Disarranged Harmonization of Transparency Reporting by Social Media Platforms Under the Digital Services Act

Amaury Trujillo, Benedetta Tessa, Stefano Cresci · 2026

Read Disarranged Harmonization of Transparency Reporting by Social Media Platforms Under the Digital Services Act by Amaury Trujillo, Benedetta Tessa, Stefano Cresci (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17655.txt.

Introduction

Trujillo, Tessa and Cresci grade how well platforms report under the Digital Services Act, covering the eight largest platforms in the European Union. Their review of key reporting areas finds mixed compliance and data quality, with every platform flawed on format, timing, consistency and completeness. Some platforms use different steps across mechanisms, giving conflicting data, and cross-system sharing still fails despite harmonization. Many old flaws remain unfixed. The authors urge audits and targeted fixes to make DSA reporting more reliable and joined up.

Catalog record

CREATORAmaury Trujillo, Benedetta Tessa, Stefano Cresci
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56882
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17655

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Disarranged Harmonization of Transparency Reporting by Social Media Platforms Under the Digital Services Act Amaury Trujillo, Benedetta Tessa, Stefano Cresci Abstract The European Commission recently introduced new regulation to harmonize transparency reporting of large online platforms under the Digital Services Act (DSA). Here, we present the first systematic evaluation of transparency reporting data quality after this normative change, for the eight largest social media platforms in the European Union. In detail, we run a set of large-scale quantitative analyses on key reporting dimensions, followed by a structured comparative assessment across platforms and reporting mechanisms. Among our findings is that: (i) the analyzed platforms had varying degrees of compliance and data quality, but all exhibited issues on data formatting, timeliness, consistency, and completeness; (ii) some platforms employed differing reporting procedures across mechanisms, which caused them to submit contrasting information; (iii) despite the harmonization, a number of issues still prevent interoperability between reporting mechanisms; and (iv) many of the previously identified issues with transparency reporting are still unresolved. We conclude by discussing implications for transparency auditing and proposing key targeted improvements to strengthen the reliability and interoperability of DSA transparency reporting. Introduction The Digital Services Act (DSA) is arguably the most ambitious European Union (EU) regulation to institutionalize the transparency and accountability of online platforms. Its impact extends beyond the European regulatory context, however, bearing global governance implications in platform regulation via the so-called Brussels effect ( 4 ) . Platform transparency under the DSA is thus an operational prerequisite for independent auditing, regulatory oversight, and public accountability about content moderation practices, with the aim of a safe and trusted online environment. To achieve its goal, the DSA introduced two complementary reporting mechanisms: the Transparency Database ( TDB ) and Transparency Reports ( TRs ). On one hand, the TDB 1 1 1 https://transparency.dsa.ec.europa.eu/ is a centralized public repository of statements of reasons (SoRs) submitted by platforms for each individual moderation action affecting users. These records provide itemized metadata with the grounds, targets, and procedural characteristics of moderation actions ( 20 ; 10 ; 12 ) . On the other hand, TRs are documents published periodically through which platforms disclose aggregated information on moderation practices, such as automated systems, notice handling, and risk mitigation measures ( 22 ) . Together, the TDB and TRs form a dual transparency framework intended to facilitate public scrutiny, regulatory oversight, and cross-platform comparability in content moderation, by respectively offering low and high levels of detail. In addition, very large online platforms (VLOPs) —those with more than 45M users in the EU— must provide additional details in their reporting, in view of their greater impact. Despite the unprecedented scope and public accessibility, early studies of these mechanisms identified a range of limitations affecting the interpretability, comparability, and reliability of the data reported by VLOPs. Concerning the TDB , research surfaced heterogeneous reporting practices across platforms, extensive use of ambiguous or generic categories, missing contextual information, and inconsistencies between structured fields and free-text descriptions ( 20 ; 10 ) . Similarly, studies of the TRs highlighted strong differences in reporting formats, aggregation criteria, and methodological explanations, which hindered systematic cross-platform analyses ( 22 ; 3 ) . In response to these limitations, the European Commission (EC) introduced a major harmonization effort for the TRs effective 1 July 2025. 2 2 2 https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/library/implementing-regulation-laying-down-templates-concerning-transparency-reporting-obligations The first harmonized reports thus cover the second half of the year (2025H2). The initiative standardized the structure, formatting, terminology, and content requirements of the TRs through official templates and binding instructions in line with broader efforts aimed at improving comparability, machine readability, and interoperability of reporting practices across platforms ( 2 ; 13 ) . At the same time, the TDB was also slightly changed to align its taxonomy and structure with the new harmonized TRs . 3 3 3 https://transparency.dsa.ec.europa.eu/page/api-documentation?lang=en#changelog These changes represent a considerable attempt to operationalize a standardized transparency infrastructure under the DSA. However, because these mechanisms have been only recently introduced, there is currently no empirical evidence on how well the platforms complied with the new reporting specifications, whether harmonization effectively improved cross-platform comparability, or whether the long-standing inconsistencies previously identified in both transparency mechanisms have been mitigated. For these reasons, we examine the first harmonized TRs submitted by the largest EU social media platforms for 2025H2, and systematically compare them against the corresponding data available in the TDB . Following recent scholarly proposals ( 18 ) and the very rationale underlying the harmonization effort, we conduct a quantitative analysis of the TRs to assess their formal compliance with the new specifications and their practical interoperability with the database. While prior work already performed manual cross-checking between the reports and the database ( 20 ) , the introduction of common and machine-readable formats creates, for the first time, the conditions for comprehensive programmatic auditing. Our analysis therefore evaluates the extent to which such operationalization is currently feasible and identifies the current limitations that hinder systematic auditing. Our work also differs from previous evaluations of transparency reporting ( 22 ) since these evaluated transparency against external and non-regulatory frameworks ( 14 ) , while here we assess it directly against the regulatory specifications established by the EC itself. Finally, our analysis also reevaluates the current state of the database nearly two years after its launch, assessing whether the inconsistencies and reporting issues identified in early studies have been mitigated ( 10 ; 20 ; 17 ) . Accordingly, this work addresses the following guiding research questions: • RQ1: To what extent do the harmonized Transparency Reports and Transparency Database records comply with the European Commission’s instructions? • RQ2: To what extent are harmonized Transparency Reports data consistent with the corresponding Transparency Database data? Beyond their methodological relevance, these questions also have broader implications for the governance and enforceability of the DSA itself. Several formal proceedings initiated by the EC against major platforms already involve alleged failures concerning regulatory and transparency compliance. In this context, assessing the consistency, interoperability, and reliability of DSA transparency data is not only necessary to evaluate platform reporting practices, but also to understand the practical capacity of the EC and the DSA framework to support meaningful enforcement at scale. Related Work Transparency Database The TDB sparked great interest among scholars around its release, but —despite its potential— several studies highlighted reliability issues in its data. For example, platforms frequently resort to broad or generic categories when describing the grounds for moderation decisions, and predominantly refer to violations of their terms of service without specifying the exact provision ( 10 ; 12 ; 20 ). There is also a limited use of optional attributes that could contextualize moderation decisions ( 20 ) . These issues persisted both in the early stages of the database and one year after its launch ( 17 ; 19 ) . Some challenges also arise from the database structure and reporting practices themselves, including the lack of explicit schema representations for certain interventions, such as actions on accounts ( 8 ; 20 ). In addition, various inconsistencies were observed between the TDB and other reporting mechanisms. For example, X, Facebook, and Instagram disclosed great use of solely automated moderation in their TRs , while

Read the complete text