The Viability of Blockchain Markets under Discrete Clearing and Paid Priority

Agostino Capponi, Álvaro Cartea, Fayçal Drissi · 2026

Read The Viability of Blockchain Markets under Discrete Clearing and Paid Priority by Agostino Capponi, Álvaro Cartea, Fayçal Drissi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17425.txt.

Introduction

Capponi, Cartea and Drissi model blockchain markets as the only venue for price formation under discrete block-time clearing and paid priority ordering. Paid priority induces endogenous selection: only high-valuation traders participate, and the cutoff rises with competition, which grows as information costs fall or liquidity demand rises. That hinders price discovery, biases prices and concentrates trading among aggressive traders, raising adverse selection. Longer block times amplify the damage and can shut markets down.

Catalog record

CREATORAgostino Capponi, Álvaro Cartea, Fayçal Drissi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE122771
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17425

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Viability of Blockchain Markets under Discrete Clearing and Paid Priority Agostino Capponi, Álvaro Cartea, Fayçal Drissi Abstract \usdate ABSTRACT This paper develops a model to evaluate the viability of blockchain markets as the sole venue for price formation. Blockchains clear at discrete intervals called block time , and transactions are executed sequentially according to priority fees paid by traders who compete for queue position. We show that these features undermine the viability of markets. Paid-priority ordering induces endogenous selection, where only traders with sufficiently high valuations participate. The participation cutoff rises with competition, which intensifies with lower information costs or higher liquidity demand. This hinders price discovery and biases prices. It also impairs liquidity: the cutoff concentrates trading among aggressive traders and increases adverse selection that liquidity suppliers absorb in a single clearing round. Although longer block times enhance consensus security, they amplify these effects and can cause markets to shut down. A central ambition of blockchain technology is to provide a decentralized infrastructure to organize economic activity at scale. The viability of financial markets within this infrastructure is therefore a fundamental test of that ambition. This paper develops a theoretical framework that models the blockchain as the sole venue for price formation to assess its viability as an infrastructure to support markets. The model endogenizes liquidity supply, trading volumes, and information revealed in equilibrium. It incorporates three defining features of blockchain infrastructure: clearing occurs discretely in a single round within each block; block time determines the length of the round and is necessary to conduct security consensus and preserve decentralization; transactions are ordered through paid-priority discriminatory pricing. Blockchains operate in discrete time, and information is revealed through an auction with discriminatory pricing. Orders are recorded into blocks built at regular intervals, called slots , and the duration of a slot is referred to as block time . At the end of a slot, a builder is selected by the blockchain’s protocol to build the next block. Once the block is created, the transactions composing the block are executed in order of inclusion. The builder sequences transactions in the block according to priority fees paid by traders who compete for queue position. Consequently, traders engage in priority gas auctions (PGAs) to optimize their queue positions in the block. Blockchain trading contrasts with traditional markets with continuous trading. In the latter, trading unfolds over multiple short clearing rounds, and in the former, trading unfolds over relatively long clearing rounds with discriminatory prices. We model the strategic interaction between liquidity suppliers and liquidity takers for a risky asset on a blockchain in three stages. In stage one, traders decide whether to enter the blockchain and acquire information at a cost. In stage two, a liquidity supplier sets the depth of a decentralized exchange (DEX) by balancing revenue from price-sensitive uninformed demand against expected losses to informed traders. 1 1 1 The DEX operates as a smart contract under the blockchain protocol. DEXs are the most widely used type of blockchain market and employ algorithms to price and trade digital assets. In 2025, DEXs support monthly trading volumes of approximately \$420 billion. A growing literature studies their microstructure ( 57 ; 16 ; 5 ; 49 ; 52 ) and compares them with traditional exchanges; see 5 ; 2 . The blockchain protocol defines the rules governing how transactions are recorded and determines the lifecycle of orders. In stage three, informed traders with private valuations compete in the PGA to buy or to sell the asset, and price-sensitive uninformed traders submit transactions. In our model, informed traders are either all buyers or all sellers. Block time is long enough for substantial price movements to occur, so most private valuations observed at the end of block time take a definite sign. The remainder of the introduction considers buyers; the seller case is symmetric. Traders compete for block priority to avoid worse execution prices resulting from the adverse price impact of preceding orders in the block. We propose and solve a special form of multi-prize auction for the PGA in which each trader’s payoff depends on the rank of their bid relative to that of others. Specifically, the surplus from bidding a priority fee is the expected price impact that a trader avoids by improving queue position. In the perfect Bayesian equilibrium of the PGA, informed traders determine both their priority fees and their trading volumes. To determine priority fees, they balance profits from better execution prices against the fee paid to the builder. To determine volumes, they balance increased expected profits from larger positions against slippage that increases with order size. We show that the defining features of blockchains fundamentally determine market outcomes and undermine market viability. Our main findings are threefold. First, competition in paid-priority contests generates endogenous selection, where only traders with sufficiently high valuations participate, which hinders price discovery by truncating information and biasing prices towards extreme values. Second, this selection mechanism raises adverse selection costs for liquidity providers and decreases liquidity in equilibrium, potentially leading to a market shutdown. Third, the very feature that supports decentralization, namely block time for consensus, amplifies these effects and tightens the constraints for viable markets. We elaborate on each of these findings below. Our first two findings indicate that increased competition between informed traders in blockchains generates adverse effects for both liquidity and price discovery. First, we show that there exists a cutoff for private valuations below which traders choose not to participate in the PGA, so only aggressive traders with high valuations transact in the blockchain. The intuition is as follows. Low valuations correspond to low desired volumes and less aggressiveness in priority fee bidding. This results in worse queue positions within the block and, consequently, higher adverse price impact from traders with better positions in the block and larger volumes. For traders with sufficiently low valuations, the adverse price impact associated with high-valuation traders will discourage participation because expected wealth from trading is negative. Hence, only a small fraction of traders in the blockchain with high enough valuations participate in the PGA. Two factors exacerbate these negative effects on markets. First, as the number of competitors increases, the participation cutoff rises, so increasingly higher valuations are required to participate in the PGA. Thus, competition limits the amount of information that is disseminated: it narrows the range of private valuations revealed to the market, and skews it towards extreme values. Second, competition also impairs liquidity. Although the fraction of informed traders submitting transactions becomes smaller with competition, trading concentrates among the most aggressive traders, and the resulting adverse selection costs per unit of liquidity supply eventually increase. These findings contrast with market outcomes in traditional markets where trading unfolds over multiple short clearing rounds. There, greater competition among informed traders accelerates the incorporation of information in the early rounds, and market depth typically improves thereafter; see 47 . The mechanism behind our result is fundamentally different. Blockchain block times are long, so each blockchain round of clearing aggregates the trading activity that, in traditional markets, would unfold over multiple successive rounds. Two consequences follow. First, the liquidity supplier must absorb the adverse-selection risk from aggregate informed flow in a single decision, rather

Read the complete text