MSIQ: Moment-based Scale-Invariant Quality Measure for Single Image Super-Resolution

Leonid Bedratyuk · 2026

Read MSIQ: Moment-based Scale-Invariant Quality Measure for Single Image Super-Resolution by Leonid Bedratyuk (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17588.txt.

Introduction

Bedratyuk proposes MSIQ, a moment-based scale-free quality measure for single-image super-resolution. It is built on comparing normalized central moments of two images. It matches images at different sizes without resizing, avoiding interpolation error forced by standard metrics. It is deterministic and model-free with a closed form. Tests confirm stability under uniform scaling. MSIQ separates shape deformations from non-shape artifacts like JPEG compression, unlike pixel and perceptual metrics.

Catalog record

CREATORLeonid Bedratyuk
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65734
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17588

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

MSIQ: Moment-based Scale-Invariant Quality Measure for Single Image Super-Resolution Leonid Bedratyuk Abstract . Assessing the quality of single image super-resolution (SISR) results remains an open methodological problem. Common full-reference metrics (PSNR, SSIM, LPIPS) do not explicitly evaluate the preservation of the geometric structure of images, which is critical for the correctness of scale-based reconstruction. In addition, they require the forced alignment of images to the same size ( forced resizing ), which introduces an external interpolation error into the evaluation process. This paper proposes a diagnostic scale-invariant quality measure, MSIQ ( Moment-based Scale-Invariant Quality ), based on the comparison of normalized central geometric moments of two images. MSIQ enables direct comparison of images with different spatial resolutions without resizing, is mathematically deterministic ( model-free ), and has an analytical form. To provide a theoretical basis for the approach, we introduce a conceptual distinction between the ability of metrics to monotonically track degradation ( tracking ability ) and their geometric selectivity ( geometric specificity ). The experimental validation confirmed the stability of MSIQ under uniform scaling and, at the same time, revealed the high sensitivity of traditional metrics to the choice of interpolation method. The results show that MSIQ has pronounced geometric selectivity: the proposed measure effectively separates geometric deformations from non-geometric artifacts, in particular JPEG compression, unlike pixel-based and perceptual metrics. It is also shown that the response of MSIQ to structural perturbations remains stable across different classes of SR algorithms, including DNN models with different architectures. The proposed measure is a complementary diagnostic tool for domains where geometric fidelity has priority, in particular medical imaging and remote sensing. Keywords: super-resolution, image quality assessment, moment invariants, scale invariance, geometric fidelity, SISR 1. Introduction Single Image Super-Resolution is the task of reconstructing a high-resolution image I_{SR} from a single low-resolution input image I_{LR} , and it is one of the central directions in modern computer vision [ 1 , 2 ] . Deep learning has substantially improved the quality of SR results: modern CNN-, Transformer-, and diffusion-based approaches achieve significantly higher PSNR and SSIM values than classical interpolation methods [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . At the same time, the increasing capabilities of SR models have sharpened the problem of their objective evaluation: it is well known that rankings based on standard indicators do not always agree with subjective quality assessments [ 6 , 7 ] . The image quality assessment literature has repeatedly emphasized that classical objective metrics have substantial limitations. MSE and PSNR primarily evaluate pixel-wise error and do not take into account either image content or the properties of human visual perception [ 8 , 9 ] . Metrics based on models of the visual system are closer to subjective assessment, but they depend on complex and incomplete models of perception [ 10 ] . Even SSIM, which accounts for structural similarity [ 11 ] , may be unstable with respect to different types of distortions. Moreover, most full-reference metrics, including MS-SSIM, LPIPS, and DISTS, require the reference and test images to have the same size [ 11 , 12 , 14 ] . This makes them unsuitable for direct comparison of data with different resolutions without an additional size-matching step, since forced resizing introduces an external interpolation error into the evaluation process. As noted in general approaches to data quality assessment, the use of standard full-reference comparisons after geometric transformations requires particular care, because resizing is not a property of the SR model itself, but it can critically affect the result. Thus, a substantial part of the evaluation may depend on the methodological choice of the comparison procedure, rather than only on the quality of the reconstruction itself. This is especially critical because existing metrics do not explicitly evaluate the correctness of the scale transformation. SISR is, by its nature, a transition between two scales of spatial discretization; hence, a high-quality result should preserve properties that are invariant under uniform scaling. If anisotropic deformations, changes in object proportions, or perspective distortions arise during reconstruction, none of the classical metrics is designed to detect this particular class of errors. The problem addressed in this paper can be formulated as follows: can one construct a scale-invariant measure that explicitly evaluates the preservation of the geometric structure of an SR image with respect to the reference image I_{GT} , detects geometric anomalies in the super-resolution result, and does not require forced resizing? To solve this problem, we propose to use normalized central geometric moments, a classical tool for shape analysis and pattern recognition [ 15 , 16 ] . Their key property is invariance under uniform scaling and translation in the continuous model. Thus, in the discrete case, a geometrically correct SR result should preserve the moment descriptor of the reference image up to discretization and interpolation errors; therefore, the corresponding normalized central geometric moments of I_{GT} and I_{SR} should be close. The deviation between such descriptors is naturally interpreted as a measure of violation of scale-invariant consistency. This makes it possible to avoid forced resizing by comparing images directly in the space of moment descriptors. Based on these observations, we propose MSIQ ( Moment-based Scale-Invariant Quality ), a measure of discrepancy between descriptors formed by normalized central geometric moments of the reference and reconstructed images. MSIQ is considered as a full-reference measure for SISR: the reference is the HR ground-truth image I_{GT} , and the test image is the super-resolution result I_{SR} . The difference between MSIQ and standard full-reference metrics is that the comparison is performed not in pixel space, but in the space of normalized moment descriptors. MSIQ does not replace general-purpose indicators such as PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS; rather, it plays a complementary diagnostic role. It enables the detection of violations of global geometry that are usually averaged out in pixel-wise error measures or in the analysis of local perceptual features. Within the FUN paradigm, where traditional metrics focus on signal fidelity and generative approaches focus on naturalness, MSIQ fills the niche of objective control of structural integrity. This is critically important for scientific and technical visualization, where geometric correctness is a priority even when the image has high subjective quality. The proposed study integrates methods that are foundational for Pattern Recognition: the mathematical apparatus of moment invariants for the analysis of geometric structures [ 16 , 15 ] , computational assessment of visual data quality [ 7 , 17 , 18 ] , and comparative analysis of image descriptors in feature spaces [ 19 , 20 ] . At the same time, the paper addresses the current problem of verifying SISR results, which has become especially important due to the spread of generative models [ 3 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] that may introduce unpredictable structural deformations. The proposed approach, namely evaluating the similarity of objects through their invariant representations, fully conforms to the Pattern Recognition paradigm, in which the identification of patterns and the metrization of their similarity are based on extracting invariant features that describe the geometry of the image scene independently of its discretization conditions or scale. The contributions of this work can be summarized in four main points: (1) A conceptual approach to SISR evaluation is proposed

Read the complete text