Do Stationarity Transformations Actually Improve Time Series Forecasts? A Controlled Experimental Evaluation

Bhanu Suraj Malla *, Yuqing Hu · 2026

Read Do Stationarity Transformations Actually Improve Time Series Forecasts? A Controlled Experimental Evaluation by Bhanu Suraj Malla *, Yuqing Hu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17689.txt.

Introduction

Bhanu Suraj Malla and Yuqing Hu test a common forecasting habit: reshaping a time series to make its statistical behavior steady over time. Across 35,099 controlled trials covering eighteen synthetic processes, ten reshaping methods, five models, and three horizons, they find that careful, structure-matched changes help, while blanket differencing hurts. Choosing by out-of-sample checks beats fixed rules or unit-root pretests, a finding confirmed on nine real series.

Catalog record

CREATORBhanu Suraj Malla *, Yuqing Hu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48469
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17689

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Do Stationarity Transformations Actually Improve Time Series Forecasts? A Controlled Experimental Evaluation Bhanu Suraj Malla *, Yuqing Hu Abstract Stationarity transformations are standard preprocessing in time series forecasting, yet their actual impact on accuracy across different non-stationarity types and model families has received little controlled evaluation. We construct synthetic datasets with known properties—trend, seasonality, heteroscedasticity, and combinations—and apply fourteen transformation configurations across seven models and three forecast horizons (3,528 experiments). Stationarity is quantified via consensus ratios from ten statistical tests, and each transform–dataset pair is classified as matched or mismatched based on whether the transform targets the dataset’s known non-stationarity. For matched pairs, transforms improve forecasts only 18% of the time. The primary exception is variance stabilization: log and Box-Cox on heteroscedastic data improve accuracy in 60–65% of cases. Differencing a linear-trend series—a textbook use case—worsens forecasts in all cases tested. Mediation analysis confirms that while transforms achieve trend stationarity, this does not translate into lower forecast error; the mechanism is signal attenuation. Real-world validation on TSA airport passenger data corroborates these findings. Our results suggest transformation selection should be guided by empirical out-of-sample evaluation rather than theoretical stationarity assumptions. keywords stationarity transformations; forecast accuracy; time series preprocessing; controlled experiment; mediation analysis; fractional differencing; synthetic data † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 1 † † issue: 1 † † articlenumber: 0 † † year: 2026 † † copyright-year: 2026 † † authornames: Bhanu Suraj Malla and Yuqing Hu † † address: 1 School of Computer Science, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, USA † † corresponding: Correspondence: [email protected] † † reftitle: References \addhighlights yes 1 Introduction Stationarity transformations occupy a central role in time series forecasting methodology. Textbooks and practitioner guides routinely recommend preprocessing steps such as differencing, log transforms, and seasonal adjustments to render a series stationary before model fitting ( ref-BoxJenkins1970 ; ref-Hyndman2018 ) . The rationale is straightforward: many classical forecasting models—autoregressive (AR), autoregressive moving average (ARMA), and their extensions—are formulated under the assumption of stationary input, and violating this assumption may degrade forecast quality. Despite the ubiquity of this advice, surprisingly little work has evaluated whether achieving stationarity through preprocessing actually improves forecast accuracy in a controlled setting. Most empirical forecasting studies either apply a fixed preprocessing pipeline without comparing alternatives ( ref-Makridakis2018 ; ref-Makridakis2022 ) , or evaluate models on real-world data where the true data-generating process (DGP) is unknown, making it impossible to determine whether a transformation targets the correct form of non-stationarity. This gap matters for practice. If transformations that successfully achieve stationarity do not reliably improve forecasts—or worse, degrade them—then practitioners would benefit from empirical guidance on when and which transformations help, rather than relying solely on stationarity as a preprocessing criterion. This gap is addressed through a controlled experimental design with three contributions: [leftmargin=*,labelsep=4.9mm] 1. Synthetic time series with known DGPs are constructed to isolate specific non-stationarity patterns—trend, seasonality, heteroscedasticity, and their combinations—enabling precise attribution of transformation effects. 2. Fourteen transformation configurations are evaluated across seven forecasting models spanning statistical and machine learning families, and three forecast horizons, yielding 3,528 experimental configurations. 3. A mediation analysis framework is introduced that decomposes the transformation–accuracy relationship into three causal pathways: whether transformations achieve stationarity, whether achieved stationarity improves forecasts, and whether transformations directly affect forecast error. The results reveal that the relationship between stationarity and forecast accuracy is more nuanced than the conventional preprocessing pipeline assumes. Transformations do increase stationarity as measured by a weighted consensus of ten statistical tests. However, higher stationarity ratios are associated with worse forecast accuracy, not better. The total effect of applying any transformation is a statistically significant increase in sMAPE. This pattern holds even for AR and ARMA models—traditionally classified as requiring stationary input—though their implementations include trend parameterization (Table 2 ) that partially accommodates non-stationarity internally, which itself underscores the diminishing practical necessity of external stationarity transforms. The primary exception is variance stabilization: log and Box-Cox transforms on heteroscedastic data improve accuracy for most model families by addressing heteroscedasticity without removing learnable signal structure. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews related work. Section 3 describes the experimental design. Section 4 presents the main results. Section 5 develops the mediation analysis. Section 6 provides real-world validation. Section 7 discusses implications, and Section 8 concludes. 2 Related Work The assumption that stationarity is a prerequisite for accurate forecasting has deep roots in the time series literature. Box and Jenkins ( ref-BoxJenkins1970 ) established the ARIMA modeling paradigm, in which differencing is applied to achieve stationarity before fitting autoregressive and moving average components. This framework has been enormously influential, and its preprocessing logic—difference until stationary, then model the residual—remains standard practice ( ref-Hyndman2018 ) . Subsequent work has expanded the transformation toolkit. Box and Cox ( ref-BoxCox1964 ) introduced the power transformation family for variance stabilization. Geweke and Porter-Hudak ( ref-GewekePorterHudak1983 ) proposed the log-periodogram regression for estimating fractional differencing parameters, enabling transforms that remove long-range dependence while preserving more information than integer differencing. Seasonal differencing addresses periodic patterns, and pipeline combinations (e.g., log followed by differencing) are common in practice. Despite this rich methodological literature, controlled empirical evaluations of transformation effectiveness are scarce. The M-competition series ( ref-Makridakis2000 ; ref-Makridakis2018 ; ref-Makridakis2022 ) have advanced forecasting methodology enormously, but their focus is on model comparison rather than preprocessing evaluation. Participants typically choose their own preprocessing pipelines, making it difficult to isolate transformation effects. Several studies have examined specific transformations. Nelson and Granger ( ref-Nelson1979 ) investigated the effects of Box-Cox transformations on forecast accuracy, finding mixed results depending on the data characteristics. Franses ( ref-Franses1998 ) examined seasonal adjustment and its impact on forecasting, noting that inappropriate seasonal adjustment can harm accuracy. More recently, de Prado ( ref-Prado2018 ) studied fractional differencing in the context of financial time series, finding that it can preserve useful long-range information. However, no prior study has systematically evaluated a comprehensive set of transformations across multiple non-stationarity types, model families, and forecast horizons in a controlled setting where the true DGP is known. This work fills this gap by combining controlled synthetic experiments with a mediation analysis framework that disentangles the mechanisms through which transformations affect forecast accuracy. 3 Materials and Methods The experiment follows a fully crossed factorial design: 12 datasets \times 14 transformations \times 7 models \times 3 forecast horizons = 3,528 experimental configurations. Figure 1 illustrates the full experimental pipeline. Figure 1: Experimental pipeline: synthetic data generation, transformation, stationarity measurement, forecasting, and mediation analysis. 3.1 Datasets Eleven synthetic time series are constructed, each of length 200 observations at weekly frequency, with known DGPs that isolate specific non-stationarity patterns. A twelfth dataset is a real-world transportation series used for validation. Each synthetic series takes the general form: y_{t}=\mu_{t}+s_{t}+\varepsilon_{t} (1) where the trend component is: \mu_{t}=\beta t (2) the seasonal component is: s_{t}=A\sin\left(\frac{2\pi t}{P}\right) (3) and the noise term is \varepsilon_{t}\sim\mathcal{N}(0,\sigma_{t}^{2}) with potentially time-varying variance. Here, \beta controls the trend slope, A is the seasonal amplitude, P is the seasonal period (set to 52 for annual seasonality in weekly data), and \sigma_{t} is the noise standard deviation which may be constant or time-varying depending on the dataset configuration. When a component is absent, it

Read the complete text