Efficient frequentist fractional polynomials for skewed dose–response and survival data: a variance-reducing alternative to OLS-FP
Serhii Zabolotnii ORCID · 2026
Read Efficient frequentist fractional polynomials for skewed dose–response and survival data: a variance-reducing alternative to OLS-FP by Serhii Zabolotnii ORCID (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16846.txt.
Introduction
Zabolotnii presents a frequentist option to least-squares fractional polynomials for skewed dose-response and survival. Fractional polynomials model nonlinear curves, but least-squares fitting falters with skewed or heavy-tailed errors, as with survival times and biomarkers. His replacement keeps the model but estimates coefficients with a moment score tuned to skewness and kurtosis, giving an efficiency gain. Across skewed errors, slope variance falls 10 to 20% for skew and up to 60% for heavy-tailed log-normal cases, with near-nominal coverage. On a breast-cancer cohort, tumor intervals narrow 26%.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Serhii Zabolotnii ORCID |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70779 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16846
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Efficient frequentist fractional polynomials for skewed dose–response and survival data: a variance-reducing alternative to OLS-FP Serhii Zabolotnii ORCID Abstract Fractional polynomials (FP) are a standard tool for modelling nonlinear dose–response and covariate effects, implemented in the widely used mfp package. The conventional FP fit estimates its coefficients by ordinary least squares (OLS-FP), which is statistically inefficient when the regression errors are skewed or heavy-tailed — a common situation for survival times, concentrations and biomarkers. We present a drop-in replacement that keeps the identical FP model and design but estimates the coefficients with a moment-based score tuned to the residual skewness and kurtosis, giving a closed-form efficiency factor g 2 = 1 − γ 3 2 / ( 2 + γ 4 ) g_{2}=1-\gamma_{3}^{2}/(2+\gamma_{4}) relative to OLS-FP. Across skewed error laws the method reduces slope-coefficient variance by 10–20% for mildly skewed errors and up to roughly 60% for heavy-tailed log-normal errors, at realistic sample sizes, while keeping confidence-interval coverage close to nominal, and it reverts exactly to OLS-FP under symmetry, so it is never harmful when no gain is available. On the German Breast Cancer Study Group cohort it narrows the tumour-size confidence interval by 26% (bootstrap variance ratio 0.53 0.53 against the predicted 0.56 0.56 ), and a primary-biliary- cirrhosis cohort reproduces the gain. The estimator is closed-form, runs in milliseconds, and is released as a reproducible R package ( pmm_fp in EstemPMM) with a one-command replication bundle; its core variance identity is machine-checked in Lean 4. Keywords: fractional polynomials; dose–response modelling; non-Gaussian errors; efficient estimation; variance reduction; reproducible research arXiv version note. This is a substantially revised and retitled version of arXiv:2605.16846v1-v2, which appeared under the title “Polynomial Maximization Method with Fractional Polynomial Basis: A Frequentist Bridge to Bayesian Fractional Polynomials”. The present version foregrounds the applied biostatistical contribution, adds the primary-biliary-cirrhosis confirmation, and moves extended proof sketches and formalisation details to the reproducibility supplement. 1 Introduction 1.1 Dose-response modelling and the role of fractional polynomials Modelling the dependence of a biological response on dose is a canonical task in biostatistics, toxicology, and pharmacometrics. Standard parametric families (Hill, Michaelis-Menten, Emax) work well when the mechanism is known a priori ( 13 ) , but in exploratory problems ( 6 ) the form R(\theta,x)=\mathbb{E}[y\mid x] is unknown and requires a flexible approximation. Fractional polynomials (FP) ( 14 ) provide such an approximation based on the basis P=\{-2,-1,-0.5,0,0.5,1,2,3\} with the convention x^{0}\equiv\ln x , encompassing classical parametric forms as special cases. The monograph of 15 and a methodological series in Statistics in Medicine ( 17 ) made FP the de facto standard in clinical statistics (R package mfp ). Classical FP inherits, however, two limitations of OLS: sensitivity to non-Gaussian errors and the absence of explicit modelling of the error distribution. 1.2 Limitations of OLS-FP and BFP under non-Gaussian errors In dose-response problems the errors \xi are typically non-Gaussian: log-normal (concentrations), gamma (time-to-event), beta (proportions). For such distributions, OLS-FP is consistent but loses 30 – 50\% efficiency for |\gamma_{3}|\geq 1 compared with an estimator that incorporates \gamma_{3},\gamma_{4} . 10 proposed a Bayesian version of FP ( BFP ) — power selection via MJMCMC in the space of 2^{K} subsets, continuing the line of 16 . However, BFP retains the Gaussian error model: for asymmetric \xi it inherits the inefficiency of OLS-FP, masked by posterior probabilities. The MJMCMC sampler is computationally expensive compared with a frequentist counterpart. Thus, OLS-FP and BFP leave a common gap open: efficient frequentist estimation under asymmetric errors, without either the distributional assumptions of OLS or MCMC machinery. We close this gap. 1.3 The Polynomial Maximization Method as a framework The Polynomial Maximization Method (PMM) ( 11 ) extends MLE to cases where only a finite sequence of moments is known. For y_{v}=R(\theta,X_{v})+\xi_{v} with \mathbb{E}[\xi_{v}]=0 , PMM-FP maximises the stochastic functional ( 21 , eq. (2)) : L_{SN}\;=\;\sum_{v=1}^{N}\sum_{i=1}^{S}\phi_{i}(y_{v})\int^{a}\!\!k_{iv}(a)\,da\;-\;\sum_{i=1}^{S}\sum_{v=1}^{N}\int^{a}\!\!\Psi_{iv}(a)\,k_{iv}(a)\,da, (1) where \phi_{i} are basis functions, \Psi_{iv}(a)=\mathbb{E}[\phi_{i}(y_{v})] , and k_{iv} are chosen variationally. The classical choice \phi_{i}(y)=y^{i} , S=2 ( 23 ; 24 ; 21 ; 25 ) with y_{v}-a=\xi_{v} yields the second-order variance coefficient in ( 15 ) ( 21 , eq. (27)) . For the integer basis, location equivariance guarantees that the y -basis and \xi -basis yield the same g_{2} ( 11 , ch. 4) . The Royston-Altman fractional basis introduces two parallel extensions into ( 1 ): regressor extension ( R(\theta,x)=\beta_{0}+\sum_{k}\beta_{k}\,x^{p_{k}} ) and extension of the score-function basis ( \{\xi,\xi^{2}\}\to\{g_{p_{1}}(\xi),\ldots,g_{p_{K}}(\xi)\} ). PMM-FP is the joint application of both. We use Form B (score-function on the residual, 11 , ch. 4 ) with R -independent \{g_{p}(\xi)\} and scalar g_{S} . The estimator therefore reuses the exact FP model an analyst would already build with mfp ; only the coefficient-fitting step changes, so it slots into an existing dose–response workflow without re-specifying the model. The technical question of correctly defining \xi^{p} for sign-changing \xi is resolved through the signed-parity convention (B2) in § 3.1 . 1.4 Contributions and outline We make three contributions, all oriented to applied use: (1) an efficiency gain over the standard OLS-FP/ mfp workflow under skewed or heavy-tailed errors — on the same selected FP model, the moment-based fit lowers slope-coefficient variance by the closed-form factor g_{2}=1-\gamma_{3}^{2}/(2+\gamma_{4}) (from 10–20% for mildly skewed errors to about 60% for log-normal errors), quantified as a function of sample size and reverting exactly to OLS-FP when the errors are symmetric, so that it is never harmful; (2) a fast, reproducible implementation — the estimator is closed-form and runs in milliseconds; it is released as the pmm_fp function in the R package EstemPMM, with a one-command bundle that regenerates every table and figure in this paper; (3) honest efficiency positioning and a usable admissibility rule — the estimator sits a definite, quantified margin above the semiparametric Cramér–Rao bound (it does not claim semiparametric efficiency), and we give a simple rule, condition BD0, for when negative fractional powers are statistically admissible. The default uses the positive-power basis \mathcal{P}_{a}=\{0,0.5,1,2,3\} under \mathbb{E}[\xi^{4}]<\infty ; the full Royston–Altman set \mathcal{P}_{b}=\{-2,-1,-0.5,0,0.5,1,2,3\} that 10 also use requires BD0 ( \mathbb{E}[|\xi|^{-2}]<\infty ), which fails for standard error laws, so it is reported only as a conditioning diagnostic (§ 3 ). The core variance identity is machine-checked in Lean 4 (supplement). Outline. § 2 — background, related literature, and positioning; § 3 — theoretical PMM-FP score, assumptions and T_{1} – T_{4} ; § 4 — the PMM-FP estimator and numerical implementation; § 5 — simulation comparison and the GBSG application; § 6 — discussion; § 7 — conclusions. Supplementary material covers extended Lean cross-references and proofs. 2 Background, related literature, and positioning PMM-FP sits at the intersection of three methodological strands: fractional-polynomial model building, Bayesian model averaging over FP bases, and Kunchenko’s moment-based Polynomial Maximization Method. This section reviews those strands once, then positions the proposed estimator relative to neighbouring estimating-equation, robust, and reproducible-modelling literatures. 2.1 Fractional-polynomial model building Fractional polynomials were introduced by 14 as a parsimonious alternative to splines for modelling smooth nonlinear effects of continuous covariates in biostatistics. The standard finite power set is \mathcal{P}_{\text{full}}\;=\;\{-2,\;-1,\;-0.5,\;0,\;0.5,\;1,\;2,\;3\}, (2) with x^{0}\equiv\log x . For x>0 , an FP model of degree m is \mathrm{FP}_{m}(x;\beta,p)\;=\;\beta_{0}\;+\;\sum_{i=1}^{m}\beta_{i}x^{p_{i}},\qquad p_{i}\in\mathcal{P}_{\text{full}}, (3) with repeated powers represented by \beta_{i}x^{p}+\beta_{i+1}x^{p}\log x . The practical success of