Send: Objects, History, and Transactions in a Single-Verb Kernel
Christopher Goes · 2026
Read Send: Objects, History, and Transactions in a Single-Verb Kernel by Christopher Goes (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17401.txt.
Introduction
Goes presents a minimal kernel for multi-party object coordination. It is built on s-expressions, a uniform send interface and transactions, with one primitive split between ephemeral and persistent objects. The kernel sorts every send into six cases without caller input and jointly guarantees proven provenance, opaque encapsulation, atomic multi-object commits, deterministic replay, immutable record and history-derived state. Setups that distrust the operator, he adds, can be built with a cryptographic compiler.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher Goes |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74316 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17401
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Send: Objects, History, and Transactions in a Single-Verb Kernel Christopher Goes Abstract Multi-party object coordination — across object-capability systems, smart-contract platforms, distributed actors, and event-sourced architectures — is shaped by six structural properties: authenticated provenance, opaque encapsulation, atomic multi-object commit, deterministic replay, immutable history, and history-derived state. Existing systems compose subsets via separate layered mechanisms (RPC, capability ACLs, transaction coordinators, event journals, vat boundaries); each layer is well-studied but the combination is fragile. We present a minimal kernel which makes them jointly compatible. Our kernel is built from s-expressions, a uniform send interface, transactions, and one primitive object distinction: ephemeral (caller’s context inherited) vs. persistent (context switches to the target’s kernel-assigned identity and append-only log). The kernel structurally classifies every send target into one of six cases without input from the caller — uniform caller interface, intensional kernel dispatch. Under kernel-faithful trust (the kernel runs its semantics as specified), this design holds all six properties as kernel-level against arbitrary programs — the kernel’s transition function refuses states violating them — in the precise sense defined in §4.4 (the §5 instantiation realises identity-pattern opacity at user-level under its sequential allocator; a hash-allocator variant restores it to kernel-level — §5.6). Opacity against the operator additionally requires operator-faithful trust (the operator accesses logs only via recall and does not censor or reorder transactions); under kernel-faithful alone, five of six guarantees survive an unconstrained operator. Append-only logs underpin immutability, replay, and history-derived state; kernel-controlled persistent dispatch yields authenticated provenance and opacity; transactions deliver atomic coordination. Opacity has one structural exception: co-participants in a transaction observe its commit-or-abort outcome (Proposition 4), an intentional consequence of atomic coordination rather than a leak. Operator-adversarial deployments can be realized with a cryptographic compiler (§7 Case Study 2, Viaduct). 1 Introduction Multi-party object coordination is shaped by six structural concerns — authenticated provenance [ 9 ] , opaque encapsulation [ 15 ] , atomic multi-object commit [ 17 ] , deterministic replay [ 23 ] , immutable history [ 19 ] , and history-derived state [ 18 ] — each individually motivated by patterns in this domain. We use multi-party object coordination throughout to refer to the broad domain spanning object-capability systems, smart-contract platforms, distributed actor frameworks, and event-sourced architectures, wherever multiple principals interact through encapsulated objects whose state must be jointly authenticated, atomically updated, and replayable from a shared record. We propose this as a category-name for an implicitly-shared design space: no prior literature treats these system classes as one, but the six requirements above span all of them, which makes the cross-class comparison §8 draws coherent. These concerns are conventionally provided for by separate, layered mechanisms (RPC, capability ACLs, transaction coordinators, event journals, and vat boundaries), with state held in mutable snapshots that must be kept in sync with the event log to remain auditable. Each layer is well-studied in isolation, but the combination is fragile: interfaces multiply, cross-layer invariants are easy to violate, and security properties leak across layer boundaries. What design provides all six simultaneously, not as separate layered mechanisms but as kernel-level properties? Our kernel is designed as a target representation, not a surface language: a structural specification that source object languages compile to, and that cryptographic compilers (Viaduct-style [ 24 ] , §7 Case Study 2) take as a specification of what must remain opaque, atomic, and replay-verifiable under adversarial operators. The §5 instruction set is correspondingly chosen for computational sufficiency, not human readability; usable surface languages are downstream work. The kernel rests on three commitments developed in §2: • Ephemeral/persistent dispatch axis. A send target’s structural classification determines whether execution context switches (persistent) or is inherited (ephemeral). The cleanest demonstration is §7 Case Study 1, where the only difference between two otherwise-identical traces is this classification. • Send as uniform cross-object interface. The sole cross-object verb, classified by the kernel into six structural cases; intra-object computation uses additional kernel-local instructions (§5) that do not cross object boundaries. • State as history. A persistent object’s state is what its program derives from its append-only log. These commitments, combined with the transaction mechanism, yield a kernel providing these six properties. The kernel’s distinctive ergonomic move is interface unification: the caller uses one verb, and the kernel performs an intensional six-way structural classification of the target — encapsulating distinctions which prior systems expose as separate caller-selected mechanisms (Self’s parent slots, Smalltalk’s super-sends, EVM’s DELEGATECALL ). Kernel-level enforcement. A property is kernel-level for a system if the transition function guarantees that it holds, regardless of program input; user-level if well-formed programs can violate it. Smalltalk’s instVarAt: makes opacity user-level; Akka Persistence’s non-deterministic event handlers make deterministic replay user-level. We show that this kernel achieves uniform kernel-level enforcement across all six properties (Definition + Theorem 3 + Proposition 4, §4.4) under these definitions; operator-faithful trust is required for opacity (see “Scope and trust” below). Each of the six properties is well-studied in isolation, and many existing systems realise subsets via composed mechanisms, but alternative designs distribute the kernel/user-level boundary differently. The row-by-row contrast in §8 makes the comparison precise. Scope and trust. The kernel is positioned with respect to three trust regimes, distinguished by what is assumed about the deployment operator. Kernel-faithful : the kernel implementation runs its semantics as specified. All six structural properties hold against arbitrary programs. Opacity against the operator additionally requires the operator-faithful conditions below. Operator-faithful : in addition to kernel-faithfulness, the deployment operator satisfies three sub-faithfulness conditions: (a) commit-faithfulness : every well-formed transaction submitted to the kernel is committed (no selective censorship); (b) order-faithfulness : transactions are ordered consistently with the wrapping protocol’s T (the operator does not reorder T beyond the conflict-serialisable equivalences §6.3 permits); (c) read-faithfulness : the operator stores K but does not leak its contents into in-kernel program execution outside the kernel’s defined read interfaces (own-log via position 3; cross-object only via send). Under operator-faithfulness, opacity holds against all programs; the operator is the only entity that can read a persistent object’s full K . Opacity is at the read interface : atomic transactional coupling necessarily exposes co-participation across receivers (Proposition 4, §4.4). Operator-adversarial : the operator may violate any of (a)–(c). The kernel does not solve this regime; cryptographic-compiler composition (§7 Case Study 2, Viaduct [ 24 ] ) is the standard remedy, and the kernel serves as the structural target the compiler instantiates against adversarial operators. Case Study 2 sketches label-derivation from object identities for the static-allocation case; dynamic allocation is future work. The kernel itself is not a distributed system; the wrapping protocol’s properties (consistency, availability, partition-tolerance trade-offs [ 29 ] ; liveness under asynchrony) are scope-conditional on the wrapper choice (§6.2), not kernel concerns. The kernel exposes strict serializability under sequential processing with a real-time-faithful wrapper (§3); §6.3 discusses conflict-serializable scheduling and its parallelism floor. The kernel assumes program termination (§3.4); resource-bounding is composition-layer scope, and under the compilation-target framing becomes a compiler obligation. Recovery is discussed in §6.4. External principals. execute assigns caller =a_{\mathrm{ext}} for top-level transactions; the wrapping protocol (signed transactions, authenticated channels, consensus-attached identity) authenticates which external party submitted each transaction. Multi-party scenarios represent external principals in-kernel as persistent proxy objects (the §7 case studies do this for bidders, buyers, and