The static coordinates cover the space between these two horizons. Exploiting spherical symmetry, we set the geodesic motion in the equatorial plane, \phi=\pi/2 . With \ \dot{}:=\derivative*{\lambda} , where \lambda is the affine parameter, the relevant first integrals are \displaystyle\dot{t}=\frac{E}{A}\ , (3) \displaystyle\dot{\varphi}=\frac{b}{r^{2}}\ , (4) \displaystyle\dot{r}=\pm\sqrt{Ae+E^{2}-\frac{Ab^{2}}{r^{2}}}\ . (5) Here E and b are the conserved quantities associated with the t and \varphi Killing directions, and g_{\mu\nu}\dot{x}^{\mu}\dot{x}^{\nu}=e , with e=0 for null geodesics and e<0 for timelike geodesics. The sign in Eq. ( 5 ) should be chosen according to whether the geodesic has decreasing or increasing r . We normalize the massive geodesic so that e=-1 . With such a choice, \lambda will be the massive geodesic proper time. Notice that it is possible to rescale away E by redefining the affine parameter \lambda in the massless case. Hence, we will always set E=1 for massless geodesics. This is not possible in the massive case. However, for comoving observers in the de Sitter expansion, E=1 is a natural choice, as explained in Ref. Butcher:2016yrs . In the main text we set E_{\rm e}=E_{\rm o}=1 for the emitter and observer. Deviations from this choice can be interpreted as peculiar velocities of the massive geodesic. For completeness, we summarize the corresponding bookkeeping in App. A . II.2 Lensing set-up We now