A Truthful Multiunit Profit-Optimal Mechanism for Synthesizing Social Laws
Jun Wu, Jian Huang · 2026
Read A Truthful Multiunit Profit-Optimal Mechanism for Synthesizing Social Laws by Jun Wu, Jian Huang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16853.txt.
Introduction
Wu, Huang and Wang model social-law synthesis as a Bayesian single-parameter auction built on alternating-time logic. They prove any valuation respecting alternating bisimulation can be written in compact form as a feature set of logic formulas. They reduce payment finding to allocation finding in polynomial time, fixing the multi-unit payment problem. They prove allocation finding is FP-NP-complete, so they encode the logic in integer linear constraints for solvers. Their PO-ASL mechanism is incentive-compatible, rational for each player, and profit-optimal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jun Wu, Jian Huang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108722 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16853
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Truthful Multiunit Profit-Optimal Mechanism for Synthesizing Social Laws Thanks: This is the full and extended version of the conference paper appearing in Proceedings of the 35th International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI-26), 2026. Jun Wu, Jian Huang Abstract This paper studies Social Law Synthesis (SLS) in strategic multi-agent environments as a new multi-unit mechanism design problem. We model SLS as a Bayesian single-parameter procurement auction based on Alternating-time Temporal Logic (ATL) and aim to design a truthful, individually rational, and profit-optimal mechanism. We first prove a representation lemma showing that any valuation respecting alternating bisimulation can be compactly expressed as a feature set of ATL formulae. We then reduce payment determination to allocation determination in polynomial time, resolving the irregular payment issue inherent in multi-unit settings. We further show that allocation determination is F P N P FP^{NP} -complete and encode ATL semantics into integer linear programming (ILP) constraints to make the problem tractable with standard solvers. Based on these results, we present the 𝒫 𝒪 - 𝒜 𝒮 ℒ \mathcal{PO\text{-}ASL} mechanism, which is incentive-compatible, individually rational, and maximizes expected profit. Theoretical guarantees and examples confirm that our approach provides an effective and computationally feasible solution for synthesizing optimal social laws under strategic agent behavior. 1 Introduction Social laws have proven to be a powerful and theoretically elegant approach to coordinating multi-agent systems. Based on modal logic, we can model a multi-agent system as a semantic structure, specify the system’s properties as logical formulas, and then verify these formulas via model checking. A social law is a set of restrictions on the available actions of agents, altering the system’s underlying structure in the hope that desirable properties (objectives) will emerge in the new structure [ 5 ] . By enabling the expression of valuations for potential social laws and accounting for the cost of implementing each action restriction, SLS can be modeled as an optimization problem [ 3 ] . However, we find that information incompleteness and the self-interested nature of agents, common in typical strategic environments, can introduce unavoidable obstacles to solving this problem. For example, the costs of action restrictions, which are key optimization parameters, are known only privately to each agent; if we attempt to elicit these costs by “asking” the agents, they may strategically misreport them to maximize their own utility. This challenge naturally falls into the domain of algorithmic mechanism design [ 47 ] . We adopt the powerful Alternating-time Temporal Logic (ATL) [ 7 ] as our foundation, enabling us to model SLS as an auction design problem characterized by the following features: 1) Multi-unit Procurement : Each agent has multiple available actions, and the social law designer seeks to selectively restrict a subset of actions for each agent. 2) Bayesian single-parameter setting : Each agent holds private information about the unit cost of restricting each of its actions, while the prior probability distribution of these unit costs is common knowledge. 3) Profit-Optimality : The objective is to reliably output the social law that maximizes profit (defined as value minus payment), even when agents behave strategically. The primary challenge stems from the “multi-unit” nature of the problem, which prevents us from deriving a clean solution directly from Myerson’s framework [ 43 , 28 ] . Indeed, the interplay between the “multi-unit” setting and the sophisticated semantics of ATL renders both the modeling and computation of the mechanism beyond the reach of current state-of-the-art techniques. We aim to develop a solution by carefully analyzing and leveraging ATL’s syntax and semantics. Our main contributions are summarized as follows: 1) We formally prove a representation lemma for ATL-based social laws: any valuation function that does not distinguish alternating bisimulation-equivalent structures [ 6 ] can be succinctly represented as a feature set, allowing us to formalize SLS as an auction design problem. 2) We identify that the critical obstacle from “multi-unit” settings is irregular payment calculation. We address this by designing an efficient polynomial-time reduction of payment determination to allocation determination, making allocation the key problem to solve. 3) We finally prove that allocation determination is FP NP -complete, and then reduce it to ILP in polynomial time by successfully encoding ATL semantics into a set of ILP constraints. This offloads the computational intractability to highly mature ILP solvers, which are widely used for large-scale industrial problems. Since payment determination reduces to allocation determination in polynomial time, we obtain a mechanism that is truthful, individually rational, profit-maximizing, and efficiently computable with ILP solvers. Building on the above work, we propose a self-enforcing social law synthesis method that reliably optimizes expected profit in strategic environments. This paper can be seen as an attempt to introduce the methodology of algorithmic mechanism design into the traditional logic-based approach to artificial intelligence. We have obtained a framework that not only greatly improves the reliability and robustness of social laws, but also enriches the study of algorithmic mechanism design. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows: We start with some backgrounds on social laws and algorithmic mechanism design as well as the formal framework of our work. Next, we present an optimal social law auction and prove it maximizes the expected profit within all Bayesian-Nash incentive compatible and individual rational mechanisms, and try to figure out an efficient approach to compute the payment. Then, we prove that the proposed mechanism is computationally intractable and propose a ILP based algorithm for computing the proposed mechanism. Finally, we present some conclusions and introduce some interesting open problems for future study. 2 Related Work Our work in this paper can be seen as to solve optimal social law synthesizing problem in the strategic case, where the agents are rational in the sense of game theory and hold some private parameters, based on the methodology of Bayesian mechanism design [ 22 , 28 , 43 ] , where prior distributions of the private parameters are public information. So, our work mainly relates to social laws and algorithmic mechanism design. Since different logic systems can provide different semantic structures or symbolic languages, which can respectively model different kinds of mutiagent systems or specify different coordination objectives, trying to use different logics for multiagent systems and corresponding model checking technologies to implement social laws is an emphasized research subject in this area. For example, using simpler CTL language to specify coordination objectives to simplify the theoretical framework of van der Hoek [ 54 ] can obtain some further theoretical results [ 5 , 4 , 2 , 1 ] . Using Alternating-time Temporal Epistemic Logic (ATEL) to specify coordination objectives can enable the agents to coordinate on “knowledge” [ 53 ] ; By specifically designing a new logic named Co-ATL, which put restrictions on the joint actions of agent coalitions instead of the actions of individual agents, can implement a social law which can modify the system more flexibly [ 61 , 56 ] . How to make autonomous agents consciously obey the constraints of social laws is also a basic issue that has been intensively discussed in this field. Since Shoham and Tennenholtz [ 50 , 51 ] proposed social laws, “all agents will unconditionally obey the