Faculty Orientations Shape Adoption of AI in Research and Teaching
T. J. Atherton, I. Descamps, T. R. Holmes, C. L. Vizcarra, N. Sui, M. Webel, J. J. Foley IV · 2026
Read Faculty Orientations Shape Adoption of AI in Research and Teaching by T. J. Atherton, I. Descamps, T. R. Holmes, C. L. Vizcarra, N. Sui, M. Webel, J. J. Foley IV (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-18140.txt.
Introduction
Timothy Atherton and six colleagues survey 90 STEM faculty on AI adoption in research and teaching, finding a clear AI teaching outlook that strongly predicts self-reported AI use. This outlook reflects views on AI's role in field thinking, learning, and skill growth, not just positive or bad feelings. School plans, backgrounds, and information sources link only weakly to AI use. The results suggest standard adoption models miss cases where tools meet field reasoning and knowledge production.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | T. J. Atherton, I. Descamps, T. R. Holmes, C. L. Vizcarra, N. Sui, M. Webel, J. J. Foley IV |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69672 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.18140
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Faculty Orientations Shape Adoption of AI in Research and Teaching T. J. Atherton, I. Descamps, T. R. Holmes, C. L. Vizcarra, N. Sui, M. Webel, J. J. Foley IV Abstract Despite the widespread availability of large language models (LLMs) in higher education, instructors vary substantially in their adoption and use of these tools, and the reasons for this variation remain poorly understood. A mixed-methods survey of 90 STEM faculty in the Research Corporation for Science Advancement (RCSA) Cottrell community examined relationships between AI use, attitudes, institutional context, and instructional practice. Exploratory factor analysis identified a coherent construct, AI pedagogical orientation , that strongly predicted self-reported AI use across research, teaching, and other professional activities. Qualitative analysis indicated that this construct reflected differing views about the role AI should play in disciplinary thinking, learning, and expertise development, rather than simply positive or negative attitudes toward AI. Institutional initiatives, demographic variables, and information sources showed comparatively weak associations with AI use. The results suggest that existing technology-adoption models may not fully explain adoption in contexts where technologies interact directly with disciplinary reasoning and knowledge production. I Introduction The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) as a consumer-facing AI product in 2022 has posed remarkable possibilities and challenges for higher education. Providing a simulacrum of naturalistic dialog, such models offer numerous use-cases including real-time interactive search, topic exploration and explanation, and summarization. Agentic models, which are able to execute tasks on behalf of the user, interact with each other, and store information between sessions, can facilitate delegation of complete tasks by users. Nonetheless, accuracy of information provided by LLMs remains challenging, and concerns around security, accuracy, and appropriate use remain. While dialogic LLMs are widely available, and are being used by students and faculty alike, we presently lack understanding of how LLM use shapes learning or disciplinary development. Nonetheless, an initial landscape of educational applications and associated education research is already emerging. Physics and Chemistry Education Researchers have begun to investigate the capabilities of models on traditional problem sets, as automated graders, virtual TAs or assistants that offer immediate, personalized feedback. There is also considerable interest in applying LLMs to education research itself, potentially to scale qualitative methods to larger data sets. An editorial accompanying the recent Physical Review PER-focused collection on AI ( 28 ) calls for an integrated program to examine “how these tools reshape what we measure, how students engage, how teachers work, and what counts as understanding” ; an editorial in J. Chem. Educ. proposed a conceptual framework, CATALyST (Context, Applications, Technology, Attitudes, Learning, Skills, Tasks), oriented around similar goals ( 59 ) . It nonetheless remains an open question whether adoption of LLMs will parallel adoption of other technologies into scientific research and teaching, or whether distinctive pathways will emerge. In this study, we examine how a group of pedagogically motivated STEM faculty are using LLMs in their work. Within the emerging literature on LLMs in education, a relatively small body of work has focused specifically on instructors. Survey-based studies ( 53 ) have examined patterns of adoption, identifying factors such as motivation, perceived usefulness, and technical barriers as predictors of use. Complementary qualitative work has begun to explore how instructors make sense of generative AI ( 47 ) , showing that instructors often hold multiple, overlapping interpretations of AI: as a useful tool, a source of knowledge, and a potential threat to learning. Work beyond physics and chemistry has examined instructors’ awareness of and attitudes toward generative AI, finding generally positive sentiment but only weak relationships with variables such as teaching style ( 18 ) . Additional qualitative studies ( 13 ) document both active adoption and cautious use, alongside concerns about student learning and assessment validity, and the need for institutional support and pedagogical adaptation. Across these studies, instructors consistently recognize both the possible uses and limitations of AI 31 . While these prior works document both variation in adoption and the coexistence of multiple interpretations, they do not fully explain why instructors respond differently to similar affordances and concerns. Some instructors who adopt AI appear aware of its limitations, while those who do not adopt it may still recognize its potential utility. This suggests that variation in use cannot be explained solely by access, information, or perceived usefulness, as emphasized in existing models of technology adoption. To understand possible mechanisms more clearly, here we determine how a selected group of pedagogically motivated faculty, awardees of the Research Corporation for Science Advancement (RCSA) Cottrell scholarship, are using LLMs in their work. In the language of prior models of technology adoption, this group represents a targeted population likely to be actively experimenting with AI in research and teaching, and variation within this group offers insight into how other STEM faculty may respond as these technologies become more widely adopted. To better understand these dynamics, we examine how this population uses AI tools in research, teaching, and other aspects of their professional work. Using a mixed-methods survey of RCSA Cottrell awardees, we identify an emergent construct, AI pedagogical orientation , that helps explain variation in AI use and reflects differing views about the role AI should play in teaching, learning, and disciplinary practice. While the survey instrument was designed to capture AI use broadly, LLMs emerged as the most widely reported class of tools across the cohort. Accordingly, unless explicitly stated otherwise, references to AI use in this work primarily concern LLM-based systems. The remainder of the paper situates this study within prior work on AI and computation in STEM education and existing theories of technology adoption (Sec. II ), describes the survey methodology (Sec. III ), and presents the quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods analyses underlying the construct of AI pedagogical orientation (Sec. IV ). We then discuss implications for instruction and faculty support, limitations of the present study, and directions for future work (Sec. V ) before concluding with broader implications for AI adoption in STEM education (Sec. VI ). II Background Recent work in Physics and Chemistry Education Research, as well as STEM education more broadly, has begun to examine the implications of large language models for instruction. Studies have evaluated model performance on traditional physics problems ( 50 ) and conceptual tasks ( 42 ) , laboratory reports ( 54 ) , chemistry problems involving multi-modal (graphical and structural) inputs ( 1 ) , as well as students’ responses to AI-generated solutions and instructional materials ( 10 ; 29 ; 45 ) . Other work has explored the use of AI as part of instructional environments, including supporting students in laboratory settings ( 27 ) and acting as collaborative partners in learning activities ( 49 ) , in lesson planning ( 21 ) , in creating, refining, and evaluating student learning assessments ( 15 ; 33 ) , and even for facilitating collaboration ( 25 ) . Across these contexts, AI systems demonstrate both productive capabilities and important limitations, with studies consistently highlighting the continued importance of human support, such as instructor oversight, in shaping how these tools are interpreted and used in instructional contexts. More broadly, studies beyond physics and chemistry education have found that the impact of LLMs on productivity and performance is