At Most Two Infinite Blue Clusters in the CMR Representation of the Edwards–Anderson Spin Glass
Yan Ru Pei · 2026
Read At Most Two Infinite Blue Clusters in the CMR Representation of the Edwards–Anderson Spin Glass by Yan Ru Pei (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-17338.txt.
Introduction
Pei proves a structural cap for the Chayes-Machta-Redner picture of the Edwards-Anderson spin glass: in any subsequential local weak limit, the blue subgraph holds at most two infinite clusters. If two exist, they share one infinite grey cluster and carry opposite overlap signs. The proof builds an abstract multicolour Burton-Keane claim from finite-box coalescence, plus finite energy and a percolation shift for the grey subgraph.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yan Ru Pei |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51614 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17338
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
At Most Two Infinite Blue Clusters in the CMR Representation of the Edwards–Anderson Spin Glass Yan Ru Pei Abstract The two-replica Chayes–Machta–Redner (CMR) representation is one of the main proposed geometric signatures of spin-glass order in the short-range Edwards–Anderson model. Mean-field arguments and recent numerics suggest that the low-temperature phase should exhibit two macroscopic blue clusters carrying opposite overlap signs. We prove a rigorous structural constraint in this direction. For any translation-invariant joint Gibbs measure on disorder, two spin replicas, and CMR bond variables on ℤ d \mathbb{Z}^{d} , the blue subgraph contains at most two infinite connected components; if two exist, then they lie in a common infinite grey cluster and belong to opposite overlap-parity classes. The main obstacle is that the blue-bond process is neither insertion-tolerant nor positively associated, so the usual Burton–Keane and random-cluster arguments do not apply. We circumvent this by working in the full joint measure and using a finite-box merge operation together with the mass-transport bound on ends of translation-invariant subgraphs. As auxiliary input, we establish finite energy and a percolation transition for the grey subgraph via Bayesian resampling of couplings and a parity-based Peierls estimate. These results do not prove the existence of infinite blue clusters or a spin-glass phase transition, but they give a rigorous upper bound compatible with the two-cluster picture for short-range spin glasses. 1 Introduction and main result 1.1 Motivation Spin glasses are disordered magnetic systems in which competing interactions can prevent the emergence of a single preferred ordered state. A central problem is to understand whether the low-temperature phase has genuine long-range order, and if so how that order should be detected. Unlike ferromagnets, where order is visible through magnetization and through Fortuin–Kasteleyn percolation, spin glasses have no fixed direction of magnetization. Their standard order parameter is instead the overlap between two independently sampled equilibrium configurations. This makes graphical representations especially useful: they turn questions about overlap into questions about random geometry. The two-replica Chayes–Machta–Redner (CMR) representation [ 1 ] associates to a pair of spin configurations a bond process with blue bonds, red bonds, and closed bonds. Blue clusters are the natural geometric objects associated with regions where the two replicas agree in their satisfaction of the disorder. Machta, Newman, and Stein [ 2 ] argued that the low-temperature phase should be reflected in the emergence of two macroscopic blue clusters of opposite overlap sign. Recent simulations in two and three dimensions by Münster and Weigel [ 3 , 4 ] support this picture. For short-range Edwards–Anderson models, even the structural part of this picture is not automatic. Frustration imposes nonlocal cycle constraints, and the blue-bond process is neither insertion-tolerant nor positively associated. Thus, before one can identify the spin-glass order parameter with blue-cluster densities, one must first answer a more basic geometric question: how many infinite blue clusters can coexist? This note proves that the answer is at most two. More precisely, for any translation-invariant joint Gibbs measure consistent with the Edwards–Anderson Hamiltonian and the CMR Edwards–Sokal coupling, there is at most one infinite blue cluster in each overlap-parity class, and hence at most two infinite blue clusters in total. If two exist, they lie in the same infinite grey cluster and belong to opposite path-parity classes. The proof works in the full joint measure over disorder, spins, and bonds. As auxiliary input, we establish finite energy and a percolation transition for the grey subgraph (blue \,\cup\, red) by combining Bayesian resampling of the couplings with a parity-based Peierls argument. We work with the Edwards–Anderson (EA) Ising spin glass on the hypercubic lattice \mathbb{Z}^{d} ( d\geq 2 ), with vertex set V and nearest-neighbor edge set E . The disorder is a collection of random couplings J=(J_{e})_{e\in E} , and for a fixed realization J and inverse temperature \beta>0 , the Gibbs measure on spin configurations \sigma\in\{\pm 1\}^{V} is \mu_{J,\beta}(\sigma)\;\propto\;\exp\Bigl(\beta\sum_{e=\{x,y\}\in E}J_{e}\,\sigma_{x}\sigma_{y}\Bigr). (1) Positive couplings favor alignment, negative couplings favor anti-alignment, and loops carrying an odd number of negative couplings are frustrated. 1.2 The CMR Edwards–Sokal coupling on the Ising spin glass The disorder distribution \mathscr{P} (the common law of a single coupling J_{e} ) determines both the frustration structure and the analytical tools available. Definition 1.1 (Disorder conditions) . We assume throughout: (D1) Independence. The couplings (J_{e})_{e\in E} are i.i.d. (D2) Two-sided. \mathscr{P}(J>0)>0 , \;\mathscr{P}(J<0)>0 , and \;\mathscr{P}(\{0\})=0 . Remark 1.2 . The bimodal ( \pm J ) and Gaussian ( \mathscr{P}=\mathcal{N}(0,J^{2}) ) distributions both satisfy (D1)–(D2). The two-sidedness condition ensures that frustration occurs with positive density and that the Bayesian resampling of couplings (Section 2 ) produces strictly positive conditionals. One-sided distributions ( \mathscr{P}(J>0)=1 , the ferromagnet) are excluded by (D2); in this case the CMR blue-bond process reduces to the FK random-cluster model and the results follow from standard uniqueness theory. This is a trivial edge case that is not illuminating to treat separately. Definition 1.3 (CMR joint measure) . The CMR representation [ 1 ] is an Edwards–Sokal coupling for two independent replicas (\sigma,\tau) of the EA model sharing the same disorder J . A bond e=\{x,y\} is satisfied by replica \sigma if J_{e}\sigma_{x}\sigma_{y}>0 . Given J and \beta , set r_{e}:=e^{-2\beta|J_{e}|} . After the spin-independent normalization that makes a satisfied two-replica edge have weight 1 , the joint measure on spins and bond variables \eta\in\{\text{blue},\text{red},\text{closed}\}^{E} has local product weight X(\sigma,\tau,\eta;J)=\prod_{e\in E}w_{e}(\sigma,\tau,\eta_{e};J_{e}), (2) where the local weights are Both satisfy \sigma only \tau only Neither satisfies (+,+) (+,-) (-,+) (-,-) blue 1-r_{e}^{2} 0 0 0 red 0 r_{e}(1-r_{e}) r_{e}(1-r_{e}) 0 closed r_{e}^{2} r_{e}^{2} r_{e}^{2} r_{e}^{2} Thus blue bonds are allowed only when both replicas satisfy e , red bonds only when exactly one replica satisfies e , and closed bonds are always allowed. The column sums are 1,r_{e},r_{e},r_{e}^{2} , which recover the normalized two-replica Edwards–Anderson edge weights after summing over \eta_{e} . Remark 1.4 (Marginal measure) . The CMR marginal measure \nu_{J} on bond configurations \eta is obtained by integrating out the spins (\sigma,\tau) . Its unnormalized weights are determined by bond fugacities and geometric factors from the cluster weight formula V(\eta)=F(\eta)\,D(\eta)\,2^{K(\eta)}\,2^{C_{b}(\eta)} [ 5 , eq. (9)] , where K(\eta) is the number of grey clusters and C_{b}(\eta) is the number of blue clusters. The merge-case weights needed later are recorded in Remark 3.2 . 1.3 Bond subgraphs and overlap structure Define the local overlap q_{i}:=\sigma_{i}\tau_{i}\in\{\pm 1\} . Definition 1.5 (Bond subgraphs) . Given a CMR bond configuration \eta\in\{\text{blue},\text{red},\text{closed}\}^{E} : • The blue-bond subgraph G_{\mathrm{blue}}=(V,E_{\mathrm{blue}}) is the spanning subgraph of \mathbb{Z}^{d} with edge set E_{\mathrm{blue}}:=\{e\in E:\eta_{e}=\text{blue}\} . • The grey-bond subgraph G_{\mathrm{grey}}=(V,E_{\mathrm{grey}}) is the spanning subgraph with edge set E_{\mathrm{grey}}:=\{e\in E:\eta_{e}\in\{\text{blue},\text{red}\}\} . Connected components of G_{\mathrm{blue}} are called blue clusters ; connected components of G_{\mathrm{grey}} are called grey clusters . Each grey cluster decomposes into two overlap parity classes (Definition 1.7 ), and each blue cluster is contained in a single parity class. Remark 1.6 (Overlap alignment from the Edwards–Sokal coupling) . The allowance rules in ( 2 ) enforce rigid overlap constraints within the bond subgraphs: along a blue bond (double satisfaction), both replicas satisfy the bond, so \sigma_{x}\sigma_{y}=\tau_{x}\tau_{y}=\mathrm{sign}(J_{e}) , which forces q_{x}=\sigma_{x}\tau_{x}=\sigma_{y}\tau_{y}=q_{y} and hence makes the overlap constant on each blue cluster; along a red bond (single satisfaction), exactly one replica